correct me i am wrong.

there are a few things in Cloverfield which i am quite puzzled about.


1. in the subway where the idiots walking in the dark, from the cam view, one of the guy in white shirt has a triangle patch behind his shirt due to sweat and dirt. If you watch closely, the patch disappeared n reappeared a few times during scenes change.


2. when they climbed the building to go over to the broken building, it says 57th floor. it each floor has 20 steps , which means there are 1140 steps the way up. Seeing your city being terrorized by a monster, you should be abit shaky or scared. By all means, those ppl are running for quite some time before reaching that building. they shud be dead tired, and yet they climbed entire 57 floors ?! moreover, they climbed to the next door, where the floor is not even. fetched the girl and descend down 57 floors. The monsted were quite near at that time. Physically, possible ?

3. in the end, the monster bite the guy, the guy is dead, and yet they want the videocam , c'mon. i will just run, forgot about the stupid videocam!

4. the monster cannot be killed, US president issued hammer down aka Nuke. Nuke is highly radioactive.
Those 2 idiots who ran under the bridge to hide cannot be far from where the monster are since the gal is injured.
So if there were a Nuke, do you think the videocam will still be there ? why did i say that? the moment you watch the film, it say something like top secret US government crap.... so is there a nuke ?



am i rite or wrong?

add if you have some things to add

whats d point of creating another thread?its been discussed in cloverfield's thread before...

wtf, another cloverfield bashing retard, grow some brains already!, there's already an existing thread, read it up!

What the? What is this? Another one? How many Cloverfield threads are there now?

Just to answer your questions before this thread is close, here are your answers:-

1). You must be able to noticed so highly from all the shakes and dizziness to be able to see it. How about one of the most common answer of all - Hollywood Blunder.

2). Dead tired or not, have you heard of adrenaline? It pumps a person energy to move on. There are some people that can run for days and rest only like an hour or so... this is only 7 hours and they did rest in the subway, remember?

3). I guess you miss "People will want to see this... how it all went down...". When World Trade Center collapse, people still stand around and film using their recorders. And some are approximately very near to the building even when they film it.

4). Nobody said Nuke even... nobody even say if it is a Nuke. Hammerdown is a codename. Go figure. Furthermore, that is a blunder. The cam recorder have fall down so many times (even survive a helicopter crash!) and yet can survive... which is worst:- helicopter crash or a bridge collapse?

I hope no more questions even... if you want your answers, just wait for the DVD version to be release sometime this year, and listen to the commentary by the creators.

This post has been edited by hairyLGS: Jan 29 2008, 12:35 PM

It's a crappy storyline, there're tons of unanswerable question. Those human behaviour and reaction is so fake in this movie.

This post has been edited by paco: Jan 29 2008, 02:18 PM

Seriously, Movies are just entertainment...
Watch it and get over with it...

Well, those pro-Cloverfield fans said it's not a movie, it's a documentary which is so real.

This post has been edited by paco: Jan 29 2008, 02:28 PM

I am not a fan... like the movie, seen the details... but that doesn't mean watching 3 times I'm a fan... because I missed so many parts...

wakakaka...I knew this movie would be such a disappointment

[Error Review] Cloverfield


You should not have watched this film. You should have watched...er... Rambo.

Also, why the heck did you open a new thread? Is it necessary?

entertainment. read it and weep. not happy with it? GO MAKE YOUR OWN MOVIE!

This post has been edited by cocklea: Jan 29 2008, 06:14 PM

nuff said

Go watch Garfield

I like the fact that someone's pointing out logical errors in a show about a huge freakin monster tearing up New York...

lmao. logical.

i lol'ed at this.

he ask so banyak question bout logic, why not ask bout the monster.

mod close tis

You know Superman?!?!? Oh... I'm feeling this... do you know Garfield?

chuckle...

kau tak suka kau keluar dari... $#$%#*%$*^&%#$#^&$%#$%#