Bamboo is good and nothing wrong with it. It's light, corrosion proof and cheap. When you see how people cook bamboo rice, we know thaat it's not easy to burn. The problem that cause the fire is the netting (not self extinguish material) and polystyrene (easily catch fire).
Bamboo for cooking is green 1. The scaffolding is dried 1. Got different 1 le…
Debate & Pressure to Ban Some experts — e.g. from the Hong Kong Institution of Engineers (HKIE) — have publicly argued for a ban, citing difficulties in uniformly assessing safety of bamboo scaffolding (variability of bamboo, weather vulnerability, higher risk over long-term use). RTHK News
Others — notably workers’ unions — oppose a ban, arguing that many accidents stem from poor workplace management rather than bamboo itself. They warn a ban could threaten thousands of jobs.
PS: They rather listen to a bunch of lowly educated contractor worker union than the highly educated & trained Institution of Engineers?
They need safety officer trained by DUPONT to supervise & advise. I would have banned the bamboo & ensure the netting is fire retardant.
Unironically if that's the standard approved configuration in HK guideline then the highest authority is the one at fault. The inspecting officer is just ticking boxes on site according to that.
Debate & Pressure to Ban Some experts — e.g. from the Hong Kong Institution of Engineers (HKIE) — have publicly argued for a ban, citing difficulties in uniformly assessing safety of bamboo scaffolding (variability of bamboo, weather vulnerability, higher risk over long-term use). RTHK News
Others — notably workers’ unions — oppose a ban, arguing that many accidents stem from poor workplace management rather than bamboo itself. They warn a ban could threaten thousands of jobs.
PS: They rather listen to a bunch of lowly educated contractor worker union than the highly educated & trained Institution of Engineers?
I learned from socmed and youtube that, earlier this year, HK authorities ruled that half of the scaffoldings have to be made from metal.
They already knew the risk - no just fire, but other risks, e.g. not as sturdy as metal.
They need safety officer trained by DUPONT to supervise & advise. I would have banned the bamboo & ensure the netting is fire retardant.
As per the video I posted, it’s alleged that many HK contractors may have ignore the requirements for fire retardant netting becoz such netting cannot be reused. Fire retardant netting will become fragile under sun whilst normal netting can be reused multiple times.
- 55 people, including a firefighter, have died. Fifty one were found dead at the scene.
- As of 2.30pm, 76 people are in hospital – 15 in critical condition, 28 deemed serious
- Full-scale rescue work is ongoing, with a woman, an elderly man and pets evacuated from buildings
- The eight residential blocks in the estate had been undergoing renovations since July 2024, sheathed in bamboo scaffolding and green mesh
Wat!!! Under renovations???!!! When I see the scaffoldings and green nettings, in yesterday's news, I thought the buildings were still under construction. 😵💫😵💫😵💫
"About 280 are still unaccounted for and rescue work continues amid flames now retreating onto the upper floors of three of the residential blocks."
This post has been edited by ScooterBoi: Nov 27 2025, 04:04 PM