Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Low cost flat vs high rental condo.

views
     
guy3288
post May 10 2026, 01:26 PM
G
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
6,136 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
Male
For those who don't believe low end properties
can beat EPF ....here is real life example



Attached thumbnail(s)
Attached Image
TSsamftrmd
post May 10 2026, 01:58 PM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(guy3288 @ May 10 2026, 01:26 PM)
For those who don't believe low end properties
can beat EPF ....here is real life example
*
Got people don't believe meh?
But from copilot's calculation, in 20 years time, epf can out perform my 200k flat with 700 rental.

QUOTE
Let’s compare RM200,000 invested in EPF vs RM200,000 in a rental property generating RM730/month. 

---

πŸ“Š Scenario 1: EPF (Compounding at 5.5%)
- Formula: \(200,000 \times (1.055)^5\) 
- Value after 5 years β‰ˆ RM259,000 
- Total gain β‰ˆ RM59,000 

---

πŸ“Š Scenario 2: Rental Property
- Monthly rental income = RM730 
- Annual rental income = RM730 Γ— 12 = RM8,760 
- Over 5 years = RM8,760 Γ— 5 = RM43,800 
- Property value appreciation (assuming 3% per year): 
  \[
  200,000 \times (1.03)^5 \approx 231,900
  \] 
- Total value = RM231,900 + RM43,800 = RM275,700 

---

βš–οΈ Comparison
Investment Capital After 5 Years Income Total Value
--------------------------------------------------------
EPF RM259,000 reinvested dividends RM259,000
Rental Property RM231,900 RM43,800 rental cash RM275,700

---

πŸ”‘ Insights
- Rental wins slightly (RM275k vs RM259k) if property appreciates at ~3% annually. 
- EPF is safer: government-backed, liquid, no tenant risk. 
- Rental has risks: vacancy, maintenance, market downturns β€” but offers cash flow (RM730/month) which EPF doesn’t. 
- Over longer horizons (10–20 years), EPF compounding can catch up or surpass rental if property appreciation slows. 
Wedchar2912
post May 10 2026, 02:35 PM
W
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,170 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 10 2026, 01:58 PM)
Got people don't believe meh?
But from copilot's calculation, in 20 years time, epf can out perform my 200k flat with 700 rental.
*
u forgot to include expenses and headaches dealing with tenants?

but like what many others said... good luck and use it as a great learning experience...
(unless u r lucky like some that have family members doing work for free to manage such apartments... lol)
GOPI56
post May 10 2026, 02:40 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,509 posts

Joined: Dec 2012
If me, I would put that cash in KWSP, etc instead of buying investment property.

Property game is not same like those days.
guy3288
post May 10 2026, 02:45 PM
G
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
6,136 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
Male
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 10 2026, 01:58 PM)
Got people don't believe meh?
But from copilot's calculation, in 20 years time, epf can out perform my 200k flat with 700 rental.
*
Bro your maths is faulty.

1 . You compare a nett rental return of 4.4% against EPF 5.5%
Your property at a disadvantage already...


2. Returns from EPF you keep and compound them ,
Return from monthly rental you just keep under your pillow??
taking away it's compounding effect for 20 years!!

Mathematically speaking that is a fatal error
Irredeemable

Because compounding it over 20 years makes a very big difference!

Is there any wonder your calculations gave you wrong results??

Just take any P from my sample above, check see if you put that same amount of money in EPF in 2012,

Now 14 years later how much would it be...

Wedchar2912
post May 10 2026, 02:50 PM
W
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,170 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(GOPI56 @ May 10 2026, 02:40 PM)
If me, I would put that cash in KWSP, etc instead of buying investment property.

Property game is not same like those days.
*
According to TS, he already outright own the place. worth 200K (assuming he sells it), but rental is at [edit: it is below] less than 800rm. so the gross yield is not even 5% pa. EPF does appear superior just based on updated gross numbers.
hope he really analyse rationally and properly... the yield comparison is vs current worth of the property, not vs original price of 70K.

This post has been edited by Wedchar2912: May 10 2026, 02:52 PM
guy3288
post May 10 2026, 02:55 PM
G
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
6,136 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
Male
QUOTE(Wedchar2912 @ May 10 2026, 02:35 PM)

(unless u r lucky like some that have family members doing work for free to manage such apartments... lol)
*
Lucky also must sek Cho la.....every property my agent bought I gave him 2k, taking care of the repairs and rentals
I pay 1 k a month, sell 1 prop I gave another 2 -5k...

I lent money for him to buy his 10 units at zero interest and there are all around same areas so not much extra work
Every year AP rm2-3k, plus free hotel stay and dinner for all family members at CNY gathering, past umpteen years....
TSsamftrmd
post May 10 2026, 04:25 PM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(Wedchar2912 @ May 10 2026, 02:35 PM)
u forgot to include expenses and headaches dealing with tenants?

but like what many others said... good luck and use it as a great learning experience...
(unless u r lucky like some that have family members doing work for free to manage such apartments... lol)
*
I kind of lucky to have tenants who always pay on time. The first tenant is a Arab lecturer that is the worst. Although he pay on time, but he drill lots of hole on the wall and saw off the windows bars to install aircon.
After that, the rest of my tenants are all OK. I rented to Malay, Indian, and Indon.
guy3288
post May 11 2026, 07:58 AM
G
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
6,136 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
Male
QUOTE(Wedchar2912 @ May 10 2026, 02:50 PM)
According to TS, he already outright own the place. worth 200K (assuming he sells it), but rental is at [edit: it is below] less than 800rm. so the gross yield is not even 5% pa. EPF does appear superior just based on updated gross numbers.
hope he really analyse rationally and properly... the yield comparison is vs current worth of the property, not vs original price of 70K.
*

Factually speaking, to ask which is better, property vs EPF.

I would go by facts rather than speculation...

1. Fact is what has been shown happening so far. past 10-20 years..... no speculation no predictions.....


2. Speculation is trying to predict the future 10-20 years...


What makes you think things would go drastically bad for property and EPF dividend will keep going same ??

If you have good stocks in hand why you think it is better to sell and convert to EPF......?


gashout
post May 12 2026, 09:41 AM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,826 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 10 2026, 04:25 PM)
I kind of lucky to have tenants who always pay on time. The first tenant is a Arab lecturer that is the worst. Although he pay on time, but he drill lots of hole on the wall and saw off the windows bars to install aircon.
After that, the rest of my tenants are all OK. I rented to Malay, Indian, and Indon.
*
so after write so much, what is your decision?
TSsamftrmd
post May 12 2026, 04:01 PM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(gashout @ May 12 2026, 09:41 AM)
so after write so much, what is your decision?
*
My initial plan is to buy a life condo for my parents, but the suitable location that my parents prefer and condition that satisfy me (dual key to rent out) would cost both my own stay and rental unit and still short a couple of hundred k. So that's out of the picture for now.
Then I thought about my age, in less than 10 years I'll be able to withdraw from epf, might as well sell the rental unit and transfer it to my epf. But the I'll lost the current rental income that I give all to my father as his own expenses.
So, I'm thinking to maintain as is so my father can collect rent. Plus, I'm waiting for the lawfirm to get my house grant. Expect to wait for some time, so I'm not in a rush to sell at the moment.
gashout
post May 13 2026, 05:22 AM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,826 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 12 2026, 04:01 PM)
My initial plan is to buy a life condo for my parents, but the suitable location that my parents prefer and condition that satisfy me (dual key to rent out) would cost both my own stay and rental unit and still short a couple of hundred k. So that's out of the picture for now.
Then I thought about my age, in less than 10 years I'll be able to withdraw from epf, might as well sell the rental unit and transfer it to my epf. But the I'll lost the current rental income that I give all to my father as his own expenses.
So, I'm thinking to maintain as is so my father can collect rent. Plus, I'm waiting for the lawfirm to get my house grant. Expect to wait for some time, so I'm not in a rush to sell at the moment.
*
parents, old age, condo, don't mix well

social life, mobility, health access.... better landed... we will see more old age living in condo and im not fond of this situation
TSsamftrmd
post May 13 2026, 07:10 AM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(gashout @ May 13 2026, 05:22 AM)
parents, old age, condo, don't mix well

social life, mobility, health access.... better landed... we will see more old age living in condo and im not fond of this situation
*
Condo got lift, got maintenance. Landed much more expensive and need to maintain. Less security.
guy3288
post May 13 2026, 07:37 AM
G
Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
6,136 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
Male
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 13 2026, 07:10 AM)
Condo got lift, got maintenance. Landed much more expensive and need to maintain. Less security.
*
Correct security is very good....for some like La Vista Condo....too good till couriers can't go up you got to come down to collect your parcels before man complained...

The down side is maintenance fee tm450 is madness for my parents don't use them at all .....in this sense I prefer landed ....
TSsamftrmd
post May 13 2026, 08:04 AM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(guy3288 @ May 13 2026, 07:37 AM)
Correct security is very good....for some like La Vista Condo....too good till couriers can't go up you got to come down to collect your parcels before man complained...

The down side is maintenance fee tm450 is madness for my parents don't use them at all .....in this sense I prefer landed ....
*
I'm not looking for one right now, but if I can afford to buy one, I intend to rent out the dual key and use it to cover the fees. Consider the facilities and security, I think the fee is reasonable. And I prefer to go down to collect delivery instead of stranger coming up in front of my door.
gashout
post May 13 2026, 12:09 PM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,826 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(samftrmd @ May 13 2026, 07:10 AM)
Condo got lift, got maintenance. Landed much more expensive and need to maintain. Less security.
*
the security is a plus plus point that landed cannot offer.


TSsamftrmd
post May 13 2026, 02:49 PM

Interface 2037
******
Senior Member
1,795 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Planet Earth
Male
QUOTE(gashout @ May 13 2026, 12:09 PM)
the security is a plus plus point that landed cannot offer.
*
Nowadays landed also got guarded sucurity. But the price will be premium lar.

 

Change to:
0.0171sec    1.18    9 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 19th May 2026 - 09:20 AM