Yes, can still eat halaal game and livestock from kafirs as long as slaughtering done by muslims along the appropriate ritual manner (dhabihah).

When religion based on false information of the past, added a layer of unnecessary abstraction or encapsulation, it might turn out to be harsh, brutal or insane in modern perspective. Sometimes there is a need to add yet another layer of abstraction or encapsulation to surmount it, just to add a bit of sanity to the overall.

It's human nature to complicate simple matters.

...and who is the arbiter on whether past information are false?


Are u an atheist or even worse, a vegan?





Some info if anyone is open to the truth (and inclined to read).

Science of meat.

Halal Meat And Science





This post has been edited by headache: Jun 23 2022, 06:34 PM

The quoted articles, are they proven and established science?

Having an article or a few articles written about it said not much.

A lot more people have consumed non-halal food. There is no data established that halal good is "better". Please conduct proper double blinded randomised tests if you want to prove this point.

complicated indeed.

you assume he is an atheist and a vegan because of his views? and whats wrong with being both? such a judgmental character aren't you?

Particularly if the matter is related to your belief and identity, which you have invested emotionally with time and resources since you were young. Religion simply put is man made.

For halal better than non-halal, these are just opinions, not science.

That means you have to be selective on which part of the religion you choose to implement too

That is the nature of religion, cherry picking which part you want and ignore (or interpret away) which that doesn't fit in. Oh if you criticize a lot, you will be reported for bashing religion ...

1st of all, let me state that the lack of comprehension on display here is quite appalling. Not only young Malaysians can't read between the lines, they simply lack tact (thoughtfulness and finesse).

Did u see the question mark at the end of my sentence? Can u discern the difference between a statement and a question? Now, who exactly is being judgemental?

I ask questions so that I can better understand the questioner. I could then frame my answers better, hopefully, conforming to the questioner's world view and bias.

Do u even comprehend my double edged answer cum question, "...and who is the arbiter on whether past information are false?" ???

It's a trap for farceurs, exactly like yourself.

Let me put it in a much cruder way, “Opinions are like arseholes, everyone has one but they think each others stink.”

So what exactly are u implying? Is the majority always right (like Malaysians voting BN)?

The 1st source is from Times of India and everyone knows how they are with anything Islamic. I believe they have a better reputation and standing than u do. My opinion, anyway.

2nd is from Japan...let me see how much deeper u guys want to dig yourselves in.

So you agree that halal is better than non-halal is just like arseholes?

that would be your stinky opinion.

also, is it your opinion that all vegans and atheists are bad people?

This post has been edited by seraph00: Jun 24 2022, 12:51 PM

2nd of all, your opinion stinks like an arsehole.

jangan tanya soalan susah boleh tak?

This post has been edited by Bossku_Johor: Jun 24 2022, 01:30 PM

Slaughtering through stunning is a new method to make the process more efficient and also seems more humane. Doesn't mean halal invented the non-stunning method. Non-stunning method was adopted by all regardless of religion before the introduction of stunning. So please stop giving credit to halal when it doesn't earn it. and please show me halal meat is better than non halal meat, scientifically. You haven't demonstrated that.

The real truth is the religion is not simple at all. It's unclear, incomplete and nonsensical such that their followers have to make things up to so that it makes sense in modern terms. In their terminology it is called Bid'ah but they willingly close one eye and call it tafsir instead to make it halal. Hilarious.

Religion claims to follow scriptures. But the details are seldom spelled out in scriptures. So religion is objective, unless it is unclear, then by all means be subjective.

Coming from someone like u, I'll take that as a compliment.


1. What's the subject of this thread again?
2. What religion do you profess?




“Never argue with an idiot. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.” ― Mark Twain

You the one who started it by posting the 2 links about.halal meat. And when we challenge u, u change the subject.

This post has been edited by ramz: Jun 26 2022, 06:08 PM