QUOTE(Wedchar2912 @ May 16 2023, 11:54 PM)
Implicit in your pdf example is that the return on capital (4%) is real rate of return.
Ie, what you are targeting is to have your portfolio earn a nominal return of of around 7% (= 4% real return + 3% inflation), if you are assuming inflation moving forward is 3%. If not, the npv of your portfolio will erode as time passes.
if you assume 5% inflation, then you are basically saying your portfolio needs to earn nominal return of 9%.
I think you now realize that 4% nominal return is not sufficient... need to take riskier investments.
To have a depreciating assets as time passes is harder to example, but would be easier to visualize using a excel spreadsheet. It is similar to calculating mortgage payment of each month and where the payment goes to: reducing outstanding balance or interest payment.
thanks for your reply. in all honesty i find the reported inflation rate on yearly basis a bit unpredictable and rather hard to gauge. furthermore some items goes down too instead of up albeit more on increase rather than decrease though. but i understand your point.
but to argue further, it should be inflation rate on the spending rather than an outright 7-9% return on savings. so it should be 4% + (4% * 4%) = 4.16% the following year and continue on subsequently, no?
QUOTE(dwRK @ May 17 2023, 12:11 AM)
food 500 per month too low typo probably... i family dinner on mother's day ald 800...
traveling i assume is vacation also too low imho...
angpow money and such?
additionally can budget say 5k per year for whatever.... phone, pc, tv, etc...
yes i forgotten to factor in ang pow and phone/pc replacement say once every 3-5 years.
fyi i got my ip7 from launch and still using it although i think it's time for a change.
travelling is meant for local travel and the "upgrade" which has a factor of RM6k per annum allows me to travel yearly somewhere below that threshold or travel somewhere <rm12k every 2 years. does that make sense?
QUOTE(CommodoreAmiga @ May 17 2023, 08:20 AM)
Do you have paid off properties you can collect rentals? Is your spouse still working? Some of the items are too low...RM500 for food
..how many people eat? Pork prices are crazy nowadays. Normal chicken also exceed RM20 seekor, don't even think kampung chicken . Seafood no need to say. Not enough bro, even for 2.
I am already retired...and I can tell you food you need RM 1.5k at least (not kira fancy restaurants dining). Travelling? Not sure what is that...if vacation cuti cuti Malaysia also very difficult. Recently went Japan Horiday...about RM15k per pax.
paid off props - yes
stocks with divvy yield - yes
but not intending to muzzle the already complicated calculation hence only concentrating on return from cash instead.
and forgot to mention, everything is based on individual for the time being.
as the saying goes, help yourself before helping others.
QUOTE(dwRK @ May 17 2023, 08:20 AM)
??? 4% return on capital
he just doing the 4% spending rule in reverse... instead of savings * 4% = spending... he doing savings = spending / 4%
yup. with the slightly higher opr, FD rates are going back to 4% ish and EPF is 5% ish or more.
am taking 4% just to be prudent without taking into account other riskier return which carries some risk of decreasing my capital