Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Helmet Intercom chat

views
     
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 1 2022, 11:24 AM, updated 8 months ago

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
For general discussion on helmet intercom.

This helmet intercom thing seems to be quite difficult to get a perfect one, and they don't really tell the whole truth with their marketing materials. Most designed in a way to get people to buy only their own brand, causing so much saturation in functionalities to a point it's becoming annoying.

Features I think an intercom should have:
1. Basic feature, act as bluetooth headset for your phone in solo ride.
2. Link with pillion to chat
3. Link with pillion and other riders to chat, regardless of brand.
4. Mix in Waze or Google map navigation voice during intercom


What I noticed:
1. Cheaper intercoms will not mix in navigation voice when using intercom mode.
2. Most intercoms especially mid range ones refused to link with other brands.
3. Even when able to link with other brands (with link request triggered by other brand), it will become 1:1 and unable to do group chat.


I haven't got chance to try out Sena and Cardo in pair and link to other brand.
Example: Cardo1 - Cardo2 - OtherBrand1, and all 3 can talk at the same time.

Any sifu can share experience of using your helmet intercom, solo, in two person group, and larger 3 - 5 person group?


TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 2 2022, 07:55 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(ZZR-Pilot @ Aug 1 2022, 11:46 AM)
I never had the need to use an intercom, until I had to coach my noob wife how to ride on the road. An intercom system is absolutely invaluable for this purpose.

Initially I had a Fodsports FX4 Pro system. It was terrible, our units had lousy connection even when she was sitting right behind me on the pillion seat. The unit was fiddly to use, making it a huge distraction when riding. The audio quality was shit too, as I would often get audio coming from only 1 speaker... if at all!

Then I got a pair of Cardo Packtalk Bold. All problems instantly solved. There are still minor niggles (i.e. reception suffers in urban areas with lots of signal interference, fcuking voice command would sometimes kick in unintentionally etc), but on the whole it has been so reliable we would not tour without it esp now that she rides separately on her own bike.

Handles Spotify, Waze & voice comm simultaneously with zero problems.

On clear stretches of the highway outside of cities, we could still communicate abt 1km apart esp if she's within line of sight.

Biggest con is that it's fukkin expensive, but it's better than throwing RM500 odd bucks on a cheap system that I ended up ripping out of my helmet in a fit of rage.

I only ride with my wife, so we've never tried to see how well it works with other systems.
*
Good sharing.

You started off with a bad experience, quite an expensive one too.
Mono headset is never good in a noisy surrounding.

Shops are pushing Cardo Packtalk as the "solve all" solution because
- it's expensive, how wrong can it be if it's expensive and quire well known tongue.gif
- it's amplifier is louder, hence able to "hear" in strong wind noise (consider hearing damage long term)
- it has an app
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 2 2022, 08:13 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(persona93 @ Aug 1 2022, 12:16 PM)
was actually eyeing some lapsap brand from Shopee
now i guess better not  laugh.gif
*
Care to share those you think are "lapsap" brand from shopee?

Here's my findings from paying plenty education fees.


If you can accept the following:
- Solo use able to stream voice / calls / navigation / songs from phone
- Intercom mode with 2 or more, navigation voice won't mix in so you don't get navigation voice alert, need to look at phone to remind self.
- Able to connect to any brand's intercom
- No "hey siri" "ok google" voice assistant. (won't work properly at speed > 80km/h anyway)

Take a good look at Maxto M2C, around RM200+.
I was using M2 before they launch newer M2C with Bluetooth 5.1.
Volume level is good, maybe 80% of Cardo.
Simple and just work.

Best part, I was able to link M2-M2-Vimoto V8 and have a nice group chat of 3 riders.
Whereas V8 - V8 - M2 fails, it became V8

Another brand is Hysnox HY-02.
Bought a pair to test. It supports Hey Siri / Ok Google voice assistant, also connects to any other intercom
Haven't tested H-H-others yet.
But on outset, the buttons are more complex to remember / operate.


If solo ride is mostly your cuppa, then pay double price of Maxto around RM500-600 for Vimoto V9S.
At this price range, you start to have an app.
Remember these things don't have a screen, so have an app to "set up" is quite useful.
It's loud like Cardo, but refuses to connect to non Vimoto brand.
However, you can trigger connection from M2 to Vimoto and they will connect.
If pairing is triggered from Vimoto, it won't connect to other brand.
This one solves the sound mixing problem, you can hear navigation etc while using intercom.
Also tested V9S-V9S-M2 ...
ends up all 3 are connected in intercom mode but the middle V9S will not route intercom to the other V9S, so only V9S-M2 can talk, not all 3.
Another caveat is, this one is only in Chinese prompt, no English.


If you can afford and wants to feel good spending money, go straight for Cardo Packtalk cost 2x more than V9S.


Most important factor of helmet bluetooth is quietness of your helmet tongue.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 2 2022, 08:19 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(jaycee1 @ Aug 1 2022, 04:03 PM)
For me, the shopee lapsap brands will do. Haha

I find I just need Bluetooth only anyway for music, telephone calls and Waze.

In in small group, just use hand signals lah.. hahaha

I am using a freedcom unit.supports inter rider com but never tried it. Sound quality not bad. Phone noise cancelling pretty good also. Sometimes the caller on the other side don't even realise I am on a bike going highway speeds. Only cons is battery life is so so only. Lasts about 5hrs.
*
Freedconn is good on paper, but
- Does not connect to other brand.
- When connected by other brand, intercom becomes 2 person only FreedConn-Other, can't loop in other Freedconn.
- Supports voice assistant on TMax
- Volume lower than Maxto, would say around 70% of maxto. if helmet noisy, you tend to max out the volume and still struggle to hear
- TMax dial is very badly designed, easily gets turned on by accident.


No, I didn't read internet review to tell you the above.
I bought 3 x TMax and 2 x TCom to test.

TCom has better physical design, small and slim.

But I won't recommend Freedconn lah.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 2 2022, 08:38 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(persona93 @ Aug 2 2022, 11:05 AM)
Maxto M2
*
So, gonna buy? grin.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 3 2022, 10:19 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(megahertz @ Aug 3 2022, 09:52 AM)
i also use freedconn before. freedconn tcom sc then i upgrade to R1 plus. i never use intercom function so cant comment on that.
Ok, if use solo and never intercom, get any bluetooth headset with stereo speakers should do, and make sure your helmet is quiet enough biggrin.gif

Again, Freedconn not as loud as Maxto, and Maxto sound quality also better.

Disclaimer:
Bought, owned and gave away:
2 x Freedconn TCom
3 x Freedconn TMax
2 x Hysnox HY-02
2 x Maxto M2 (still keeping a 3rd unit for testing)

... not listing other brands / models owned before for testing purposes....
tongue.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 3 2022, 10:35 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(megahertz @ Aug 3 2022, 10:32 AM)
yeah, for me  the R1 plus quite ok. but if i ride long distance, i never use it because the sound more than 120kmh quite bad since i use open face helmet and wind noise very bad. need to replace my helmet. plus, i  like ride with silence right now, more calming and hear the engine sound more nice. lol

R1 plus now mostly i use because of the dashcam function. got few times almost hit some crazy cars and at least i got evidence.

so based on ur past experience, maxto m2 quite ok?
thinking to find intercom that able to connect other brand since my friends mostly used other brand. i see Maxto M3 which got video function as well. might be good replacement for my R1 plus.
*
Haven't tested the M3 with video, or any other models with video.
DareDevil's reply from his experience should gave you enough detail.

Yes, M2 is pretty good for it's price point.
I assume M3 is similar in firmware ie. able to connect to any intercom.
Only downside is, not support voice assistant.




QUOTE(ThE DaReDeViL @ Aug 3 2022, 09:21 PM)
M2 never tried connect to other brand before.. But I've tried group of 5 and 6, the interference is strong to the point that it's near to not useable.. End up we break to 2 small groups connections of 3 and 3.. If use 2-3 person I gotta say it's good.. sound and range also fine.. M3 just bought, haven't use the comm yet, but picture quality is good but not great.. Stabilization is weak compare to gopro, but not to the point that makes you dizzy la.. recording time as advertised, but with using comm system..
*
Yep, group of 2-3 is good. Anything more, even with other budget brand, it's not stable.
This is where Cardo packtalk and Sena shines with their mesh connection.


TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 4 2022, 12:13 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(jaycee1 @ Aug 4 2022, 09:18 AM)
I have the freedconn tcom SC. I find it pretty sufficiently loud, even with earplugs in. But then again my helmet is quiet.

It beginning to flake out after a year of use. The connection socket is getting slightly loose due to having to unplug and plug it every time to charge. But then again, I rode 25k over the past year..so considered heavy use. Shopping for another unit to replace it soon. Technically I "could" repair the socket and continue to use it....but for the price, I really can't be bothered.

Any com unit that has a dedicated charge port as to not have to plug and unplug it all the time to charge?
*
TCOM does not have separate charging port.

TMax, Maxto all has. In short, newer ones all will have.

The only funny one might be TMax's charging port. It's micro USB but long type.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 4 2022, 12:17 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(gataddhin @ Aug 4 2022, 10:15 AM)
I paid RM220 for Lexin B4FM (share 4 riders) in 2018. I think they increased the price to RM300 plus for nrw model (10 riders). Clear and long battery life. Highly recommended.
*
First time this brand crosses me.

May I know if this unit is able to mix in navigation alert when you are using intercom mode with other riders?
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 5 2022, 08:09 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(gataddhin @ Aug 4 2022, 06:11 PM)
5.6 Function Priority LX - B4FM operates in the following order of priority : 1. Mobile phone ( highest ) 2. Intercom 3. Bluetooth stereo music , FM radio ( lowest ) lower - priority function is always interrupted by a higher - priority function . For example , stereo music is interrupted by an Intercom call , and Intercom conversation interrupted by an incoming mobile phone call .
*
Ok, sounds like you have not tried running it in intercom mode, then try to navigate using waze / google map at the same time.

After looking it up, this B4FM seems like product of the same ODM for Maxto, Freedconn and other budget brands.



QUOTE(ajaibman @ Aug 4 2022, 06:32 PM)
To Answer TS question on Cardo to non-Cardo via Bluetooth connectivity, yes it can be done.. the voice depends, mine one connected to a Sena set then some static sound is heard when communicating.

The biggest issue is if you and your non-cardo rider distanced more than 10m or had obstacles in between, it disconnected and was unable to pair back automatically.
*
All I know is, when they (not just Cardo) connect to same brand for intercom, they use a specific frequency or bluetooth profile. When other brand being added, it uses a headset profile and this type of connection somehow has limit on range. I think it's mentioned in my Cardo's or Sena's manual, can't remember which one. I didn't get a pair of Cardo / Sena to test due to price. Just got one each. Sold them away 'cos many friends want the brand biggrin.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 6 2022, 09:56 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 6 2022, 11:28 AM)
thanks.
didn't know about the upgrade m2c model.

been running maxto m2 for a while. no big issues. really worth the RM150 price
*
Surprisingly, the M2 is my favourite of the lot I had bought and tested (includes Vimoto, Cardo and Sena)

At it's price point, now RM200+, it simply is worth the money.

If battery konk? Buy a new one loh... Cardo and Sena claims to offer battery replacement (which I had seen many returning to shop for repair / claim), at a price. This M2, just ditch and buy new.

Only down side during intercom, which I am still bitching about, no navigation alert from your Waze or Google map.

TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 6 2022, 09:58 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
I have 3 of these "kits"

These connects to Maxto M2, but not Freedconn.

If all intercom is friendly to bluetooth walkie talkie, it really solves a lot of compatibility issue.

user posted image
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 7 2022, 02:06 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(paskal @ Aug 7 2022, 09:19 AM)
but since i have a really loud exhaust not much SQ can be heard once i'm at speed  biggrin.gif
*
I don't have your problem, because unker me don't speed, only 80-100km/h nia.. tongue.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 8 2022, 12:21 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(ZZR-Pilot @ Aug 7 2022, 10:46 PM)
I find that it's rather pointless to buy an intercom that has a built-in camera, because the camera has to be built to such a low price there's just no way it'll produce a satisfactory video.... esp since everyone by default expects action camera-level footages.
*
I still believe a permanently mounted front / rear "dash cam" on bike for recording is best for the intention of recording unwanted moments and not for socmed postings.

At least the cams are powered by bike and not by battery that runs out if you are going on a long ride.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 8 2022, 09:30 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(megahertz @ Aug 8 2022, 09:29 AM)
i use it as dashcam. many times i almost got accident due crazy driver. once there this some uncle make illegal uturn and almost hit me, that video already sent to JPJ, but not sure if they do anything about it . at least i hv proof if anything happened. car driver will always blame motor rider anyway.

and sometimes use it to capture picture in the video for whatsapp group picture with friends when convoy.  laugh.gif

and yes, the quality of course cant compare with those action cam, even the cheap 1. because of that price alone, u cant expect to much.
and i lazy to use my gopro because dont hv proper mount for it.
*
Not so sharp is ok, but are you able to capture number plates at night?
This is more important
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Aug 9 2022, 09:53 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(megahertz @ Aug 9 2022, 09:04 AM)
well, for night time, to be fair, if the area quite dark, even branded car dashcam also hard to see.
*
It's more like capturing the "final moments" of those farker hitting you, with you head / tail lamp shining on their plate if scenario allows. tongue.gif
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Jan 19 2025, 08:01 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(bo093 @ Jan 8 2025, 10:10 AM)
Anyone know anywhere that can fix intercom?

Is a freedconn r3, gone haywire on the intercom but the dashcam still working.
*
Haven't seen people offering to fix intercom.
This might need some DIY enthusiast to figure out.

Otherwise, might be better to get a new one.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Jan 20 2025, 10:26 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(mypie @ Jan 19 2025, 02:55 PM)
Finally, my Sena went dead on me after 12 years. So out of touch with current tech and market trend. Don't want to go Sena again as the price is getting expensive for the same tech I need like 12 years ago. I just need comm with my pillion, voice navigation and phone call in the same mode. Clear sound at 150kmh is added advantages. Generic China model will do. Any suggestions?
*
QUOTE(memoriany @ Jan 20 2025, 09:58 AM)
be sure to get JBL version if u want to hear properly at 160kmh>

my cardo just die within a year lol. i think its the battery issue, not able to start up at all suddenly
*
Want to hear intercom at high speed, the safest solution for your hearing health is ear bud.

you don't need to crank the volume to dangerously high DB (with bigger speaker etc) when you use in-ear ear-bud.

In-ear ear bud also cut out nasty high frequency noises.

I got a 3.5mm adapter for my Vimoto to hook up ear bud while using mic we installed in helmet.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Jan 21 2025, 04:15 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(mypie @ Jan 21 2025, 09:23 AM)
Thanks for the feedback. Bite the bullet and bought Parani by Sena (lol - I know) as I will embark on a long ride this coming weekend. It basically Sena old tech cascade down to B rated brand and sell it cheap. With the same tech I do hope it should pair with my other Sena and to interchange between 3 of those.
This is the bitch with intercom. Proprietary.

I am looking at walkie talkie with Bluetooth, and a separate PTT button to mount on handlebar.
Use it with any intercom that can mix audio from multiple sources (e.g. Vimoto, Cardo, Sena)

Then we are no longer bound by need to have same brand of intercom to talk to each other, except with pillion, still prefer same brand so no need PTT.
TSWH4CockcooBird
post Jan 21 2025, 06:41 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
194 posts

Joined: Jul 2022
QUOTE(jaycee1 @ Jan 21 2025, 05:11 PM)
That's the best solution. Also the greatest range.

user posted image

Found universal BT adapter for bao feng radios.

Maybe I should dig out my bao fengs
*
I have 3 sets of these adapters on my shelf.
The enclosed earpiece is shit. Throw it away. Can't work properly in normal condition, not to mention under helmet.

Too troublesome to pair this pair that.

The bluetooth walkie talkie I am eyeing is this, price came down from RMB900 to below RMB500 now.
Can search for model UV78 and new model UV79

user posted image

This post has been edited by WH4CockcooBird: Jan 21 2025, 06:41 PM

2 Pages  1 2 >Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0186sec    0.42    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 25th November 2025 - 02:09 AM