QUOTE(SportyHandling @ Sep 29 2024, 09:10 AM)
I usually listen to instrumental music, no vocals. Clarity, separation between instruments, refined and extended treble and taut defined or textured bass are the priority. Dislike boomy bloated bass of some systems where cheap thump thump bass overpowers everything.
QUOTE(SportyHandling @ Sep 30 2024, 07:50 AM)
Yes, that's what most of them who dislike Focal home audio speakers say, too much treble.
I have close preference as you (not sure similar, but at least close).
I like vocal clarity, at the same time I like instruments separation from the vocal and each others.
I'm after the female vocal at the tail end a little of subtle transpose, to tiny bit of "wooden sand shakers" (not sure what's actual name), that usually lost, at the same time like the 90's pop.
For bass, I'm obsessive with 1 beat is 1 beat. 2 beats, must not be muffled together like some poor quality woofer (or just the stupid DSP poor TruBase effect).
Here's why I choose B&W Panorama 3 over Bose 900, Sonos Arc, how it compares with HK in my car.
Sony HTA7000 is out as soon as I listen it for first time. Honorable mention Samsung 990
pros
- the built-in dual Subwoofer is actually best at 40hz range, that's woofer for my standard
- real woofer vs others that use full range speakers for 40hz range, they have no real woofer. + Sonos/Bose when add Subwoofer is for 20hz, the 90's pop beat is not as crisp
- B&W DSP on the vocal signature I'm after
- 90's pop the drum beats are exactly per my teenager memory. Clear and crisp.
cons
- not real subwoofer at 20hz range (and can't add one). Watch movie with explosion, bass is near dead.
- limited DSP processing power. Watch movie with very busy scene or hard rock, certain Anime songs, the separation quality degraded.
- can't add satellite speakers.
If I'm not after the vocal signature or priorities movies, Samsung 990 is the best bang of the buck all rounder.
Both Bose 900, Sonos Arc are both better option than B&W if one watch more movies.
Sony strong base, but the base quality not clean (or the shop messed up with the EQ). It is best example of technically best on spectrum analyzer, but not in real life.
So compared to my car HK, that has both actual woofer + subwooder + full range speakers + tweeters.
So it covers both 40hz + 20hz scenario. Separation is better than the Panorama 3, again especially busy sounds combination.
My car EQ setting is actually on clarity that low base, high mid/treble + half TruBase for woofer + quarter TruBase for subwoofer, to find back the balance, vocal still stands out.In most other (low cost) systems I experience, TruBase usually mess up the bass quality that cause them to be murky + muddy, lost the separation, best left off or just minimum.
Only thing HK lack is the vocal signature. But anyway Panorama 3 vocal is also synthetic by DSP, different from real high end B&W speakers hardware, lol. Real audiophiles probably laughing at me
This post has been edited by constant_weight: Sep 30 2024, 01:03 PM