Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Prudential vs Great Eastern: My Experience, Not all insurance companies are the same

views
     
prophetjul
post Sep 6 2019, 01:30 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(wirelessdude @ Sep 5 2019, 09:32 AM)
Background:
I was a non-believer in insurance, mostly due to the aggressive way it's sold, up until I was 30 years old. Then a friend became a Prudential agent and I bought a medical card to support him, which also included life and critical illness protection, and very minimal investment.

Then I started freelancing and also bought a house and a car, so I thought of increasing my insurance - in case something happened to me, the insurance would pay off the loans. Still having doubts about the ethics of insurance companies, I decided to buy extra life and critical illness protection from Great Eastern this time to "diversify the risk".

Over the years, I increased my insurance protection and also bought insurance, including a 15-year education savings which I regret, for my 2 sons. I also started a company that grew to almost 100 people and have been buying company group insurance from Great Eastern - paying a premium of about MYR 70,000 a year.
Critical Illness:
Last year, I was diagnosed with a heart condition that was covered under the critical illness insurance. Due to my fitness level, I was able to undergo non-invasive keyhole surgery (more advanced, less painful, recover faster, smaller scar) to repair my heart, instead of the conventional open-heart surgery where they saw your chest bone and open up your chest.
Claims:
Upon discharge, I submitted all the neccessary reports and documents to both agents and on the SAME DAY. This was what happened:

Prudential
- the agent told me Prudential will respond within 14 working days.
- within that period, Prudential sent me an SMS saying the claim was successful.
- the money was paid into my bank account 2 days later.

Great Eastern
- the agent said don't know how long the process will take.
- a week later GE asked for "certified" docs, which were copied and submitted by their own agent.
- a week later, I was asked to complete a questionnnaire, including which other insurance company I bought from.
- then my claim got rejected.
- GE says based on the policy, I MUST undergo an open-chest surgery to qualify.

My agent was stunned and my cardiologist literally said "what the fuck?". My agent appealed and got rejected - twice. Finally, I wrote a long email to express my disappointment and detailed my entire journey with GE, comparing it with Prudential. My email was escalated two levels up ...and then NO REPLY for a whole month.

Then my surgeon wrote another report and appealed to them. Finally, my claim was approved but GE proudly emphasized that they were ONLY doing it out of goodwill.

I promptly terminated and switched my company group insurance to Prudential. I also did the same with my son's insurance.
Buyer Beware:
It's companies like GE the reason why I never trusted insurance companies. Even my insurance agent who had been selling GE for 13 years was unaware of such a clause, hidden in the fine print.

The insurance policies are supposed to cover us until 100 years old. So between now and then, if there's a new and more advanced medical treatment, we still can't use it because it's not covered under GE's archaic policy?

Over the 13 years, my insurance agent has sold over 500 policies. But including mine, he has only made 3 CLAIMS for critical illness/life to date!

Other issues that I had with GE, was with their online access which didn't work and customer support which takes a minimum of 3 business days to respond, e.g. "we will transfer your request to the relevant department". Seriously? In this day and age of Internet speed? In my last interaction with them, they took 1.5 MONTHS to reply "due to sudden surge of volumes of email" (I wonder why), by which time I'd totally given up.
Conclusion:
Be careful when buying insurance - it's easy to buy but difficult to claim. Based on my personal experience, I would highly recommend Prudential instead (for now). The PruWaiver that I bought meant my son's premium will now be borne by Prudential. My premium will also be borne by them and paid towards my cash value until my policy expires at 100 years old.
*
Yes. Prudential is better at handling claims. Professional.

My experience with Great Easter many years ago was they tend to put lots of hurdles to your claim and fine print as they can.
Its just a rubbish insurer. Enough said!
prophetjul
post Sep 6 2019, 01:37 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(WaCKy-Angel @ Sep 5 2019, 02:28 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

Hi just to share my story also about GE.

They seems trying very hard to reject claims by using many excuses/reasons. But i was able to fight for it and won it after a few phone calls with their "supervisor".

Just FYI if they trying to be funny, just tell them u will report to OFS (Ombudsman for Financial Services) and BNM (Bank Negara Malaysia).
Their services are FREE u do not need to pay anything, they will help u to deal with the insurance company.
*
Sounds like GE!

thumbup.gif
prophetjul
post Sep 6 2019, 01:44 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(wirelessdude @ Sep 5 2019, 02:07 PM)
user posted image

How many of us are actually given the opportunity to go through the entire document before we sign? It's the same in Malaysia for SPA, will, loan agreements, etc.
*
What is this Risk Commencement Date and date of reinstatement?

Did you pay your premiums late or something?
prophetjul
post Sep 6 2019, 01:52 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(muscaa @ Sep 6 2019, 01:50 PM)
Yes. GE is very old fashioned. You gotta pay premium through their agent. Very inconvenient
*
Is that so??????????

Maybe operated by Chinaman. biggrin.gif

Biz first. Customer last.
prophetjul
post Sep 6 2019, 03:04 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(wirelessdude @ Sep 6 2019, 02:55 PM)
That's how we were all sold the policy but it's clearly not the case. Hence, the point of this post to create awareness.
*
Yeah

I do not recall anything about the method of treatment.
Once you are diagnosed, you can already apply for the funds. At least that was how they told us.
prophetjul
post Sep 11 2019, 09:01 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(drindy @ Sep 10 2019, 09:41 PM)
Actually the critical illness definition in Malaysia is streamlined across all life insurance companies.

Based on this individual story, I would think that the claim made under Prudential is medical claim while the claim made under Great Eastern is the Critical Illness claim.

While medical claim will cover the surgery cost, critical illness policies stated explicitly that keyhole surgeries is excluded for coronary artery by-pass surgery. This would be the same even for any other life insurance companies in Malaysia, including Prudential.

I would say that the agent does not understand the policy well and did not provide the appropriate advice. Getting the right agent is very important.
*
I thought Critical Illness is paid out upon confirmed diagnosis of any of the 36(?) illnesses stated in the policy.

Only Medical cards will likely has exclusions of type of treatment.
prophetjul
post Sep 11 2019, 09:04 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(wirelessdude @ Sep 10 2019, 10:17 PM)
Perhaps you should read the thread in its entirety before commenting. I claimed for both medical and critical illness under Prudential.
*
Did Prudential pay your claims for both policies?
prophetjul
post Mar 12 2021, 10:37 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

35 years ago, i heard of complaints about insurance calims made to GE....slow and drag and then reject.

Seems 35 years on, its still the same GE.


prophetjul
post Mar 30 2021, 08:44 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

Great Eastern Life issues. Hahahaha! thumbup.gif 30 years ago was like this. Nothing changes with GEL laugh.gif

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The High Court here has recorded a consent judgment between a 42-year-old cancer patient and an insurance company in a RM2.5mil lawsuit she filed against the latter.

In the judgment recorded before Judicial Commissioner Liza Chan Sow Keng here on Monday (March 29), businesswoman Tan Siew Wei and Great Eastern Life Assurance (Malaysia) Bhd achieved a full and final settlement in one of the two insurance policies she is claiming for.

In the settlement, a sum of RM500,000 was to be paid by the defendant to Tan as a full and final settlement of all the claims and demands which Tan has against the defendant, in respect to the particular policy.

Tan, who was diagnosed with Stage 4 cervical cancer in 2019, had sued the company for rejecting her critical illness insurance claims on allegations that she had broken the policy clause with a non-disclosure on her mental state, where she was diagnosed with an anxiety attack in February, 2017.

She is suing the company to claim for RM500,000, which is the basic sum assured from the first life insurance policy, and another RM2mil, the basic sum assured from her second life insurance policy.


The court ordered for the settlement sum to be paid before April 1 and did not make any order as to costs.

Neither party would have any further claim against the other after the settlement is completed. The policy shall be terminated with all the benefits and rights provided under the policy to cease.

Tan's lawyer Ng Kian Nam said hearing for the RM2mil policy continues on April 14.

In the statement of claim filed on Aug 12, last year, Tan said she bought the first policy in 2015 from Great Eastern with a half a million basic sum assured and a monthly premium of RM600 payable for 20 years.

In 2018, she signed up for a second policy with a RM2mil basic sum assured and a monthly premium of RM1,666.70 payable for 61 years.

Before entering into the agreement on both policies, Tan said she had truthfully filled in her information in the forms and made full disclosures in line with the Financial Services Act on her health, including declaring that she did not have depression or anxiety at all material times.

On Dec 27,2018, the plaintiff said she gave birth to her fourth child at a private hospital in Cheras and the next year, she was diagnosed with cancer.

She subsequently made insurance claims on critical illness from the defendant, as well as other insurance companies where she had bought life insurance policies.

Tan claimed that all of the companies have compensated her, but Great Eastern had repudiated both her policies and returned her monthly premiums on grounds that she had made a non-disclosure, had a psychology consultation and had been diagnosed with anxiety attack.

In Great Eastern's statement of defence, the defendant said it had assessed and processed the plaintiff's insurance claims and found that the plaintiff did not have the right to the basic sum assured under the policies.

It claimed the plaintiff had a psychological consultation history on April 17,2014.

It further claimed the plaintiff was diagnosed with anxiety attack and was prescribed Xanax on Feb 13,2017.
The defendant claimed that Tan had consulted with another doctor on Feb 16,2017, and complained about an infection in her body.

"The defendant found that the plaintiff had the illness and is aware of the illness as early as February, 2014.

"She, however, failed to disclose the diagnosis, treatment or the illness in her forms," it added.

Great Eastern said it had rejected the plaintiff's claims through its letters dated June 18,2019 and returned her premiums via direct credit.

"Therefore, the defendant's rejection of liability on the plaintiff's claim was valid, lawful and justifiable," it said.

Lawyers Wong Hok Mun and Chris Lim appeared for the defendant in the proceeding.

https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2021...ompany#cxrecs_s


prophetjul
post Mar 30 2021, 11:35 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(lifebalance @ Mar 30 2021, 10:58 AM)
prophetjul busy fanning the flames?  innocent.gif
*
Look at the thread title.

And this news happen to come out in the kopitiam.

SHARING IS CARING! laugh.gif
prophetjul
post Mar 30 2021, 01:47 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(hedfi @ Mar 30 2021, 01:25 PM)
Agent butthurt
*
Ha....i am no insurance agent. I am a 60 year old senior engineer with nothing better to do, GE agent! laugh.gif
prophetjul
post Mar 30 2021, 02:21 PM

10k Club
********
All Stars
12,268 posts

Joined: Oct 2010

QUOTE(hedfi @ Mar 30 2021, 02:10 PM)
Sorry, didn't mean you but the person that you replied to ☮️
*
OOOppss.....i am sorry. But i really am a 60 year old senior engineer. icon_rolleyes.gif

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0134sec    0.51    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 2nd December 2025 - 12:38 PM