I'm total car newbie, i'm just eyeing getting a new axia base model manual is fine by me. But somehow i see just by topping up around 5-6k from axia base model i can get Iriz second hand with around 25-30K mileage and its a auto transmission . Axia have a way better fuel consumption but iriz safety feature kinda won me over? Which is better? why does iriz cost so cheap compare to myvi second hand btw.

there's no radio in axia e.
does that tell you anything?

for iriz, if you can, get the manual transmission. better fuel efficiency, better acceleration, instant throttle response. and the gear feel is great too.

life or fuel efficient more important.
After you know the answer, you will not need to ask this type of question.

Very true.

tunggu Iriz 1.0 turbo

Comparing new to 2nd...top up a bit can get BMW 5 series 2nd hand...true story.

Your first goal is always New car.
2nd hand car is like a gamble. If problematic, more money come out.
But if good, than you lucky.
Used car also bank interest higher. Look at it that way.

Unless there is a specific reason for you to get a 2nd hand car, like axia too small, your family can't fit, or you are thinking safety concerns, or you are too fat and axia doesn't look good with you, or you love iriz looks, etc.
Means you die die wanna buy iriz instead of a new car with same price.

Like I go buy car, New Hrv and Used CRV also same price.
If Hrv already OK with me, I sure buy that Hrv cos its new.

This post has been edited by azbro: Jan 22 2019, 07:34 AM

Get brand new Iriz 1.3MT instead.....ada ESC and way2 b3tter handling than axia

But /k all about RV...

kek

The new facelifted Iriz will not feature 1.0 turbo TGDI engine from Geely. It has been confirmed by paultan.

The new 1.0 &1.5 turbo TGDI will only be fitted in X50

Iriz imo. But for 2nd car, you know what to do. Have to check thoroughly.

MT for legend drivers, not for noob

checked the price at paultan..

axia 22k
iriz 40k

so depends on ts budget... of course, spec to spec, iriz better.. but if take iriz, how about myvi manual? hahah

new myvi has an awful manual gearbox.....get auto instead if you want myvi

kia picanto gt line

iriz is safer

Axia is the moving coffin, your choice

your life so cheap..

it will depends what are u using the car for
city = axia
highway = iriz

Agreed this
But axia G variant.

love life = iriz
love resell value/fuel efficiency = axia

Perodua handling all sampah.

But kelisa handling very good

No radio. No rpm meter

1st 1 week u will like heck year why do i need radio and rpm in a basic car.

The 2nd week onward. Fark why did i choose this. P2 mde my life feel terrible and feel so poor

True story

This post has been edited by maxizanc: Jan 22 2019, 08:36 AM

If u ok with crappy penumbuk cvt & drone sound go with iriz..handling syiok + stable car..make sure u got some one experience with car to check that car before buy
If ok with tin milo body just go with axia. Fuel consumption very jimat. Buy new no need pikir2 if anything happen with car

Ts u are considering a used car better pick used myvi than an Iriz

Tupop a bit get s90

but used myvi is a moving coffin unless opt for used facelift myvi then can suggest

You buy a antique Toyota KE70 or 1992 Honda EG 4 door also better than any produa cars, because you only have 1 life and you can't shop for a leg or arm in the pharmacy. So go for Iriz else used waja or city.

Facelift one la. 23- 25k can get la.

Avoid axia e at all cost.

i've check carlist

the facelift myvi dont have between 20k-30k, only 40K above(mostly new or showroom model)

Both car ok. You just need to decide your purpose for the car. Both can fo for city drive or highway drive & fuel effiecient is depending on the person handling. If you do F1 like drive surely fuel not efficient. Budget, Safety feature (examlple ASEAN NCAP crash test) & engine type is the only difference. Just do your research.

This one? Is facelifted right

https://www.carlist.my/used-cars/2012-perod...-new-12/5163210

that one is pre-facelift model
i meant the new model launch in 2017.

that one is pre-facelift model
i meant the new model launch in 2017.

If u don't mind manual, please get Iriz manual. The auto is crap, jerky, noisy and worrying long term durability.

Especially if u can find 1.6L manual, the extra torque and power over 1.3L really makes it worthwhile.

test drive the new picanto then you will know

Dude avoid this model, this 1 got no ABS and EBD. Get 1 with SXi or EZi under the Myvi badge.

2nd hand Iriz FTW. Accident or fall from bridge, A pillar still intact, door still can open & passenger could get out fine.

And KL there a lot of noobies pondan driving auto 😇

Yes pls buy second hand BMW like the e60 or e90. No regret.

What's your size? I find Axia very crampy, haha. I understand your dilemma, contemplating btwn better specced Iriz and affordable Axia. Although Iriz is more compelling since it gives better value for money and has more safety features, it would be more exhausting for your financial condition. Meanwhile, Axia is cheap for being cheap. For Axia, it's a gamble for losing out many features especially safety-wise. However, u wont use the safety features like airbags all the time, no? Iriz? It's there when u need it, the airbags, vsc etc. For me, i would compromise on safety, so im more flexible financially, as long as u drive safely, the absence safety features have literally no effect. dont know about you...

Sad thing in Malaysia cars are pricey and stingily specced

Btw, how about Kia Picanto? A segment nimbility with B segment specs@ around RM50k

there is a reason iris selling at 20000km and at lower price.

i believe people nowadays or proton supporter will say that axia is not safety.. but look at the testing result.. it has 4 star ncap rating while iris is at 5... yes one star ahead but then again it at different segment

This post has been edited by mykazza: Jan 22 2019, 09:09 AM

Iriz have ESC

I have Axia and Saga at home, both A segment car, and both cars are rewarded with 4 stars.
I felt more safe inside of the Saga, Axia feels kosong.

bezza or aruz le

wow. stupidest shit i've read this morning..

Axia for me. Older 1st gen iriz tends to be rough. Like really rough

why not considered 2nd hand manual iriz instead?

Kia picanto

Ya. Even Mazda SUV can drop off some bridge. So...

calling people stupid without a valid reason more like you the one that is stupid, be realistic in comparison look at new axia price and compare with axia 20k km used. and compare iris new price and 20k km used. the reason of this due to unsatisfied owner like you who say proton is way better because of proton steel and frame.. they are 2 different company with 2 different mindset while proton looking into old technology like saga/iswara with heavy metal body and bad fc... and perodua with lighter body with good fc

not even gonna argue with that much stupidity spewing from your mouth.

your logic of 4 star vs 5 star ncap rating not a big difference between axia and iriz is enough to prove it.

then u just stupid for not understanding what the segment difference is..

I m axia owner g spec auto standard own fr 3years this car sucks on safety n stability. Fuel consumption wise minimum can achieve 14-17km/l never trust 21km advertise on their brochure is impossible to achieve. Car rattle every where even car seat rattle spring broken. Axia is super-duper under power going up genting with three to 4 passengers like not enough energy car keep on rev up n down n keep on change gear. Rear passenger always complain on air-cond cannot feel the air-cond even set to 3 out of 4 during hot weather. Good thing abt this car so far did not breakdown n is easy fr parking if u r single n drive n city shud be OK. If u r fat n always drive highway this car is not fr u I wud choose new persona at least more power n safer extra power better incase u need to fetch more people. Proton quality now is better perodua car now mostly have rattle around the place even new Myvi too

Said many times before

If you dont need interior space and you dont mind just a slight drop in fc

Kia Picanto all the way

If you drive like mad go for Iriz, if drive like granny go for axia. You cant go wrong with iriz handling.

His budget seems <rm30k, either new Axia E or used auto Iriz.

Which i find odd. If he willing to consider buying manual, I'd recommend used Iriz 1.6MT.

But yea, previous gen Picanto manual also pretty good, most comfortable and quiet at least. But none on mudah now, unless TS is in Sarawak :

https://www.mudah.my/2015+Kia+PICANTO+1+2+M...EH-71562925.htm

new facelift Iriz is coming. You can get discounts of 2018 models which may goes well with your budget too.

Safety - Win
Looks - Win
Space - win
Price - moderate

https://www.mudah.my/2018+Proton+IRIZ+1+3+C...CK-71205227.htm

Yup, that's a no brainer. Better get that. Best reply.
But ads you know lah, later go there different price.

If ur you look at financial prospective, need a vehicle that can bring you to point a to b and love manual than auto like me then axia basic is the best choice..

If ur looking for top safety and space then go for other model..

Im my self using axia basic model..been using it for 2 years already...very happy with it, install android car player now can waze without using semakphone. No cental lock also but im ok with it wait till warranty over before install one. The best thing is the car is cheap i go for 5 years loan only and that mean low intrest compare to ahem2 9 years loan

kesian iriz now compared to axia. how come cannot compare with myvi anymore?

new price axia vs 2nd price iriz ma

if compared to myvi pre-facelift price, please dont...
safety tarak, R&H tarak, NVH also tarak

Like you said it is different segment. Even if Axia get 5-stars also will be less safe than Iriz's 5-stars, simply because it is a smaller car.

what is pre facelift myvi? there is only the current myvi - no facelift, its a new generation model.

anyway goes to show how useless the iriz is. cant even fight in its proper category anymore.

4 month ago,i buy used iriz 1.6mt..no regret..myvi?..meh..my car 100x better than Ferrari..

This post has been edited by wira_laju: Jan 22 2019, 11:27 AM

u dont compare axia with iriz

myvi with iriz

haiyo TS also never do research, take the LRT la

noobs like McDBigMaC need to ask himself simple question: U mau pening kepala or not?

Tak nak pening kepala, tak payah fikir2 beli jer perodua

If always scared as if everyday kena accident then go jumpa bomoh mandi bunga buang suewey bad luck jin from ur body

yup need brand new axia to compare with 2nd hand iriz (price wise)

soon brand new Aruz also need to compare with 2nd hand X70

that's how topkek a brand can becum if losing big trust from rakyat

Iriz is not as bad as what people mentioned. Fuel consumption also reasonable with full tank going 450km. My mother Iriz has so far not given any problem to her and we are really happy with the car (of course discount matters). Service centre in Ipoh also really helpful during first service only took us 2 hrs with upgrade service centre. Driving wise, it is a pleasure for the price you pay.

I think this is the most sensible answer. It really depends of the driver driving habit.

Fuuuh, congrats and nice u got the 1.6MT

Angkat new myvi 1.3L can kawtim already

Takyah susah2 takyah pening2

4 airbags VSC jimat minyak reliable all under 50k

ya factors to consider when purchasing New and 2nd Hand Car..

IMHO i would look for second hand 1.6 variant mt Iriz, but of course the mileage will be quite high and very rare to find.

manual car in klang valley?
good luck.

I driven manual car for 5-6 years in klang valley and PJ. No complain