MyKiosk Madani dikritik, kos RM34,660 seunit dipersoal

Projek MyKiosk Madani di bawah Kementerian Pembangunan Kerajaan Tempatan (KPKT) kini menjadi perhatian ramai selepas kos pembinaannya didakwa tidak masuk akal, dengan setiap unit mencecah sehingga RM34,660.

Menteri KPKT, Nga Kor Ming sebelum ini menyatakan bahawa kos satu kiosk hanya sekitar RM25,000. Namun, berdasarkan maklumat daripada KPKT, RM250 juta telah dibelanjakan bagi membina 7,213 unit kiosk, purata kos sebenar setiap satu sebenarnya mencecah RM34,660. Perkara ini mencetuskan persoalan hangat dalam kalangan rakyat, termasuk kritikan tajam di media sosial.

Rata-rata netizen mempersoalkan bagaimana struktur sekecil itu boleh menelan belanja sedemikian, malah ada yang menyindir kiosk berkenaan mungkin diperbuat daripada emas.

Kurang mendapat sambutan

Lebih memburukkan keadaan, MyKiosk dilaporkan kurang mendapat sambutan daripada peniaga tempatan. Antara rungutan yang diterima adalah lokasi kiosk yang dikatakan tidak strategik dan jauh dari kawasan tumpuan orang ramai. Malah, ada yang menyatakan mereka lebih memilih untuk kekal berniaga di tapak asal kerana aliran pelanggan yang lebih baik.

Peniaga juga mendakwa terpaksa menanggung kos permulaan sebanyak RM710 bagi menyewa kiosk tersebut, termasuk deposit, sewa bulan pertama, yuran pendaftaran dan lesen perniagaan. Ini dilihat sebagai satu beban tambahan kepada usahawan kecil yang cuba bangkit selepas pandemik.

Selain itu, reka bentuk kiosk turut menjadi bahan kritikan. Peniaga mengadu ruang dalamannya terlalu panas ketika cuaca terik dan mudah dimasuki air ketika hujan. Reka bentuk yang dikatakan ‘tidak praktikal’ ini menimbulkan persoalan mengenai kualiti serta keperluan sebenar projek tersebut.

Perbandingan turut dibuat dengan projek perumahan rakyat (PPR) di bawah kerajaan terdahulu. Ketika era pentadbiran Najib Razak, kerajaan mampu membina rumah PPR pada harga antara RM30,000 hingga RM40,500 sebuah — lengkap dengan bilik, tandas dan kemudahan asas. Justeru, timbul pertanyaan mengapa sebuah kiosk bersaiz kecil boleh menelan belanja hampir sama.

Dalam pada itu, Menteri Nga menafikan dakwaan bahawa MyKiosk merupakan projek gajah putih. Bagaimanapun, ramai pihak kekal skeptikal, melihat projek ini sebagai satu lagi contoh ketirisan dan pembaziran dana awam yang perlu disiasat lebih lanjut.

sos

I extend my home 10x20 ft for 40k

that piece of leaking junk is 34k. still no songlap meh

2x5 saja

mana reformasi pundek

ptui

that's why when nurul say reformasi still ongoing, ppl smiled

Ninamafuki songlap kaw kaw oh.

Anthony loke must resign now

TL;DR
What are these kiosks for?

For doing business.

But I hope the Kiosk can be converted to Homeless Shelter.

ini bahagian nga kor ming punya. he need to explain

wait,i ask quotation for mine 2ft x 20ft 30k
but with pillar la

at the end didn't go for it.

Pasar malam or wat? No tandas facility? Cannot sewa? Where?

If I can afford RM35K, won’t trade on d street..

This post has been edited by TiramisuCoffee: May 14 2025, 11:39 AM

Langsung tak pernah nampak this kiosk. Mau rent support pun tak boleh.

Why they smile? They support her reformasi?

The location can be 50-50. Some places I see memang no people, but other places literally gerai tepi jalan buka just besides those kiosk.

Breakdown on the RM710 initial cost (based on Lim Siam See punya post):
RM150 rent
RM450 deposit
RM50 agreement
RM60 business license

No comment if quality really that shitty it either cooks you inside or it leaks (what's the point of having that kind of enclosure lol). Haven't really seen much kiosk utilized near my place tbh.

Menteri KPKT, Nga Kor Ming sebelum ini menyatakan bahawa kos satu kiosk hanya sekitar RM25,000. Namun, berdasarkan maklumat daripada KPKT, RM250 juta telah dibelanjakan bagi membina 7,213 unit kiosk, purata kos sebenar setiap satu sebenarnya mencecah RM34,660. Perkara ini mencetuskan persoalan hangat dalam kalangan rakyat, termasuk kritikan tajam di media sosial.

Why huh?

but but but macai say DAP minister all squeaky clean won't songlap one

Sampah product

I have seen this kiosk everywhere in Shah Ale for the past 4-5 months. And it has always been empty since. When are they actually going to lease it out?

it's better to buy/rent a food truck instead of this garbage, it's more practical and the mobility means you can always switch locations to somewhere with more crowd at different times of the day

Actuali many abandoned buildings can b converted… nonit waste money.. in EU they convert old shopping malls shops into tiny flats…every1 needs a roof over their head.

Sakau as long u can

How much food truck cost?

Remove Cokk Ming

https://dollarsandsense.my/how-much-does-it...ss-in-malaysia/

Also the cost being 34k is farked up, see what I can get in FB marketplace.



Not like these Madani kiosks come with water / electricity supply for tapping either.

Then cronies,, opps I mean strategic alliance partners makan apa? Makan pasir ? 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

that figure... better go for food truck.

Rokek songlap

#BebasNajib
#NajibForPMXI

Don’t ask, can or not? This one has been thought out very well by Madani Gov edi. Just spent 35k! You must have faith in what madani do la!

I suspect this is a pre-cursor to Ramadan tents in near future.

parkingggggggg

lol..i thought this is the vending machine.

of course la complain location not strategic, they want to be able to put it anywhere they like, kaki lima ke, tepi jalan ke. dont care about traffic.

Does not have to be so grand la. Just go to Krabi landmark night market. See how organised and clean it is. Just a simple structure saja. Minimal investment.

A check on popular marketplace platform Mudah, under Carousell, shows that used food trucks are available for rent from RM1,200 to RM2,200 per month. There are also second-hand food trucks that are available for purchase from RM12,800 to RM89,800 with engine capacities of 1.0 cc to 4.6 cc.

The most affordable food truck on the platform, priced at RM12,800, is a Japanese brand Suzuki truck released in 1992 or 1993. The medium-sized truck is sold in Kuching, Sarawak and has the equipment ready for business.

Meanwhile, there is a food truck priced at RM89,800 is from Japanese brand Isuzu and was bought in 2015 with a garnered mileage of 25,000 only. The 14-feet food truck comes with air-conditioning, power steering and relatively new green paint work.

For new vehicles, vehicle seller Papavan offers a new 1.3 cc engine truck for RM47,000. The new truck comes with a three-year warranty and is 8.5 feet long.


With that I think I rent or buy a 2nd hand food truck… I can change location, which area got crowd ..n resell my truck if I tutup biz..

This post has been edited by TiramisuCoffee: May 14 2025, 11:58 AM

inb4 subcon-5 sell 5k with profit a unit.

put robot to good use.. sure stuffy n hot like hell inside…

High class stall

if it involve earthwork and road tar then it is ok lah, but just a kiosk at walk way pun cost RM30k+ is a bit absurd

This salah dap

I dont use contractor, I find tukang rumah and they quoted 20k+ for the upah. barang I order myself and spend around 20k+ also. this does not include wiring tho.

engine capacities of 1.0 cc to 4.6 cc

must be a really tiny food truck

What to do with me, I'm just a number plate minister.

But not to protect or what. Maybe this is the cost of sub-sub-sub sales. You know, Malaysia has a very good culture of sub-sub-sub sales. Similar to LOW Y*T Plaza, the shop and kiosk sub sub sub still costs 10K per month for a tiny little kiosk, which is the same size as my house toilet. However the Bangladesh and Pakistan can rent the kiosk happily with the sale of gray area product .