Haagen dazs it's dependant on the flavor. Cookies & Cream tbh all brands nothing special since it's a muddled flavor.

For HD best IMO is Pralines & Cream + Belgian Chocolate combo or Macadamia Nut, they're hard to find equivalent elsewhere, even Tilamook (which is my #1 fave)

on 2nd eating and following my own recommendation:

It's damn nice.. My opinion of it actually improved. I highly recommend this flavour, coming from a non coffee drinking person as well..

Flavour + texture = both win.

on the other hand, the sunnyside peanut butter cup a bit let down.. The ice cream itself is PB flavour but i feel its a bit lacking in PB kick, only when you actually have some of the peanut butter cup in your mouth then only the kick comes again.. But its not every bite/scoop you will get the PB cup. Maybe for those not so into peanut butter would enjoy it. but for hardcore lovers of the PB flavour will find it a bit lacking.. Even Tillamook have a weakness, their PB flavour has kick but it's a bit too little and no texture for the ice cream..

Enough of PB flavour for now since i've tried both sunnyside and tillamook dy.. Gonna try others next and maybe can find another gem like the coffee + cookie..

hmm now that you mentioned it this way... I agree, I think that was what was lacking when i give my review earlier but couldn't pin point exactly what it was..
i bought my 2 tubs of sunnyside last weekend for 25 each @ jaya.. normally is 28 each.. then grab promo spend above 100 got 10 cashback too..

So yeah buy at jaya got its benefits..
I tried HD peanut butter crunch the other day.. Very gooding.

The peanut taste is kaw2 because there is actual salted peanuts inside the ice cream.