Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Residensi Wilayah JSatin, Block C crack, structural failure

views
     
yuzhe28 P
post Nov 8 2024, 08:21 PM

New Member
*
Probation
1 posts

Joined: Mar 2021
[quote=thpace,Nov 8 2024, 06:06 PM]
architectural minmun,, a few worker to replaster or skim back again

Structural - maybe 200 to 300k
if your are the PSP/SP, your will be shitting brick right now on why it failed, your design loading issue or poor material which also fall your under part under the RE scope of works

if me, i rather quickly push for proper rectification rather than fault finding at this stage. Stabilize the structure, study the cause of failure, and rectification and carry on

the fault finding come later
it limited to one unit and more like sheer crack which indicated localized zone. plus the no severe concrete buckling seen on the sheer wall structure which could have indicatedtotal failure

repair is most likely rather than demolished whole block
*


You sounds like u are PEPC and practice like a layman contractor. How would u rectify a serious matter by this way???

Even an underpinning works would take weeks to redo all SI before come out with a rectification proposal.

U can blow like just a small case for u. 200-300k my ass bro.

Dont ever think you been into high rise project before. Just shit talker.

Mind to disclose ur professional registration number if u were registered to the board? Else u just talking shit

yuzhe28 P
post Nov 9 2024, 09:27 AM

New Member
*
Probation
1 posts

Joined: Mar 2021
QUOTE(goodiemangold @ Nov 9 2024, 09:14 AM)
From photo I really can't. So I do admire and amazed by your confident in quoting RM200k for repair. Coz I can't see the extent of damage, how many floors, what is affected, and doesn't even know the cause. No original drawings, no details, no BQ, no proposal or rectification details and yet you can figure out the cost of repair.
You're really a very experienced person with high technical and management knowledge with know-how of the in and outs of construction.

I do not understand how Sheer Wall design as I normally heard it them as Shear Walls. Would you be so kind hearted to enlightened us how "Sheer" Wall works? And how do you know the failure is from load bearing?
*
Bro no need to talk to this kind of person. I really interested who is he and which company he working or owner. So we can avoid giving him any job.

He can speculate all the design without looking at design calc and talk. Can confirm he is not a practising engineer.

Giving all these crap and misleading the public. What a failure.
yuzhe28 P
post Nov 11 2024, 01:04 PM

New Member
*
Probation
1 posts

Joined: Mar 2021
QUOTE(Haru97 @ Nov 11 2024, 09:56 AM)
Got a yellow profile pic guy say this is sapsap water aje, downplaying the issue, offering 200k to fix the issue.
In cases like this we want to UPPLAY instead of downplayying the issue, scare tactic works cause people lifes is at stake.
Over the weekend when I yamcha with my friend who is an actual building engineer,
they say cannot save d this building. Once ground floor start crack it will pull all the way to from ground floor upper floors, no doubt about it.

If they want save other blocks, they can try to seperate the carpark into sections, cut out the failed buiding AND failed shared columns to try and save other blocks.
But doing so would require an intense assessment of whether the other columns can hold the extra weight or stress when the failed ones is seperated, I highly doubt the technology and expertise we had
in malaysia. They would require to cut the concrete, etc to seperate the shared column and building.

Jacking it up is NOT A VIABLE OPTION in this case anymore, SHOULD NOT put into consideration.
Not to mention, "skim back" / "plastering" / "reinforcing failed column" is also NOT AN OPTION.

Just like a plastic pen, when u snap it, you could try to hotglue it back to a usable state where you can still use it to write,
but it will no longer has the previous hardness, and a slight bit of force or squeeze could deform it.
Same like concrete columns, when cracked or snapped or deformed, reinforcing from the outside it is just hotglueing it to make it looks more stable,
doesnt mean that it could withstand earthquakes or slightest bit of ground movement due to nearby construction.
*
I replied him he said i have no experience wor? Hehehe

There is another guy also supporting him and challenged my comments.

Really hope both of this guy reveal their company. Lets see who they are. Hehehe
yuzhe28 P
post Nov 11 2024, 01:07 PM

New Member
*
Probation
1 posts

Joined: Mar 2021
QUOTE(Raddus @ Nov 9 2024, 05:41 PM)
how much developer pay you to come post this
*
Read my comment carefully bro. Im against this fella 200k rectification proposal without any ground investigation and throwing these rubbish proposal.

Its not as easy as any crackline and grouting.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0219sec    0.35    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 16th December 2025 - 07:04 AM