Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Foreign Tenant Background Screening

views
     
edyek
post Jun 4 2019, 05:00 PM

Business Rating :
*******
Senior Member
3,820 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
From: Land of the Hornbills & Land Below the Wind


QUOTE(hanhanhan @ Jun 4 2019, 12:21 AM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


airbnb, simply put, is short term rental. Thus airbnb guests are deemed to be tenants in the eyes of the law.

you, as the proprietor (property owner), surrender full access of usage of your parcel (unit) together with the rights of a parcel owner (right to use the common facilities subject to the management's house rules & regulations) for a certain period of time (number of days' stay). During their stay, you legally do not have any right to access the property or the common area (as you have already surrendered the right of usage to your tenant/airbnb guest).

an airbnb guest is no different from a monthly/yearly tenant in the eyes of the law. They are considered a 'tenant', and airbnb guests are regarded as 'short term tenant'.

The definition of 'short term rental' is not defined under the law, however the municipal council passed the baton to the building management to come up with their own definitions.

You can check in the Deed of Mutual Covenants (most, if not all, of the condo/apartment/serviced apartment/ gated & guarded landed strata houses has one) whether short term rental is forbidden by the Developer & subsequently adopted by the JMB/MC upon their formation.

Licensee, however, refers to a 'guest' in layman terms. If you ask ur friend to come into your condo, he is an visitor/invitee/licensee (which means the same under the law) who has mere access to your unit (or the common area) but no exclusive access to it (meaning he can't lock you out of your house without you getting pissed off)

a tenant/licensee/invitee/visitor ceases to be one, once they no longer have your permission or consent, whereupon they will become trespassers.

A lessee however legally means someone who has leased the property/building/land for a term exceeding 3 years, and has the right to register his lease onto the individual title/strata title of the property.
*
QUOTE
airbnb, simply put, is short term rental. Thus airbnb guests are deemed to be tenants in the eyes of the law.

I don't think you are right in your definition.

Airbnb like you say is short term rental or short let BUT in exchange for PAYMENT and/or CONSIDERATION.

As a Tenant, you will have tenancy agreement.

As a Tenant with short term rental usually referring anything less than 1 year tenancy under tenancy agreement. Still a TENANT.

As a Guest (not the kind of guest which your friend come over to spend a night for free; it is ESPECIALLY referring to "guest in exchange for payment and/or consideration on a temporary basis for a period of short consecutive days and where such occupation is not subject to residential tenancy agreement or lease"), it is also refer to as "PAYING GUEST".
Therefore you will have a short let for business purposes. Hence, this is where AirBnB comes in. Strata residential properties does not "accomodate" paying guest hence many JMB try to outlaw it.
Like you say. AirBnB refers them GUEST BUT NEVER will be deemed as "TENANTS".

It is a can of worms that AirBnB opens thus there are many such cases popping out. But to refer generally as what I've mention as above, residential properties are not allowed for short let business.

A very good example, whereby Kota Kinabalu has passed a (SHORT LET) BY-LAWS, 2017 of CITY OF KOTA KINABALU ENACTMENT 1998
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT ORDINANCE, 1961 (No. 11 of 1961). Which DEFINES as per below :-
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


So in a nut shell, any short let business carry out in RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES is illegal here in Kota Kinabalu. Although some are still running it and the enforcement is still lacking.

I think other cities/towns in Malaysia should follow suit like what Kota Kinabalu city council did (maybe some other cities have already did? I dont know). This is the best way to prevent any further misinterpretation and leading to court cases or misuse of any short let business under residential properties.

A very well detailed court decision on the link provided by aurora97
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

Anyhow, please feel free to correct me. Cheers.

This post has been edited by edyek: Jun 4 2019, 05:13 PM
edyek
post Jun 5 2019, 11:47 PM

Business Rating :
*******
Senior Member
3,820 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
From: Land of the Hornbills & Land Below the Wind


QUOTE(hanhanhan @ Jun 5 2019, 08:06 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


i disagree with the judgement and definition.

once i win another case to change the law then i'll update u.
*
QUOTE(hanhanhan @ Jun 5 2019, 08:10 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


govt doesn't want to enact a tenancy act to address this , as lots of stakeholders are involved in this (heck, even their ownselves or their family members).

hence the dirty work is being passed to the JMB.

I've done many cases to bypass whatever the JMB has thrown at my client. HMU if you require consultation for your homestay strategy.
*
Of course if the land title is commercial usage and the "residential" was built on commercial title for commercial usage, then it is not illegal. Thus JMB cannot outlaw it.

Please do update if you have any news. This is a good thing for the pubic to be aware of.
edyek
post Jun 6 2019, 12:09 AM

Business Rating :
*******
Senior Member
3,820 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
From: Land of the Hornbills & Land Below the Wind


QUOTE(aurora97 @ Jun 5 2019, 11:56 PM)
The decision of a court typically stands until they are overruled by either a superior court or legislation through parliament. Even if a decision isn't favourable, it stands.

So for those reading and those providing their views, we should always present our case based on prevailing authorities (despite differing views).

Aside from the above, I think its also pertinent that one does not make baseless allegations/assertions without first providing source or reference.
*
thumbup.gif notworthy.gif Couldn't have say it any better. You should have type this in your last post. So I won't type so much kok. tongue.gif

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0193sec    0.64    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 14th December 2025 - 12:39 AM