All your tires are having almost same thread pattern. Nothing too aggressive with big ribs. So not surpring ps4 took the lead.

I think for overall performance. Meaning low noise, good wear rate, good grip dry n wet, etc best should be michelin ps4 d. Only bad is price factor, quite expensive.

If you are like me, dont care noise, dont care so much wear rate, only wan super dry grip, acceptable wet and cheap. Then can try this sumaxx. Basically all i care about is grip and price.

In comparison, i think in dry grip my sumaxx should be same or better than your ps4. I cant be sure but im comparing with ps3, and the sumaxx feels much grippier in dry grip than ps3.

For your size, sumaxx can get for rm210. Yours rm350 per tire.