Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 WGT Fifa 2007 Rules, Updated on 23 October 2007

views
     
ken0777
post Sep 22 2007, 05:40 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
It is not allowed to score a goal from a computer taken free kick.

Falcon, it means tat when you are taking a free kick, you can't leave the game goin idle cause if you do, after about 30 seconds or so, the AI will automatically take the freekick for you. So the goal being scored that way, it's not legal.

And good suggestions from accelerator, loon and bpwx. I agree with them on their case. So i guess we need more player's feedbacks. Well, at the end of the day, these rules are being made for gamers. So, i think suggestions will be great. Give constructive comments and suggestions. Help luige out here.

I'm totally agreeing on the same set of rules being implemented by my.WCG07 and if there's a problem on the 1 on 1 long ball lob which is done by precisely exsecuting the "A" button to create a 1 on 1 ST on GK situation, which most players seems to deem it unfair. Then ban that "A" move in addition to the previous my.WCG07 set of R&R. Don't ban the D clearance and A clearance or any long balls which do not create a 1 on 1 situation (ST vs GK).

Good job by luige in moderating the FIFA R&R despite his work and hectic schedule. KUDOS for your dedication.

Another 1 more thing, is FIFABOT gonna be used?

Thanks.

This post has been edited by ken0777: Sep 22 2007, 05:43 PM
ken0777
post Sep 23 2007, 02:10 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
QUOTE(bpwx @ Sep 23 2007, 01:46 PM)
Hmmm...why not you try confirming first whether there is internet connection available.. Cause it is preffered if the fifabot is used, to somehow stop all this arguments and prevent future problems in tourneys..

I'm sure you remember my situation with kayren about his time wasting and forbidden move which scored the crucial goal that beat me right? With a fifabot, definitely his move will be detected, but since nobody saw him doing it, only me, no marshalls saw it, he can deny and deny and there's nothing we can do about it.....

If really there is no internet connection, then I suggest maybe have one marshall to officiate EACH match, not one marshall to observe few matches... With one marshall to watch each match, at least we can get them straight away once a problem occurs... Like last time, when kayren did the forbidden move to me, I was shouting and showing hand signals like a crazy man but there was NO marshalls available... The earliest marshall to arrive was like, walking from one end of the tournament area to my position and by the time the marshall arrived, kayren stopped doing the time wasting stuff so the marshall couldn't see it but clearly, the damage was done to me already......

And for the second point should there be no internet connection, I think this would be a fair long ball rule( copied and posted from my earlier post) :

1. Long balls 'QA', 'QD' and 'QW' are banned.
2. Long balls which somehow gets past the whole defence and straight to the striker( as in the ball lands in front of the striker without any problems and any challenges from the last man) is banned.
3. Long balls which makes the ball travel high in the air but STILL require a challenge for the ball whether a header or a ball chesting fight between the defender and the striker is allowed. This is indeed fair for both players as with this long ball, the defending player can still have a chance to actually do SOMETHING and win the ball than just watch as his opponent's long ball as stated in no.2 penetrates the whole defence and giving his opponent a 1v1 chance....

P.S. : luige, we all know you're trying your best to solve the problem and we really appreciate it
*
AGREED!

add:-

Clearance ball of 'D' or 'A' is allowed as long it doesn't create a without any challenge situation of 1 on 1 of Attacker with Goalkeeper. If does and goal is scored, the goal will be consider void and inform to marshall. If the situation is created unintentionally, fairplay is encouraged, just kick the ball out of play to give the ball back to your opponent.
ken0777
post Sep 24 2007, 02:41 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
QUOTE(luige @ Sep 23 2007, 03:03 PM)
if u guys volunteer to become marshal, then i will have 1 marshal for each game biggrin.gif

if ther's not internet connection, ok...
- Q combinations is banned
- No DIRECT LONG BALL TO STRIKER POSITION / FURTHEST PLAYER
- Long ball which required challenges will still be banned

at the moment, tat's it
i will update the rules by tmr
*
No long comments or examples... luige... just want to ask about how do the players go about when encounter or did the above banned moves? Are the action suchs as:-

1. Goals being scored the above methods will be disallowed and the oppossing player that did the invalid move be given a yellow card for unsportsmanship or just a warning?

2. If the player accidentally does the move, be it without an intention, what should the player do?
a. kick the ball out for throw in for the opposing player?
b. end the attacking run and repass back the playin ball back to his midfielders or defenders (push the ball back
below the half line and continues the game with the ball in his side?)

What are the steps or procedure on handling banned moves/illegal moves? How to go about it? Maybe luige can provide some insight on how to deal with the matter. Thanks, no hurry for the reply, take your time.

kEnN-iEd

This post has been edited by ken0777: Sep 24 2007, 02:42 AM
ken0777
post Sep 24 2007, 03:13 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
Totally agree on accelerator. Exactly what i thought of. Just that i think we all need clarification from luige in 'black and white' regarding what's the procedure in handling the issues of banned moves and also the banned long ball moves.

Another few suggestion:-

1.Print out the final draft of the my.WGT FIFA07 set of Rules and Regulations and pinned it together with the match schedule during my.WGT FIFA07. So that there's no excuse of not knowing the R&R for my.WGT FIFA07.

2.Brief to players to check on the notice board where the R&R are stated so that marshalls don't need to explain 1 by 1 and everytime. (Saves more time). Just ask players to refer to notice board for the my.WGT FIFA07 Rules & Regulations, prior to the actual game time. (During Pre-registration, staffs can inform players to check the R&R of each participationg game, stress more on FIFA players since FIFA has alot of technical issues.)

This should help to manage the process and avoid any further problems or difficulties. Thanks for hearin me out.

kENn-iEd
ken0777
post Sep 24 2007, 03:58 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
True! Not many players take note on the R&R side and wateva tat is being discussed on this forum. Agree on you regarding the explanations but i think printing out the final draft of the my.WGT FIFA07 set of Rules and Regulations and pinned it together with the match schedule during my.WGT FIFA07 would help too. So on the save side, do both of the suggestions i suggested and also include a briefing on all my.WGT FIFA07 players before the match starts. And again, thanks for all the players who gives suggestions and feedbacks to help smoothen the R&R side of FIFA. Just hope to see that all the players joinin FIFA07 WGT Malaysia 2007 will be aware of the current R&R. Thanks for hearin us out luige and thanks to players that took time to contribute and to make an effort in improving this thread.

*Totally random stuff:
1. Padan muka that chelsea lost!!! *as predicted by me*
2. Shows that Avram Grant can't do $hit as well.
3. Mourinho!!! Ur de MAN!!! Forever will be!!! Thanks Mourinho!!! God Speed!!!
4. Red card was totally un-necessary!!!
5. Referee Mike Dean was being very ridiculous on the multiple decisions.
6. Totally support on video replays!!! English FA! FIFA! Approved video replays!!!
7. To Roman Abramovich!!! F**k you!!! You are the boss...so yeah...i respect that! But don't think cause you love the game and you go on and try to be a manager!!! If you were to just shut the f**k up and let mourinho do his job.
8. Very sad on Chelsea Management, very disappointed!!! F**k you ROMAN!!!
9. I am still staying "True Blue"
10. That's all for my random jitters and whinners.

kEnN-iEd

This post has been edited by ken0777: Sep 24 2007, 04:01 AM
ken0777
post Sep 24 2007, 09:58 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
QUOTE(luige @ Sep 24 2007, 08:29 AM)
i will brief all the players before tournamet begins
and no question ask at tat time

i will have enuf marshal to guide u all, so plz raise ur hand and call for the marshal
*
That's more than what the players can ask for. thumbup.gif


Added on September 24, 2007, 10:01 am
QUOTE(bpwx @ Sep 24 2007, 09:05 AM)
Yea I get exactly what you mean, I'm just writing those examples so I don't get screwed again in WGT like how I got screwed in WCG. I don't want to get into heated arguments where I was the fair player who abided by the rules, yet for some reason, lose out when arguing about the unfair play from my opponent and get decisions which still favoured my unfair opponent.... I just want to be perfectly clear about EVERY situation that comes to mind. I'm not worried about using it for my advantage, I'm just worried about my opponent using it againts me....I don't want to treat certain stuff as illegal, but for SOME reason, the marshall says it's legal when my opponent uses it againts me...More arguments will arise then.....Nvm, I'll do myself a favour and shut up now.... We'll just do the arguing during WGT then  rclxm9.gif  brows.gif  rclxms.gif
*
bpwx mean well. I believe, he didn't ask those questions to manipulate the long ball run. He is mere just tryin to give situations that might arise during the competition that resolves around the long ball move. i think no need to argue on that that bpwx since luige has assured us that there's gonn abe briefing and there's gonna be enough marshalls around.

Thanks, luige for the fast feedbacks. Good job!

This post has been edited by ken0777: Sep 24 2007, 10:01 AM
ken0777
post Sep 25 2007, 07:24 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
536 posts

Joined: Jul 2007
From: KL, Malaysia
Pity Forza... can't go to seattle...

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0149sec    0.47    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 6th December 2025 - 07:58 PM