Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Proton S70 discussion, Budget Volvo sedan

views
     
MyProLife
post Oct 24 2023, 10:31 AM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(RegentCid @ Oct 24 2023, 10:13 AM)
Future sure got Proton S90 ....that will be based on Volvo S80 / Emgrand chassis.
Currently S70 are same as Geely Borui / Volvo S60
*
I think s90 is possible will based on Preface sedan. Size close to vw passat. But in order to assembly this cma platform must do heavy retooling in tanjong malim plant so don't expect it to come soon in 2-3 years
MyProLife
post Nov 28 2023, 05:35 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

go to sleep if cannot do launch properly

chinamen always sucks in such like to drag so long
MyProLife
post Nov 28 2023, 05:44 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

user posted image
MyProLife
post Nov 28 2023, 05:44 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

lower than expected kek
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 05:45 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 05:36 PM)
Another thing that i think you maybe overlooked...

Geely have their own BMA (B-segment Modular Architecture) platform.....

This BMA is B-Segment platform...

and they apply this BMA in Geely Emgrand....but the wheelbase is 2650mm not 2627mm in proton s70...

https://global.geely.com/en/models/emgrand

Unker also check the proton S70 brochure....proton didn't specifically mentioned they use BMA in S70...

So unker think proton S70 probably not built on BMA platform...


Below is the BMA platform....

user posted image
user posted image
Below is the PROTON S70 platform...

user posted image
Quite huge different
*
From sources emgrand/s70 just piggyback on the name of BMA, actually still using FE platform aka modified from Toyota MC/old corolla platform


BMA is just the fancy name of FE platform that have been used since 2009 on geely emgrand ec7 (1st gen)
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 05:57 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 05:46 PM)
don't understand what you trying to say...is better if you could further elaborate...
*
If know Chinese and do some research on x50 (BMA) aka binyue as well as others platform mates binrui etc, actually you can see that BMA platform is a bit sus one.

BMA is just blanket for geely 3.0 subcompact/compact models (2016-2020 era). BMA can also consist of older FE platform spiced up under BMA name like binrui sedan (that was originally the base for s70 before switching to emgrand 4th gen middle of development). Binrui sedan was also delayed in development cycle (suppose to launch around 2016 but ended up launched in 2018 just before binyue x50)

If you curious about FE platform. It was evolution of FC platform from 2006 (yuan Jin sedan , basically carbon copy of corolla Altis e120), then FE debuts in 2009 on original EC7 emgrand.
NL platform on boyue (1st gen) aka x70 was a development from geely gleagle gx7, which was RAV4 XA30 carbon copy . The sideways fuel tank layout was carried over to boyue aka x70
CV platform (jiaji, haoyue, x90) is yet another development from NL platform, basically stretched version of NL platform
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 06:21 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 06:15 PM)
Okay. Unker will go and read their chinese website for this info.
*
Yeah
Can start from auto home forum

https://club.m.autohome.com.cn/bbs/thread/7...57065086-1.html

Very spicy info on x70 origins
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 06:39 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 06:32 PM)

*
S70 dimensions seems shrink from emgrand. Some black magic or maybe either party faked the spec?

Impossible to see the localized version shrinking from OG version. It's more common for other way around (lengthen the dimensions is easier to do then shrinking)

How proton measures the dimensions actually until got different from donor car? Idk, black magic?
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 07:38 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 06:41 PM)
not the same platform lah wey.....like this also wonder meh.....don't be like that leh....

if S70 is using BMA....they will put it in S70 brochure edy....and promote kaw kaw...
*
In 2016 when geely partnership with proton (took over 49% stack) proton licensed 3 platforms from geely (NL, BMA and CV)

NL boyue is ended up as x70
BMA binyue is ended up as x50

However for larger 7 seater based on CV platform (x90) originally wanted to based on jiaji, but due to changing market conditions, proton swapped the base to haoyue middle of development


For the sedan that follows above 3 SUVs models, originally wanted to based on FE6/A06 binrui, but as I said also swapped the base to emgrand 4th gen due to various reasons. Binrui was found out not viable for LHD to RHD converting development as it was developed way before the geely-proton deal. Instead geely and proton opened yet another similar project to replace emgrand ec7 and preve of respective makes called SS11 that ended up as S70. Logically speaking, sharing same BMA platform with binyue/x50 is more efficient for SS11/S70 development and manufacturing. While SS11 for china was to be affordable entry sedan that directly replace both emgrand ec7 and yuanjing (corolla Altis clone), so different power train was being used for cost cutting measure (also no Adas and lower equipment level)

S70 for Malaysia was to eventually replace Preve that discontinued in 2020. So S70 undergone more localisation for ride and handling and made a bit more upmarket for equipment level. Yet to save costs it shares same power train with X50 (1.5 3g15t and dct) because localisation has been done for such power train.

Of course if already share the same power train, also more logical to share same BMA platform as X50 right ?

Why proton didn't say BMA so loudly? Well maybe their marketing decision is more to sell on value (price per performance) rather than selling technology that we already known since 2020 X50

https://www.automachi.com/2023/11/why-proto...t-geely-binrui/

Edit to add source and fix autocorrect typo

This post has been edited by MyProLife: Nov 30 2023, 07:45 PM
MyProLife
post Nov 30 2023, 10:26 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Nov 30 2023, 09:38 PM)
Thanks for sharing…indeed this is a good info…

Btw, do you know how geely reduce the JLH-3G15TD to JLH-3G15T?
*
just swap out direct injection parts with mature pfi parts. yeah still rnd need to be done but simple tasks relatively
MyProLife
post Dec 1 2023, 01:22 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(tonewow @ Dec 1 2023, 03:49 AM)
to those saying S70 = s60 rebadged....wrong la

its Preface...thats a proper c segment.

this s70 by right should be s50 = persona replacement = persona pricing top specs 65k only.

but because of the loophole B "+" , the plus sign being there proton took it and main belakang all of us. Raised the price raised the marketing.

And this is how you know all those pokimak influencers car reviewers are being bought, yes most of them sebab all kept promoting on socmed - "Kete C segmen harga B segment".

impossible they dont know about emgrand car segmentation and pricing in china which is way below 65k. so price it at persona pricing still tons of profit ok even with the so called uniquely malaysian only drivetrain version. still fat profit even after that!

kepala bapak ko la marketing cara yahudi!
*
preface is close to passat size already, CMA platform, too bad proton not yet license CMA yet

for reason why put ss11 positioning above persona, maybe persona still have some sellable lifespan despite quite old, can keep selling as bezza alternative
MyProLife
post Dec 1 2023, 04:07 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Dec 1 2023, 04:02 PM)
but if they use BMA platform, that should be directly under B-Segment catagory...no? Unker still no clue what Proton try to do....and they are actually wasting a lot of times....
*
In china sedans mostly starting with c segment entry. Vios or city no market at all in china, no replacement for those.

So emgrand in china also officially compared with entry c segment from rivals (JV and self brand) like Sylphy , VW Jetta etc.

Platform is still scale able . In china as long as longer than 2600 wheelbase already in C segment (A class in china or VW classification if you got confused)
MyProLife
post Dec 1 2023, 04:52 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(xiaojohn @ Dec 1 2023, 04:10 PM)
Bro...i think it is not me confused...it is GEELY confused...

So you are saying GEELY want to market BMA as C-Segment in Malaysia/ASEAN? to follow and align with their CHINA standard? Is that correct?
*
Correct, just that china version for both x90 and s70 are kinda down-market models (value oriented)

Malaysia version got upgraded trims and equipment because cannot sell too cheap, localisation rate not as high as perodua
MyProLife
post Dec 3 2023, 07:51 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(adam71 @ Dec 3 2023, 07:17 PM)
I think S70  & Volvo ( Red)  look 90% same

user posted image
*
Far from that although still inherited design DNA from Peter horbury

Proton is not that near Volvo despite same parent. Lol
MyProLife
post Dec 3 2023, 08:02 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(lurkingaround @ Dec 3 2023, 06:52 PM)
.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_X50
.... Marketed as a B-segment SUV, ...

Geely's BMA platform is likely referring to B-segment SUV, not B-segment Hatchbacks (<4m long). .......

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-segment_Mod...ecture_platform - B-segment Modular Architecture platform
.... Applications
Geely Binrui (A06) (2018–present)
Geely Binyue/Coolray/Proton X50 (SX11) (2018–present)
Geely Emgrand (SS11) (/Proton S70) (2021–present)/
Geely Icon (2020–present)
Lynk & Co 06 (2020–present) ...


https://www.timesnownews.com/auto/features/...rticle-93682238 - A B C D E and M: Different-car-segments-explained - 21 Aug 2022
.
*
Although the platform specifically says B segment platform but can also use for c segment as the platform wheelbase can be adjusted between 2550-2700
Just like daihatsu/perodua dnga B, can be between 2620 (vios ac100) till 2750 on veloz/alza


And another one which used B segment platform before on c segment sedan was nissan Sylphy G11 (quite spacious at that time because wheelbase stretch to 2700, but width quite narrow compared to Altis, civic at that time)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nissan_Sylphy
MyProLife
post Dec 3 2023, 11:06 PM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(plouffle0789 @ Dec 3 2023, 08:30 PM)
Engine is modified from geely and volvo sc40
*
Engine is derived from 2.0 4cylinder T5 but down to 3cylinder 1.5 on GEP3 version used by proton with GDI swapped with MPI so already stray away from Volvo original

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volvo_Engine_Architecture
MyProLife
post Dec 4 2023, 12:45 AM

I bully wumao & MPKL
*******
Senior Member
2,068 posts

Joined: Sep 2021
From: nowhere

QUOTE(spursfan @ Dec 4 2023, 12:09 AM)
let's just call it a tongsan b segment. technically correct, right?
*
In tongsan is called A segment (Açş§) actually for c segment classification because tongsan actually follows Volkswagen system (A0 = B seg, A = C seg, B = D seg, and so on)

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0584sec    0.33    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 1st December 2025 - 07:57 AM