Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Bad Reno Experience

views
     
TSkimteck
post Dec 18 2021, 03:57 PM, updated 4y ago

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
As my connection is not that "powerful", I had to find a reno company online. Here to share some of my experience/ journey to this 1000 sqft unit renovation in KL:

At first, I found 3 quotations online for simple reno as below:
1. Wiring - all 13A powerpoints, light/ ceiling fan installation
2. Kitchen cabinet, and 3 rooms wardrobe
3. 2 toilets cabinet/ shower screens
4. Entrance grill door and backyard windows
5. Touch up painting after the work
6. All windows curtain
7. TV board and TV console at living room

It looks basic things to me so I budgeted around Rm 50k for a small unit. Ended up all 3 quotations coming back close to RM 80k. So I chose one that just started the business and hope she could do all the best for building her rapport.

That's when "vomit blood" communication starts after you paid your first deposit

So the common "market rules" are like this, if you're not aware of:

a. 40-50 % deposit (roughly)
b. 20-30 % before start work
c. 15%-25% upon 50-80% completion
d. 5% upon completion


At stage A, you give them the house plan, your idea, they give you a rough quotation, without site measurement, no itemized quotation.
According to them, itemized quotation can only be given after you pay the deposit , and site visit, which is Stage B. - Finalizing the plan & quotation.
After adjusting and tuning the final quotation with "current market price", they give you another itemized quotation to proceed to stage B to start the work.

Guess what, my stage A RM 80k quotation increased close to RM 100k at stage b.

So what had been deviated from my original plan?

1. M&E
Rewiring all light points/ceiling fan points with plaster ceiling , as concealed wiring at ceiling slab is not recommended. I listed down roughly the number for you to judge:
~ 18-20 downlights, 5-6 mounted lights, 7-10 cabinet LED , 1 pendant, 2-3 track lights, 20-25 nos 13A points, relocate DB , relocate switches, & install ceiling fan


2. Carpentry - plywood laminate
~ took out bedrooms wardrobe as cant afford
~Do kitchen cabinet, master bedroom wardrobe, TV wall & console, toilets cabinet/ under sink cabinet

3. touch up paint and repaint the doors, others like curtain, grille door, backyard windows remain the same.

Of course, you have to pay additional for 10% project management and 5% design fees.

And you can only see the itemized quotation after you pay the deposit and site visit.

I have some sleepless night as feel like I being "diok" become "water fish". A simple plan to move in a 1000 ft unit need RM 100k.

Another rule, the ID company holds full control during the renovation work, you're not allowed to visit the unit spontaneously without appointment.

So my advice, if those sounds reasonable to you, go ahead with the ID company. Else find your YiMaGujJe, brother sister , uncle aunty to get a contact that can help.
If you have no contact, go to facebook join the group and ask for one.

Hope no "vomit blood" workmanship when the work starts.


~To be continued - Part 1 -

Listing down few things this Reno doing which I really don't like :

1. Giving all the required documents piece by piece, including drawings (not merged, literally piece by piece) and forms/data for management approval. Today one piece of info, tomorrow another one
2. Last minute work and demand you to reply/agree where work about to commence within 1- 2 days
3. Didn't go through the details of the drawings , and I had to go through myself. When you asking for some clarification, she answered I already sent you the info right.
If you overlook it, jialat. Like what I overlooked the distance from kitchen countertop to wall hung base cabinet as I trusted their profession .. ( I had 8++ mm..) .
4. I spot a few mistakes in the drawings, and they've never admitted.

~ To be continued - Part 2

I'm kind of tired and exhausted after 3 months following up with this small renovation that almost cost me Rm 100k. I don't think I want to recall my PAINFUL memories to describe all the details again.
I just want that lady quickly finishes the work and get out from my house. The wiring and plaster ceiling workmanship was terrible, hack/install at so many wrong places.

For all lengzai lengnui out there that you want to engage an ID company, my advices here as below:

1. Find more companies for comparison, those not giving free/reasonable quotation with site visits can straight away OUT.
2. Unfair payment terms to customer - OUT
3. Ego like he/she knows everything and difficult to communicate -OUT
4. No other project site visit - or show unit - OUT. Why project site visit is important? From my painful experience, they made lot of mistake hacking a wrong place/wrong tiles, and simply touch up with cheap materials.
You might also have surprise findings like unprecise measurement (not follow the drawings), bad workmanship and cheap materials used which are not on the paper, and cannot be seen during the discussion.
5. Discuss every single details , remember , all details, like what brand, what material, and ask a lot of why and what if before you pay the deposit.

This post has been edited by kimteck: Mar 7 2022, 06:59 PM
TSkimteck
post Dec 18 2021, 06:56 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(stormer.lyn @ Dec 18 2021, 05:33 PM)
You know it is a con as soon as a contractor/ID/whoever asks for a deposit of 50%. Didn't the alarm bells go off after they included all the ridiculous additional charges and conditions? Why on earth did you proceed with them?

I'll take your story with a grain of salt, as I read in another thread about companies using this forum to discredit their competitors.
*
All 3 quotations I got online from A*** have the same payment terms, just minor difference from the percentage. So I thought it is ID company common practice and proceed.
TSkimteck
post Dec 18 2021, 06:59 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
BTW, you can go to A**p and pretend you're potential customer, and get the quotations. It's free.
TSkimteck
post Dec 19 2021, 11:13 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
Thanks for sharing.

Yes , I paid the deposit before site visit, as it's the time during MCO /just lifted. She said they normally lock the agreed price after project confirmation , as materials price keeps increasing now.

The major changes after site visit is plaster ceiling , she recommended to do plaster ceiling for ceiling lights as some of the rooms don't have ceiling points and only wall light points given by developer. That's one of the increase. And also resize the kitchen wall with new sliding door.

The other things just like you mentioned, some things we thought is small but all will be charged. Plaster ceilings light point one charge, switch one charge, install the light one charge, supply light one charge, so 3-4 charges per light installation. Almost about rm 280-300 /light.

Not really worry about the company as her profile can be found from LinkedIn. For the site visit rule, she wants to make sure no direct communication from owner to contractor , to prevent the end result deviated from the original plan. So she has to be there when you do the site visit.

But since I had paid the first deposit, I have to go ahead , already "wet my head".

Just to share here with those who want to engage ID company, please list down all the details like how many light points, switches , wardrobe height/ drawers design, and proper site visit before you confirm and pay, don't be rushed by price hike or lack of resources , all excuses that can affect your decision making. If they are not willing to show you itemised quote like how much charges per light installation before confirmation, how much the TV feature wall , you have to think about my experience. Don't be innocent like me 😂 using 'trust basis' , ask for itemised quotation before paying.


Ask every single price details like what they charge on bills. Everything will be charged, and the light bulb /led prices can be doubled from what you get from shop/Lazada.

QUOTE(yuen300 @ Dec 18 2021, 09:56 PM)
Share my experience.

Usually, if you go for those renovator directly, especially those reno company, they do charged quite high end. Not so sure, it is because of the materials they used is expensive or more service they provided.

However, are you sure you pay deposit without the designer do the site visit? Or is it the design fee that you are paid. Looking at the size you mentioned and not sure how many rooms you requested for design picture, usually the design fee for this size costs around 5k to 8k depends on the reputation of designer.

For price inflate, if everything is done without site visit, I guess this will be quite normal since buyer and seller tends to have bias. What we considered small item, to the renovator, everything will be a charge.
So, from 50k to 80k, I guess is quite normal or expected if it is based on without site visit. Since a lot of things are quite expensive if you decided to customize a lot of items, especially wardrobe.
The wardrobe is the weird products among all furniture. If you buy from furniture shop, you can pay 2.5k for one full package (including the bed frame). However, if you just want the wardrobe, you will need to pay 2k as well.
(You can try to ask in any furniture shops. So, expect you have to allocate more budget if you decide to go for customize wardrobe)

From 80k to 100k, did you asked what is the major driver? Is it because some items you cant see without site visit? For example, the ceiling is higher than normal house so wardrobe need to be larger? Or some of the items beams etc cannot be hacked so wiring need to use longer path? Since unless you are rich, as rationale buyer, we will ask what is being charge additional and pay when it sounds reasonable.

Anywhere, based on your size given, the price quote by the designer looks around the same as per most designer I engage with. (That is like 2 years ago)
No comments whether it is expensive or cheap, just that my budget is low.

For the site visit rules, it is because of the Covid SOP? If you cannot do site visit, do you manage get the weekly updates from them? Like pictures of the construction etc?
If you did get, then I wont be too worry abt it. Just that perhaps negotiate with them during the next payment, you must at least do some site visit before you pay.

Anywhere, for TV feature wall, please dont be too surprise if you are asking for customize. The TV feature wall do looks simple, my previous designer quoted me for RM8K so your Rm5K still consider cheap in the market.
Just that I give up to have feature wall, and decide to use the paint with striking colour.
*
This post has been edited by kimteck: Dec 19 2021, 11:31 AM
TSkimteck
post Dec 19 2021, 11:40 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
Price Per Points

downlight/track light points 88
LED light points (built in) 95
pendant light point 140
wall light points 140
ceiling fan points 140
install 13 A points 140
install 15 A points 275
install 20 A point 330










QUOTE(yuen300 @ Dec 19 2021, 11:31 AM)
For your light, is it included with the light or only wiring?
Just curious whether the major cost is driven by the light itself or wiring.
Since I do have one friend pay 300 bucks just for one light in ceiling, because the designer mentioned it look nicer and got warranty for 5 years.

So, maybe if you want to cut cost, perhaps can discuss with your designer whether you can supply the items based on the dimension they give.
Just that you have to take the responsible if you buy wrong etc.

For site visit, I guess it is fair as well.

Not sure how much additional, from the additional one, kitchen sliding door if go for normal glass, around 4k I am being asked for. Then, maybe is some hacking around the wall. Total I remember it is around 6k.
So, if the price is around the same (like within 10%/20%) I guess should be okay gua considered my one is 2 years ago price.
*
This post has been edited by kimteck: Dec 21 2021, 08:53 PM
TSkimteck
post Jan 7 2022, 05:30 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(yuen300 @ Dec 20 2021, 02:07 PM)
That is why I admire those houseowners would dare to haggle with constructor worker. For me, I only proceed if the price he quote is okay.
*
I also admire my "stupidness".. bangwall.gif

TSkimteck
post Jan 8 2022, 12:00 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(ongss @ Jan 8 2022, 08:56 AM)
Don't blame yourself too much. After reviewing the item price, I think you are paying current market prices. There won't be perfect renovations.
Customized TV feature wall of RM 5000 is considered as cheap if you are using plywood laminate.
Same practices also. I had one renovation and this round is 2nd sites. Two different contractors but the same style. My current ones have been hacking the concrete several rounds because the plumber placed the concealed pipes wrongly. He constantly blame the drawings. All these contractors build based on their experiences and senses. They don't look at the drawings until the owners spot the mistakes.  doh.gif
For these charges, this ID company marked up 10%. It is usual because she has to design the location of the switches, power points. As an end users, we may not come out final design/location. But, there are industry practices e.g. the switches are located 1m above the ground, the power should be 500mm above or 300mm above, and etc. The designer has to have knowledge to prepare the drawing for the electricians to work. Supervise them to work. For my case, the 20A point I am paying RM 331.20 (i.e. RM 288 +15% contractor mark-up) , 13A points I am paying RM 126.50 (RM110 + 15% contractor mark-up).  For my case, it was a contractual price I signed with the main con back in Aug 2020!

Overall, I think you are paying the current market price for engaging an ID company or main con. So, don't be over upset. Just enjoy once your renovation is over. My two cents.
*
Thanks a lot sharing your experience with me ! May I know what's the distance from your kitchen countertop to base of the wall hung cabinet ?


TSkimteck
post Jan 8 2022, 02:48 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(ongss @ Jan 8 2022, 01:29 PM)
800mm + too-, some of the parts,  e.g. the ball bearing  drawer slides, are standard size.  Even disk washers that some people put below the kitchen counter are designed  around this size.
*
user posted image

The circled distance also 800mm +?
TSkimteck
post Jan 9 2022, 02:07 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(ongss @ Jan 8 2022, 08:04 PM)
Opp, I might have misunderstand your statement. I am too used to the idea of 800mm.

No, for that area, my current apartment is the same like the drawing i.e. 22" / 560mm.

The drawing is 27 11/16"  + 22" + 32 3/16" and mine is 30" (760mm) + 22" (560mm) + 33 7/8" (860mm actually 60 is for platform, the cabinet is 800mm tall only).

Previously, when I had that design, it was due to the height of the sliding door separate my kitchen from dining and living room. I think they will try to match the height of the door enter your kitchen and the cabinet.
*
I have 33 5/58" + 32 9/32 " (820mm) + 35 7/16" (100mm as platform). And I was blamed for changing their measurement..

This post has been edited by kimteck: Jan 9 2022, 02:08 PM
TSkimteck
post Jan 9 2022, 09:54 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(ongss @ Jan 9 2022, 05:54 PM)
820mm - I think that is too high even if you are using those pull down shelves.

You should ask her to fix it or you go to consumer tribunal to complain

https://www.kpdnhep.gov.my/en/consumerism/c...-procedure.html
*
I requested to change , same goes to gas stove countertop , 900mm, with wok stand height, my wok will be placed at 968mm , how to carry the stainless steel wok when cooking ?

Now saying I'm changing the drawings , so have to delay the project till the drawings is fixed. I am now the one being blamed by architect due to her 'no common sense ' design. Pity me

This post has been edited by kimteck: Jan 9 2022, 10:25 PM
TSkimteck
post Jan 13 2022, 09:00 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
QUOTE(5igzag @ Jan 11 2022, 09:36 AM)
engaging ID companies made me feel like I'm in dark, and they are the boss.

I don't have sufficient knowledge and ideas in renovation, that's why finding ID companies.
But they simply put sales person to give me rough quotation, without providing any useful feedback. Keep pushing to sign and pay few thousands only can start to get ID person onboard.
*
I have the same feeling with my current ID lady. If they make you feel so, stop the discussion and find the other one that you can negotiate and communicate like @sawhueijye mentioned.

TSkimteck
post Mar 7 2022, 07:09 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
Don't want to describe the details anymore. after 2 months, the small renovation yet to finish. And so many terrible workmanship , hack/install at wrong location, later simply touch up /cover with cheap materials.

Really "vomit blood" workmanship, and this ID company answered back you can't request so much, later the workers are not happy and purposely make it worse.

And I'm being blamed as a "demanding customer".

I don't know how many ppl is having a similar experience like me. But imagine you save for years buying a house then engage a ID company to do the renovation. Ended up bad workmanship with materials/ fittings that not worth the paid price.. then start arguing with no avail.

At the end, you just want to end the nightmare and give the money to chase them out from your house.

This post has been edited by kimteck: Mar 7 2022, 07:11 PM
TSkimteck
post Jul 1 2022, 02:00 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
42 posts

Joined: Jun 2013
After all the work, I have to fix many defects by myself. Even a sliding windows installation is leaking water when heavy rain. No more layan you after the full payment. Lesson learnt no 1. never get a one stop station to do the work unless they are very reputable and reliable. .

If you see some name with N**Y , remember my renovation experience.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0285sec    0.46    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 13th December 2025 - 02:46 AM