Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Chat Mount Kinabalu is the highest in South East Asia

views
     
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 03:24 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


There are definitely higher peaks in Myanmar and Indonesia

Myanmar
QUOTE
Above 5000 mEdit

Hkakabo Razi, 5,881 m (Highest point in Myanmar and in Southeast Asia)[1]

Gamlang Razi, 5,870 m

Peak 5710, 5,710 m[2]

Dindaw Razi, 5,464 m[3]

Peak 5412 m,5,411 m[3]

Peak 5310 m, 5,309 m[3]

Peak 5224 m, 5,223 m[3]

Peak 5219 m, 5,218 m[3]

Peak 5188 m, 5,187 m[3]

Peak 5127 m, 5,126 m[3]

Peak 5127 m, 5,126 m[3]

Peak 5111 m, 5,110 m[3]

Peak 5110 m, 5,109 m[3]

Tami Razi, 5,101 m[3]

Peak 5086 m, 5,085 m[3]

Peak 5081 m, 5,080 m[3]

Peak 5081 m, 5,080 m[3]

Peak 5027 m, 5,026 m[3]

Above 4000 mEdit

Peak 4974 m, 4,973 m[3]

Peak 4964 m, 4,963 m[3]

Peak 4954 m, 4,953 m[3]

Peak 4941 m, 4,940 m[3]

Peak 4890 m, 4,889 m[3]

Peak 4823 m, 4,822 m[3]

Tasudo Razi, 4,841 m[3]

Peak 4812 m, 4,811 m[3]

Peak 4775 m, 4,774 m[3]

Peak 4771 m, 4,770 m[3]

Peak 4694 m, 4,693 m[3]

Peak 4661 m, 4,660 m[3]

Peak 4648 m, 4,647 m[3]

Romaing Razi, 4,623 m[3]

Madoi Razi,[4] 4,616 m

Tani Razi, 4,580 m

Peak 4550 m, 4,549 m[3]

Peak 4510 m, 4,509 m[3]

Peak 4402 m, 4,401 m[3]

[[peak 4382 m]], 4,382 m[3]

Peak 4381 m, 4,381 m[3]

Phangran Razi, 4,328 m

Peak 4324 m, 4,323 m[3]

Noi Madwe, 4,319 m

Peak 4311 m, 4,310 m[3]

Phonyin Razi, 4,282 m

Peak 4271 m, 4,270 m[3]

Masinsang Razi, 4,269 m[3]

Tasnu Hpawng, 4,196 m[3]

Khambi Madin, 4,176 m[3]

shan feng, 4,140 m[3]

Peak 4031 m, 4,030 m[3]

Taungnyo Taung, 4,163 m



Indonesia
QUOTE
Highest Peaks

Puncak Jaya

4 884 m (prom: 4 884 m)

Sumantri

4 871 m (prom: 366 m)

Ngga Pulu

4 839 m (prom: 82 m)

Carstensz Timur

4 820 m (prom: 311 m)

Mandala

4 760 m (prom: 2 626 m)

Trikora

4 730 m (prom: 1 244 m)

Ngga Pilimsit

4 717 m (prom: 544 m)

Middenspits

4 698 m (prom: 56 m)

Gunung Speelman

4 540 m (prom: 722 m)

Wachter

4 529 m (prom: 176 m)



For reference Kinabalu is only 4095m. There are plenty of unnamed peaks in Myanmar much taller than that

This post has been edited by nobrainer86: Aug 4 2023, 03:30 PM
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 03:58 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(river.sand @ Aug 4 2023, 03:46 PM)
Myanmar was part of British India until 1937.
Irian Jaya is, from geological perspective, part of Oceania.

So my theory is:
Before 1937, some angmoh said Kinabalau was the highest mountain in SE Asia.
And the belief held on until today.
*
Very possible. In fact Papua (which all the Indonesian peaks are located) was still under Dutch until 1970, and if gained independence rather than being invaded by Indonesian army would have been part of Oceania for sure.
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 07:37 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(differ @ Aug 4 2023, 06:14 PM)
British Burma you mean?
*
Burma was a province of the British Indian Empire, similar to other Indian provinces until 1937
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 07:38 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(billy3336 @ Aug 4 2023, 03:49 PM)
this

Myanmar highest if part of Himalayan, they didn't count it

edit: even chatgpt support us

The highest mountain in Southeast Asia is Mount Kinabalu, located in Sabah, Malaysia.
*
Thats just us making up rules to suit ourselves
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 11:19 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(dickybird @ Aug 4 2023, 07:43 PM)
It is about geographical boundaries not political boundaries.
*
South east Asia is defined by the political boundaries of it's constituent countries, of which Myanmar & Indonesia both definitely are.

You could discount West Papua by saying it's not traditionally part of SEA, but how can you do the same for Myanmar?
nobrainer86
post Aug 4 2023, 11:21 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
65 posts

Joined: Jan 2013


QUOTE(dickybird @ Aug 4 2023, 07:42 PM)
Across the Wallace Line is Australasia not SEA
Myanmar is more South Asia than SEA
*
Myanmar has always been more politically, linguistically and ethnically related to SEA than India

It's only because of British occupation via India that Myanmar ended up lumped into South Asia

This post has been edited by nobrainer86: Aug 4 2023, 11:22 PM

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0163sec    0.72    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 15th December 2025 - 02:40 PM