TBH, both cars are not expensive to own.
But if buyer is concerned about saving money, then avoid SUVs entirely.
The tyre costs itself will make you hurt.
Like I said above, cars are just tools. If you need an SUV, then you get one. If you dont, there are other options.

Want power get X50
Want good FC get Ativa

ativa

X50

Purely due to the driving dynamics n experience

Tekan sure vroom damn syok

Run over bumps also no rasa

Keep in mind high FC and exp tyres

But Myr still cheap fuel so yolo

x50 la. spareparts can buy from taobao je

ativa

Reconsider both choices if money is tight. SUV maintenance is higher than sedan car.

maintenance fee: ativa > x50

even x50 can go far, i will pick ativa.

wait for s50 and new vios?

x50 active cruise control is still not as refined as toyota.

sometimes the car steer itself too close to the other lane.

tested both on mrr2

I see! Any examples?

X50 Bad FC? shocked 😲

Maybe Perodua light weight that's why good in FC?

WOW... I might be able to get the satisfied ideas from you 😁
70% KL & Selangor Drive. And maybe once a month outstation!
My concern still surrounded to maintenance wise — parts (price and durability), fees (overall).

How about performance and power (5 persons + luggages)?

This post has been edited by mactreouser: Feb 27 2023, 11:12 AM

for 5 person + luggage, even the x50 is too small.
If short distance still bearable. If you go long distance, its uncomfortable.

Very Honest Suggestions and advice! Appreciate!
Does it mean, New Alza also should be avoided?
Actually how expensive is the SUV's Tyre compare to Sedan?

High FC really shocking me! Nowadays, what a technologies!

Wow.... Can't imagine! Roughly, how much difference? Like how many percentage higher than a Sedan maintenant fees?

sound like axia vs vios..... but the new vios now has some features brought from ativa... lol

This post has been edited by kevintth: Feb 27 2023, 11:20 AM

They are not sewel, they just not cheapskate like Perodua owner. They know what they paid for. They rather pay extra money for fuel than have to endure the feeling like 'naik sampan' at the highway or road with lots of corners.

I used to own both (MyVi & Persona) and have to travel almost 100-150km daily for my previous job, and seriously the fuel difference just around RM30 per month. But the comfort and handling of Proton over Perodua, even if the FC difference is RM100 per month i still willing to choose Proton. MyVi gave me body ache all over after just 2 months of travelling and the problem settled when i changed to Persona.

If avoided those SUV like X50 , Ativa, Alza... What's your advices and suggestions for a better maintenance and good FC with spacious' vehicle?

What a great user reviews! Appreciate!
So. Which car are driving now?

i support this,
i know is diff segment, given u got the budget to buy any of this..

thats the main diff

Fixed

actually, Alza is a good idea too.
It also uses regular sized tyres.

Civic

If no budget then it’s City