XM2 more for comfort. PS 3 4 5 is best to meet your requirement.
Alternative option Goodyear F1 Asymmetric, or Toyo Proxes Sport (cheaper, more noisy)

Price, age and availability. Otherwise is always manufacturers claim of % improvement.
Personal experience, PS is the best goto consumer tyres for handling+ comfort+ less noise.
Also it is priced higher and wear out faster then GY F1.
Of late I turn to Toyo for budget consciousness.

I think PS dont have 16.