You are going out of context of the main topic. It's not about the question of Deductible options. But rather to address options to reduce cost in the event of increase in Cost of Insurance.
What are the options available to you as a policy holder? you either:-
1. Pay the higher premium to maintain the similar benefit
2. Downgrade the plan if there is a lower plan to reduce the premium
3. Downgrade the plan by applying deductible / co-insurance.
Overall, you'll be paying more - one way or another. In other words, if you pick option 2 or 3, you'll be enjoying an inferior quality of your original plan by subjecting yourself to pay additional on top of what is supposedly covered entirely by the insurance company.
Let's take an example.
John pays RM200 monthly for his insurance with no deductible. Now, John is advised to pay RM360 monthly to maintain his benefits. John does not want to pay more and opt for deductible. Now John pays RM250 monthly but with a deductible of RM3,000.
Scenario 1. (Before the increment)
Surgery Cost RM100,000
John yearly premium RM2,400 (200 x 12)
John medical plan - RM0 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM2,400.
Scenario 2. (After the increment)
Nothing happens to John this year
John yearly premium RM3,000 (250 x 12)
John medical plan - RM3,000 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM3,000 (+25%) of the original 2400 premium.
Scenario 3. (After the increment)
Surgery Cost RM100,000
John yearly premium RM3,000 (250 x 12)
John medical plan - RM3,000 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM3,000 + RM3,000 =
RM6,000 (+250%) of the original 2400 premium.
In other words, at any point of time, if there is no claims, you are already paying +25% higher premium. If there is a claim, your cost would shoot up to +250%
##################
Let's take the forummer's suggestion here to keep "increasing" the deductible higher as the cost increases to maintain the same or lower premium.
Scenario 1. (Before the increment)
Surgery Cost RM100,000
John yearly premium RM2,400 (200 x 12)
John medical plan - RM0 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM2,400.
Scenario 2. (After the incremenet)
Nothing happens to John this year
John yearly premium RM3,000 (250 x 12)
John medical plan -
RM10,000 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM3,000 (+25%) of the original 2400 premium.
Scenario 3. (After the incremenet)
Surgery Cost RM100,000
John yearly premium RM3,000 (250 x 12)
John medical plan -
RM10,000 deductible.
John's cost for that year RM3,000 + RM10,000 =
RM13,000 (+541.67%) of the original 2400 premium.
In other words, at any point of time, if there is no claims, you are already paying +25% higher premium. If there is a claim, your cost would shoot up to +541.67%
I don't think anybody mentioned anything about "keep increasing the deductible higher" just to avoid paying the revised premiums for sustainability.
Besides, I hope you can also help enlighten me as well as all of us here, which company in which round of medical rate hike, increased any of their cost of insurance by 80%?