Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Residensi Wilayah JSatin, Block C crack, structural failure

views
     
goodiemangold
post Nov 7 2024, 11:24 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Aug 2016
QUOTE(ihm11 @ Nov 7 2024, 09:46 PM)
songlap lah the rebar inside

column/beam supposed to have 10x15mm rebars inside end up 6x10mm oni
*
Mana ada 15mm rebars in the market? LOL
goodiemangold
post Nov 9 2024, 07:17 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Aug 2016
QUOTE(thpace @ Nov 8 2024, 06:06 PM)
architectural minmun,, a few worker to replaster or skim back again

Structural - maybe 200 to 300k
if your are the PSP/SP, your will be shitting brick right now on why it failed, your design loading issue or poor material which also fall your under part under the RE scope of works

if me, i rather quickly push for proper rectification rather than fault finding at this stage. Stabilize the structure, study the cause of failure, and rectification and carry on

the fault finding come later
it limited to one unit and more like sheer crack which indicated localized zone. plus the no severe concrete buckling seen on the sheer wall structure which could have indicatedtotal failure

repair is most likely rather than demolished whole block
*
How to estimate 200~300k basing on just photos and videos without knowing the reason or even cause?

Why is PSP and not only SP coz this is under structural if it's design loading and material as what you mentioned? Why design issue also fall under RE scope?

If it's you, you will rectify first. But how do you know the people are not rectifying first?

What is sheer crack? Why isn't it Shear crack?
And if it's Shear crack, how does the wall fail in shear when bending and compression is always the most critical force instead of shear?
goodiemangold
post Nov 9 2024, 09:14 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Aug 2016
QUOTE(thpace @ Nov 9 2024, 08:37 AM)
from the photo, you cant determine the cause? maybe u need more experience

why PSP? again u need more experience. Hint, who ultimately sign the borang F? PSP or SP?

why not RE scope? if material quality issue, it fall under the RE for his quality inspection prior to casting same goes for the BRC inspection if it not accordance to design

do u understand what is a sheer wall design compare to column and beam design? how does it work and how it load bearing principle is?
*
From photo I really can't. So I do admire and amazed by your confident in quoting RM200k for repair. Coz I can't see the extent of damage, how many floors, what is affected, and doesn't even know the cause. No original drawings, no details, no BQ, no proposal or rectification details and yet you can figure out the cost of repair.
You're really a very experienced person with high technical and management knowledge with know-how of the in and outs of construction.

I do not understand how Sheer Wall design as I normally heard it them as Shear Walls. Would you be so kind hearted to enlightened us how "Sheer" Wall works? And how do you know the failure is from load bearing?
goodiemangold
post Nov 11 2024, 01:48 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Aug 2016
QUOTE(vexus @ Nov 11 2024, 11:43 AM)
Soe consult many big project development in hand. The problem lies to the COW on site. Someone sleeping there.
Or some smart alex developer play value engineering on design changes. 😂
*
Website says they are only setup in 2019?
Isn't that considered a newly formed company especially an engineering consultancy 🤔

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0340sec    0.72    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 12th December 2025 - 01:09 PM