Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Add Reply RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 CFM, SKMM no reply, LCP terminated by peer

views
     
TSAnime4000
post Dec 13 2018, 12:13 PM, updated 7y ago

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
Yesterday TM called say, problem is fixed, but I check, still same!
it simply cannot use 8Mbps + 512kbps at the time,

this issue since 12/Oct, until now.



I do have Self Hosted Cloud and some cheap CCTV to access remotely.

List device and layout I use:
1. INNATECH-W7100N (borrow from kawan)
2. Riger DB120WL (modem TM)
3. Asus DSL-AC52U (i bought 2!)
4. ZTE ZXHN H267A (borrowed from technition TM)
5. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Windows 7 (Share PPPoE)
6. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Ubuntu 18.04 (pppd, NAT, iptables)
7. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + pfSense
8. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Linksys EA7500
9. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + NEC UNIVERGE IX2105 [PPPoE fail]

This post has been edited by Anime4000: Dec 13 2018, 12:18 PM
JuneResources
post Dec 13 2018, 02:56 PM

ONE Stop Resources
*******
Senior Member
4,167 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
From: Kuala Lumpur
What means of LCP?
JohnLai
post Dec 13 2018, 03:13 PM

Skeptical Cat
*******
Senior Member
3,669 posts

Joined: Apr 2006
QUOTE(JuneResources @ Dec 13 2018, 02:56 PM)
What means of LCP?
*
Link Control Protocol.

His DSLAM pppoe server has issue. Maybe hardware or software related. Only TM can 'solve' it.
dcheah
post Dec 13 2018, 03:32 PM

OldSkool
******
Senior Member
1,455 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
From: Kajang
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Dec 13 2018, 12:13 PM)
Yesterday TM called say, problem is fixed, but I check, still same!
it simply cannot use 8Mbps + 512kbps at the time,

this issue since 12/Oct, until now.



I do have Self Hosted Cloud and some cheap CCTV to access remotely.

List device and layout I use:
        1. INNATECH-W7100N (borrow from kawan)
        2. Riger DB120WL (modem TM)
        3. Asus DSL-AC52U (i bought 2!)
        4. ZTE ZXHN H267A (borrowed from technition TM)
        5. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Windows 7 (Share PPPoE)
        6. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Ubuntu 18.04 (pppd, NAT, iptables)
        7. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + pfSense
        8. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + Linksys EA7500
        9. INNATECH-W7100N/Riger DB120WL (Bridge) + NEC UNIVERGE IX2105 [PPPoE fail]
*
I am assuming that 8Mbps & 512Kbps is a totally different account & packages, and I noticed you are also running pfsense thus I also assumed that the LCP is configured in the pfsense. Then it should works out of the box if your configuration in pfsense is correct.

But I'm very confused of the total ADSL line you have there, possible to share a drawing of your network diagram so I can have more understanding, then from there also maybe I can find the bottleneck/root cause.

LCP is not control by TM nor do they block any, as I've 2 Unifi account + 1 Maxis + 1 TIME in the office here. Configured with LCP + QoS, the only difference here is I'm using VyOS instead of pfsense. But it should work regardless if its pfsense or not.

Do share the network diagram (briefly) to understand how your network is connected.
hmm.gif
TSAnime4000
post Dec 13 2018, 06:40 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(JohnLai @ Dec 13 2018, 03:13 PM)
Link Control Protocol.

His DSLAM pppoe server has issue. Maybe hardware or software related. Only TM can 'solve' it.
*
My ASUS Modem Router has log, so, it print remote initiate disconnect, useful to disconnect if user not paying the bill

QUOTE(dcheah @ Dec 13 2018, 03:32 PM)
I am assuming that 8Mbps & 512Kbps is a totally different account & packages, and I noticed you are also running pfsense thus I also assumed that the LCP is configured in the pfsense. Then it should works out of the box if your configuration in pfsense is correct.

But I'm very confused of the total ADSL line you have there, possible to share a drawing of your network diagram so I can have more understanding, then from there also maybe I can find the bottleneck/root cause.

LCP is not control by TM nor do they block any, as I've 2 Unifi account + 1 Maxis + 1 TIME in the office here. Configured with LCP + QoS, the only difference here is I'm using VyOS instead of pfsense. But it should work regardless if its pfsense or not.

Do share the network diagram (briefly) to understand how your network is connected.
hmm.gif
*
I use iperf v2, 2 Upload + 2 Download at same time, to simulate busy day, like having HypptTV (UnifiTV), 3 PC, many smartphone, have some FTP upload, cloud sync, etc...

Last year, never have this problem, it happen at 12/Oct, really ruin the day, cannot use TV, only 1 PC at the time, I had to tell everyone, stay off wifi, and limit bandwidth to 6mbps DL, 100kbps UP.

There are no Bottleneck, new cable, new copper cable, even bought 2 same Asus modem, both give same result

This post has been edited by Anime4000: Dec 13 2018, 06:41 PM
dcheah
post Dec 24 2018, 04:24 PM

OldSkool
******
Senior Member
1,455 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
From: Kajang
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Dec 13 2018, 06:40 PM)
My ASUS Modem Router has log, so, it print remote initiate disconnect, useful to disconnect if user not paying the bill
I use iperf v2, 2 Upload + 2 Download at same time, to simulate busy day, like having HypptTV (UnifiTV), 3 PC, many smartphone, have some FTP upload, cloud sync, etc...

Last year, never have this problem, it happen at 12/Oct, really ruin the day, cannot use TV, only 1 PC at the time, I had to tell everyone, stay off wifi, and limit bandwidth to 6mbps DL, 100kbps UP.

There are no Bottleneck, new cable, new copper cable, even bought 2 same Asus modem, both give same result
*
Still no idea what's your network like, if you really want to do load balancing the easy way, try (https://www.peplink.com/) products.

Their load balancer is very good & highly recommended, else try VyOS.
TSAnime4000
post Dec 25 2018, 01:22 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(dcheah @ Dec 24 2018, 04:24 PM)
Still no idea what's your network like, if you really want to do load balancing the easy way, try (https://www.peplink.com/) products.

Their load balancer is very good & highly recommended, else try VyOS.
*
this happen,
Attached Image
dcheah
post Dec 31 2018, 04:28 PM

OldSkool
******
Senior Member
1,455 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
From: Kajang
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Dec 25 2018, 01:22 AM)
this happen,
Attached Image
*
WOW.... it did disconnects very often & re-connect back. It seems like packet drop just like that.

During the test, is there any other computers or network devices running ?

Maybe we can try the following :-

1. Disconnect all computers from the network (including wifi devices too).

2. Disconnect all WANs.

3. Connect 1st WAN first, & see is there any drops.

4. Disconnect 1st WAN & connect 2nd WAN, & see is there any drops or not.

5. Then try both WANs connections, is there drops or not.

6. Then start to connect each network devices, 1 at a time slowly & monitor it closely.

7. Lastly is the computers & wifi devices, also 1 at a time.


Somehow I think its still the configuration issues.

A. Another thing to take note also, the incoming cable for that ADSL, is it new ? I mean from outside into your home.
B. Do you have those ADSL Splitter installed ? If yes, try removing it.


Let me know your test results...
TSAnime4000
post Dec 31 2018, 10:11 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(dcheah @ Dec 31 2018, 04:28 PM)
WOW.... it did disconnects very often & re-connect back. It seems like packet drop just like that.

During the test, is there any other computers or network devices running ?

Maybe we can try the following :-

1. Disconnect all computers from the network (including wifi devices too).

2. Disconnect all WANs.

3. Connect 1st WAN first, & see is there any drops.

4. Disconnect 1st WAN & connect 2nd WAN, & see is there any drops or not.

5. Then try both WANs connections, is there drops or not.

6. Then start to connect each network devices, 1 at a time slowly & monitor it closely.

7. Lastly is the computers & wifi devices, also 1 at a time.
Somehow I think its still the configuration issues.

A. Another thing to take note also, the incoming cable for that ADSL, is it new ? I mean from outside into your home.
B. Do you have those ADSL Splitter installed ? If yes, try removing it.
Let me know your test results...
*
1. Yes, only test pc is connected

2. Done

3. Done

4. Done, no error, no drop

5. Yes

6. Yes... it will disconnect when I reached 8mbps bandwidth

7. I use Asus DSL-AC52U, Vyos, pfSense, ClearOS, NEC IX 2105

A. TM Technition just change to new copper cable, FOR FREE (they want close my case as fast as possible)

B. It's direct connection, see how good my SNR Margin
Attached Image

It just happen,

Every time I use 8mbps available bandwidth, PPP LCP from TM send a Disconnect Request, and PPP Client had to accept, I thinking to exploit PPP by ignore Disconnect request, stay connected all the time

Dont believe Asus Logging, I have Wireshark results:
Attached Image

To visualise:
Attached Image

YES, DSL is stable 100%
see this video...


Issue since 15-Oct-2018
miloaisdino
post Jan 1 2019, 11:54 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
maybe try ask them to increase your dsl cap to 12000kbps, then qos your connection to max out at 8mbps

it might work
TSAnime4000
post Jan 2 2019, 08:04 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 1 2019, 11:54 AM)
maybe try ask them to increase your dsl cap to 12000kbps, then qos your connection to max out at 8mbps

it might work
*
I tried to ask them to increase 10240kbps to 12000kbps, TM wont allow it sad.gif
currently I using QoS Bandwidth Limiter, at 6mbps, even I set exact 8mbps, there will have disconnect
miloaisdino
post Jan 2 2019, 08:09 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Jan 2 2019, 08:04 PM)
I tried to ask them to increase 10240kbps to 12000kbps, TM wont allow it sad.gif
currently I using QoS Bandwidth Limiter, at 6mbps, even I set exact 8mbps, there will have disconnect
*
really? maybe u hv to get thr technician to do it then... last time kopi duit all can dunno now still can ornot haha
miloaisdino
post Jan 2 2019, 08:10 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
how about changing your mtu value?
TSAnime4000
post Jan 2 2019, 10:55 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 2 2019, 08:09 PM)
really? maybe u hv to get thr technician to do it then... last time kopi duit all can dunno now still can ornot haha
*
I also tried duit kopi, but he said everything is recorded, so he cant open more

QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 2 2019, 08:10 PM)
how about changing your mtu value?
*
I tried, 1492, 1480, even 1446

PPPoE LLC
ATM 31*48 Full Cells 1488
AAL5 Trailer -8
PPP -2
PPPoE Header -6
Ethernet Header+FCS -18
LLC Header -8
Optimal Layer 3 MTU 1446

https://whirlpool.net.au/wiki/ADSL_Theory_PPP
https://www.sonicwall.com/en-us/support/kno...170505851231244

None of them are working, TM still sending termination request to ppp client after long use of 8mbps bandwidth

here the log I made my self, using vyos as router:
CODE
[2019-01-02 03:33:37]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.211
[2019-01-02 03:40:10]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.211
[2019-01-02 03:42:31]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.195
[2019-01-02 03:45:41]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.178
[2019-01-02 03:49:01]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.178
[2019-01-02 03:51:51]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.174
[2019-01-02 03:59:11]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.3
[2019-01-02 10:58:27]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.3
[2019-01-02 11:02:17]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.55
[2019-01-02 11:05:27]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.16
[2019-01-02 11:07:47]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.103
[2019-01-02 11:10:37]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.220
[2019-01-02 11:13:17]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.198
[2019-01-02 11:20:08]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.70
[2019-01-02 11:25:48]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.9
[2019-01-02 11:29:18]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.107
[2019-01-02 11:31:38]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.57
[2019-01-02 11:34:08]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.57
[2019-01-02 11:36:28]: pppoe0 inet is 124.13.107.94
[2019-01-02 11:38:58]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.35
[2019-01-02 11:42:18]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.57
[2019-01-02 11:44:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.86
[2019-01-02 11:46:48]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.72
[2019-01-02 11:49:09]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.36
[2019-01-02 11:54:19]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.24
[2019-01-02 11:56:39]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.27
[2019-01-02 12:00:49]: pppoe0 inet is 124.13.107.83
[2019-01-02 12:03:29]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.106
[2019-01-02 12:05:39]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.3
[2019-01-02 12:11:59]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.4
[2019-01-02 12:14:49]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.105
[2019-01-02 12:17:00]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.192
[2019-01-02 12:21:20]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.182
[2019-01-02 12:23:40]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.182
[2019-01-02 12:25:50]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.102
[2019-01-02 12:28:50]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.37
[2019-01-02 12:32:40]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.205
[2019-01-02 12:35:40]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.61
[2019-01-02 12:38:30]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.108
[2019-01-02 12:49:51]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.221.165
[2019-01-02 12:52:41]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.174
[2019-01-02 12:56:01]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.208
[2019-01-02 12:58:11]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.2
[2019-01-02 13:01:11]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.174
[2019-01-02 13:03:21]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.57
[2019-01-02 13:06:01]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.3
[2019-01-02 13:08:11]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.44
[2019-01-02 13:10:31]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.206
[2019-01-02 13:13:01]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.84
[2019-01-02 13:16:22]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.234
[2019-01-02 13:18:32]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.92
[2019-01-02 13:22:12]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.170
[2019-01-02 13:27:22]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.30
[2019-01-02 13:29:42]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.170
[2019-01-02 13:31:52]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.9
[2019-01-02 13:40:53]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.22
[2019-01-02 13:43:03]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.113
[2019-01-02 13:47:03]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.136
[2019-01-02 13:49:43]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.209
[2019-01-02 13:55:13]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.28
[2019-01-02 13:58:53]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.215
[2019-01-02 14:01:03]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.231
[2019-01-02 14:03:23]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.20
[2019-01-02 14:06:53]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.119
[2019-01-02 14:09:14]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.200
[2019-01-02 14:15:54]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.119
[2019-01-02 14:18:44]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.131.21
[2019-01-02 14:21:04]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.8
[2019-01-02 14:23:54]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.192
[2019-01-02 14:26:24]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.81
[2019-01-02 14:30:24]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.103
[2019-01-02 14:33:54]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.103
[2019-01-02 14:36:14]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.62
[2019-01-02 14:40:45]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.82
[2019-01-02 14:43:05]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.106
[2019-01-02 14:45:35]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.150
[2019-01-02 14:47:55]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.173
[2019-01-02 14:51:25]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.246
[2019-01-02 14:55:05]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.147
[2019-01-02 15:01:55]: pppoe0 inet is 60.49.49.4


The script I use:
CODE

#!/bin/bash

# filename: stress.sh
# call: bash stress.sh
# os: vyos 1.2.0

killall -9 iperf 2> /dev/null

echo "[INFO]: Hello!"

while :
do
sleep 10s

if ip link show | grep -q pppoe0; then

 if pidof iperf > /dev/null; then
  echo "[INFO]: pppoe0 is up and iperf is running"
  continue
 else
  echo "[INFO]: connection restored! waiting..."
  sleep 30s

  echo "[$(date +'%F %T')]: pppoe0 inet is $(ip addr | grep 'pppoe0' | tail -n1 | awk '{print $2}')" >> pppoe0.inet.log

  echo "[INFO]: iperf is executing..."
  iperf -c server.vultr.vps -p 8080 -t 600 -d -P 3 &
 fi

else

 echo "[WARN]: pppoe0 is down!"
 killall -9 iperf 2> /dev/null

fi
done



Since they monitor my PPPoE dial activity, I do this when no one use internet
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 01:36 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
today up time

CODE
[2019-01-03 01:32:46]: pppoe0 inet is 60.49.49.4
[2019-01-03 01:35:06]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.12
[2019-01-03 01:38:16]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.113
[2019-01-03 01:41:36]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.113
[2019-01-03 01:46:57]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.203
[2019-01-03 01:50:07]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.148
[2019-01-03 01:52:37]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.249
[2019-01-03 01:55:17]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.249
[2019-01-03 02:02:27]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.249
[2019-01-03 02:04:47]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.141
[2019-01-03 02:07:17]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.141
[2019-01-03 02:09:37]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.100
[2019-01-03 02:12:07]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.100
[2019-01-03 02:14:18]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.42
[2019-01-03 02:17:38]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 02:20:18]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.188
[2019-01-03 02:22:48]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.224
[2019-01-03 02:25:08]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.92
[2019-01-03 02:27:18]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.224
[2019-01-03 02:30:18]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.91
[2019-01-03 02:35:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.53
[2019-01-03 02:40:08]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.138
[2019-01-03 02:44:59]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.25
[2019-01-03 02:47:39]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.91
[2019-01-03 02:49:49]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.203
[2019-01-03 02:52:49]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.97
[2019-01-03 02:55:49]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.116
[2019-01-03 02:57:59]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.116
[2019-01-03 03:00:19]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.203
[2019-01-03 03:07:09]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.240
[2019-01-03 03:09:29]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.240
[2019-01-03 03:13:10]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.204
[2019-01-03 03:15:20]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.4
[2019-01-03 03:17:40]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.178
[2019-01-03 03:21:50]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.147
[2019-01-03 03:24:50]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.27
[2019-01-03 03:27:00]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.80
[2019-01-03 03:30:20]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.172
[2019-01-03 03:32:30]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.172
[2019-01-03 03:34:50]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.172
[2019-01-03 03:37:00]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.163
[2019-01-03 03:40:01]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.163
[2019-01-03 03:42:11]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 03:44:31]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.138
[2019-01-03 03:47:41]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.161
[2019-01-03 03:50:01]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.12
[2019-01-03 03:53:51]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.171
[2019-01-03 03:56:11]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.12
[2019-01-03 03:58:41]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.12
[2019-01-03 04:01:41]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.79
[2019-01-03 04:08:12]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.79
[2019-01-03 04:11:32]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.138
[2019-01-03 04:13:42]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.214
[2019-01-03 04:17:02]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.50
[2019-01-03 04:19:12]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.50
[2019-01-03 04:21:32]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.243
[2019-01-03 04:23:52]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.243
[2019-01-03 04:26:02]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.26
[2019-01-03 04:28:22]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.172
[2019-01-03 04:30:32]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.108
[2019-01-03 04:34:12]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.1
[2019-01-03 04:36:22]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.82
[2019-01-03 04:38:43]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.123
[2019-01-03 04:42:33]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.215
[2019-01-03 04:45:43]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.215
[2019-01-03 04:51:03]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.124
[2019-01-03 04:53:13]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.124
[2019-01-03 04:55:43]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.190
[2019-01-03 04:58:03]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.248
[2019-01-03 05:01:33]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.190
[2019-01-03 05:05:14]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.214
[2019-01-03 05:07:24]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.214
[2019-01-03 05:10:44]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.221
[2019-01-03 05:15:24]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.185
[2019-01-03 05:17:44]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 05:20:14]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 05:23:34]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 05:25:54]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.14
[2019-01-03 05:28:44]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.78
[2019-01-03 05:33:25]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.95
[2019-01-03 05:38:05]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.9
[2019-01-03 05:41:15]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.106
[2019-01-03 05:43:35]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.164
[2019-01-03 05:46:15]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.176
[2019-01-03 05:49:05]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.58
[2019-01-03 05:51:25]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.96
[2019-01-03 05:53:35]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.119
[2019-01-03 06:02:16]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.203
[2019-01-03 06:04:26]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.105
[2019-01-03 06:06:46]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.227
[2019-01-03 06:10:46]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.167
[2019-01-03 06:14:16]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.10
[2019-01-03 06:16:36]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.190
[2019-01-03 06:18:46]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.143
[2019-01-03 06:21:46]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.106
[2019-01-03 06:24:36]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.232
[2019-01-03 06:27:36]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.29
[2019-01-03 06:30:27]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.170
[2019-01-03 06:34:07]: pppoe0 inet is 124.13.107.84
[2019-01-03 06:37:57]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.90
[2019-01-03 06:42:57]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.39
[2019-01-03 06:45:37]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.245
[2019-01-03 06:48:37]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.89
[2019-01-03 06:54:07]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.134
[2019-01-03 06:58:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.27
[2019-01-03 07:00:48]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.19
[2019-01-03 07:05:58]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.125
[2019-01-03 07:09:18]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.71
[2019-01-03 07:11:58]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.12
[2019-01-03 07:15:48]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.82
[2019-01-03 07:18:28]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.153
[2019-01-03 07:20:38]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.64
[2019-01-03 07:23:18]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.222
[2019-01-03 07:25:29]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.44
[2019-01-03 07:30:09]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.211
[2019-01-03 07:34:19]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.197
[2019-01-03 07:36:39]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.162
[2019-01-03 07:40:39]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.148
[2019-01-03 07:42:59]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.249
[2019-01-03 07:45:09]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.6
[2019-01-03 07:47:29]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.210
[2019-01-03 07:55:20]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.131.49
[2019-01-03 08:00:00]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.115
[2019-01-03 08:02:10]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.103
[2019-01-03 08:09:40]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.81
[2019-01-03 08:12:20]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.42
[2019-01-03 08:16:00]: pppoe0 inet is 124.13.107.85
[2019-01-03 08:18:10]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.38
[2019-01-03 08:21:51]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.24
[2019-01-03 08:26:11]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.211
[2019-01-03 08:28:21]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.16
[2019-01-03 08:30:51]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.78
[2019-01-03 08:33:51]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.13
[2019-01-03 08:37:01]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.106
[2019-01-03 08:39:21]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.79
[2019-01-03 08:42:11]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.183
[2019-01-03 08:45:11]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.151
[2019-01-03 08:47:52]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.200
[2019-01-03 08:50:02]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.136
[2019-01-03 08:53:22]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.41.195
[2019-01-03 08:55:32]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.136
[2019-01-03 08:57:52]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.239
[2019-01-03 09:00:42]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.89
[2019-01-03 09:03:22]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.240
[2019-01-03 09:05:52]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.97
[2019-01-03 09:08:22]: pppoe0 inet is 124.13.107.68
[2019-01-03 09:12:02]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.229
[2019-01-03 09:14:12]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.92
[2019-01-03 09:16:53]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.237
[2019-01-03 09:20:03]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.199
[2019-01-03 09:22:23]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.102
[2019-01-03 09:24:43]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.184
[2019-01-03 09:29:53]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.82
[2019-01-03 09:32:33]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.204
[2019-01-03 09:34:43]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.235
[2019-01-03 09:37:43]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.221.210
[2019-01-03 09:42:54]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.192
[2019-01-03 09:45:04]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.113
[2019-01-03 09:47:44]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.252
[2019-01-03 09:50:34]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.208
[2019-01-03 09:53:14]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.252
[2019-01-03 09:55:24]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.110
[2019-01-03 09:57:44]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.131.107
[2019-01-03 10:00:34]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.134
[2019-01-03 10:04:34]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.2
[2019-01-03 10:08:44]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.118
[2019-01-03 10:11:05]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.229
[2019-01-03 10:15:35]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.118
[2019-01-03 10:19:55]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.73
[2019-01-03 10:22:05]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.150
[2019-01-03 10:24:15]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.212
[2019-01-03 10:26:35]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.156
[2019-01-03 10:35:45]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.17
[2019-01-03 10:38:06]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.240
[2019-01-03 10:40:26]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.85
[2019-01-03 10:42:36]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.27
[2019-01-03 10:45:56]: pppoe0 inet is 60.48.218.228
[2019-01-03 10:52:06]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.221.187
[2019-01-03 10:55:06]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.130
[2019-01-03 10:57:36]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.137
[2019-01-03 11:01:16]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.69
[2019-01-03 11:05:27]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.102
[2019-01-03 11:08:27]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.221.156
[2019-01-03 11:12:27]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.63
[2019-01-03 11:14:57]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.184
[2019-01-03 11:17:57]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.176
[2019-01-03 11:20:07]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.188
[2019-01-03 11:23:07]: pppoe0 inet is 60.54.127.245
[2019-01-03 11:25:17]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.145
[2019-01-03 11:28:37]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.130
[2019-01-03 11:30:47]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.170
[2019-01-03 11:33:08]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.115
[2019-01-03 11:36:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.199
[2019-01-03 11:38:58]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.4
[2019-01-03 11:41:18]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.103.22
[2019-01-03 11:43:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.23
[2019-01-03 11:47:48]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.234
[2019-01-03 11:51:28]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.68
[2019-01-03 11:58:18]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.123
[2019-01-03 12:01:19]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.10
[2019-01-03 12:04:39]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.166
[2019-01-03 12:06:59]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.36.248
[2019-01-03 12:09:09]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.228
[2019-01-03 12:14:29]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.7
[2019-01-03 12:16:49]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.209
[2019-01-03 12:18:59]: pppoe0 inet is 203.106.191.12
[2019-01-03 12:23:59]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.79
[2019-01-03 12:27:50]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.146.192
[2019-01-03 12:31:00]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.26
[2019-01-03 12:33:20]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.22.155
[2019-01-03 12:35:40]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.244
[2019-01-03 12:37:50]: pppoe0 inet is 110.159.102.117
[2019-01-03 12:40:50]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.8
[2019-01-03 12:44:00]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.1
[2019-01-03 12:46:10]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.129
[2019-01-03 12:48:30]: pppoe0 inet is 1.32.126.90
[2019-01-03 12:54:51]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.127
[2019-01-03 12:57:01]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.215.52
[2019-01-03 12:59:41]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.235
[2019-01-03 13:01:51]: pppoe0 inet is 115.135.63.113
[2019-01-03 13:05:31]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.219.153
[2019-01-03 13:07:41]: pppoe0 inet is 115.134.254.117
[2019-01-03 13:10:21]: pppoe0 inet is 175.144.54.145
[2019-01-03 13:13:01]: pppoe0 inet is 118.100.56.239
[2019-01-03 13:15:11]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.117
[2019-01-03 13:18:11]: pppoe0 inet is 175.137.74.24
[2019-01-03 13:20:21]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.7
[2019-01-03 13:23:02]: pppoe0 inet is 175.140.148.19
[2019-01-03 13:28:02]: pppoe0 inet is 118.101.23.62
miloaisdino
post Jan 3 2019, 01:47 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
good job taking all their ip addresses haha
JohnLai
post Jan 3 2019, 02:16 PM

Skeptical Cat
*******
Senior Member
3,669 posts

Joined: Apr 2006
Just asking.....have you ever change the streamyx login password before?
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 02:32 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 3 2019, 01:47 PM)
good job taking all their ip addresses haha
*
hahaha yeah, TM 04:25:c5:96:f7:63 (Huawei Telekom) keep rejecting my internet sessions

QUOTE(JohnLai @ Jan 3 2019, 02:16 PM)
Just asking.....have you ever change the streamyx login password before?
*
Yes, I change many time
SilentVampire
post Jan 3 2019, 02:41 PM

Networking Enthusiast
*******
Senior Member
5,714 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
That is crazy. You are being disconnected and reconnected multiple times. Stupid question, but did you ever try using another modem router, and another cable? Just remove everything on your current network and use a different modem router, and a different cable, and see if that changes things.
miloaisdino
post Jan 3 2019, 02:46 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
how about find a way to force them to switch port for u?
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 05:03 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(SilentVampire @ Jan 3 2019, 02:41 PM)
That is crazy. You are being disconnected and reconnected multiple times. Stupid question, but did you ever try using another modem router, and another cable? Just remove everything on your current network and use a different modem router, and a different cable, and see if that changes things.
*
Technician change new outdoor - indoor copper, for FREE
Technician lend me ZTE ZXHN H267A, same problem
Technician lend me Riger DB120WL, same problem
I bought 2 Asus DSL-AC52U, same problem.

Using Modem Bridge - Router:
1. NEC IX2105, cannot connect, improper peer PPPoE Implementation Protocol
2. Asus DSL-AC52U, still disconnect
3. pfSense, still disconnect
4. VyOS, still disconnect
5. ClearOS, still disconnect
6. Windows 7 Pro with Wireshark, still many disconnect!
CODE
Wireshark filter: pppoe || pppoed || lcp || pap || ipcp

Attached Image
As you see, without Asus Syslog, Wireshark tell the same, around 5 minute of 8mbps, 04:25:c5:96:f7:63 asking PPP client to disconnect... I just... WTF!?

is there any filter or capable to drop certain PPP LCP request? been 3 month TM no answer and no idea what to do.

I tried to ask for rebate, they say case need to complete then can rebate, currently I paying the full bill

As SKMM report, still on going
Attached Image


QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 3 2019, 02:46 PM)
how about find a way to force them to switch port for u?
*
Technician come to my house from 10AM until 5PM, he change the each port, get DSL reading, high as 30dB, Att low as 8.6dB

I tried change password, still the same.


28/Dec/2018, TM from Seremban (not regular technician) come to my house, also check, and they also no Idea what cause 04:25:c5:96:f7:63 asking to terminate PPP client, they say my VPS server is problem, I told them I try using 4G, can hold 1 hour of iperf! I dare them to host iperf on any Unifi, I can guarantee it will disconnect

Today, I cant connect anymore, PPP error, cannot find port! I guess 04:25:c5:96:f7:63 banned me from connecting, since too many disconnect-reconnect...

ADSL already ancient technology for 2019, clearly TM no longer maintain ADSL or fix

This post has been edited by Anime4000: Jan 3 2019, 05:09 PM
miloaisdino
post Jan 3 2019, 05:19 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,418 posts

Joined: Jul 2015
i meant change port on the dslam side?
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 06:11 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(miloaisdino @ Jan 3 2019, 05:19 PM)
i meant change port on the dslam side?
*
Yes, Technician move my port from #4 to #255
even swap with other 8mbps user port
the problem not fix
SilentVampire
post Jan 3 2019, 07:45 PM

Networking Enthusiast
*******
Senior Member
5,714 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Jan 3 2019, 06:11 PM)
Yes, Technician move my port from #4 to #255
even swap with other 8mbps user port
the problem not fix
*
Sad to hear that. There must be an issue with your line. There is probably degradation somewhere.
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 09:53 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(SilentVampire @ Jan 3 2019, 07:45 PM)
Sad to hear that. There must be an issue with your line. There is probably degradation somewhere.
*
I check, not only me are effected, I tried many house, just they didnt notice disconnect
SilentVampire
post Jan 3 2019, 10:12 PM

Networking Enthusiast
*******
Senior Member
5,714 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
QUOTE(Anime4000 @ Jan 3 2019, 09:53 PM)
I check, not only me are effected, I tried many house, just they didnt notice disconnect
*
It must be a site-wide issue then, and they might have botched the installation of the physical infrastructure. Your only hope is that they start laying new fiber infra and decommission the current copper cables.
TSAnime4000
post Jan 3 2019, 10:56 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(SilentVampire @ Jan 3 2019, 10:12 PM)
It must be a site-wide issue then, and they might have botched the installation of the physical infrastructure. Your only hope is that they start laying new fiber infra and decommission the current copper cables.
*
hahaha, I agree... no point to maintain copper infra

this my year 2010-12-19 showtime, 1483 hours!
Attached Image

This post has been edited by Anime4000: Jan 3 2019, 10:56 PM
neuromancerx
post Jan 4 2019, 12:07 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Junior Member
879 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
im afraid nothing can be done from your side, action is more on the provider side.

https://www.garethjmsaunders.co.uk/2014/03/...care-after-all/

anyway, kudos to your testing methodology, networking gear and tools involved.
TSAnime4000
post Jan 4 2019, 01:22 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,399 posts

Joined: Jul 2009
From: /dev/null
QUOTE(neuromancerx @ Jan 4 2019, 12:07 AM)
im afraid nothing can be done from your side, action is more on the provider side.

https://www.garethjmsaunders.co.uk/2014/03/...care-after-all/

anyway, kudos to your testing methodology, networking gear and tools involved.
*
yeah, is TM fault,
that link tell he have same problem like me, hahaha,

what I read, TM need increase more overhead for Down and Up Stream, because 1492 packet will get split into tiny ATM Payload, which is increase more overhead and out of sync
System Error Message
post Jan 4 2019, 02:32 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,781 posts

Joined: Jul 2010
It is TM's fault. Unlike some ISPs i know, no ISP in malaysia maintains more than 1 PPPOE server and link per area, this means there are no redundancies and TM's PPPOE servers have a history of unreliability. Unlike with 1 ISP in the UK which i connected to 2 simultaneously improving my DSL throughput a little and with traffic going through whichever server was faster at the time as you also have load to consider.

2 possible cases for TM's problem, either their link is overloaded or their server is overloaded. This is why you are getting disconnects, and another possibility, poor server configuration which is to be expected in malaysia as they regard IT very poorly.

Also i find SKMM never respond, they are very ineffective, would rather just give the TM CEO a bad day instead in a more direct way.

Unless people start flinging eggs at TM's upper management or just peacefully protest outside their properties and send them peaceful physical messages, not emails or texts , maybe just overfill their house mailbox with angry letters as well, it should get them to change the way they run things at TM, because they always screw the customer over. I havent even gotten my turbo which was promised last year and am paying more than 300 a month. I need that extra upload that the turbo brings.

Reading further, you can write a script on asus routers using rmerlin firmware to ignore the disconnect request, it will take some research.

This post has been edited by System Error Message: Jan 6 2019, 11:26 PM
« Next Oldest · Networks and Broadband · Next Newest »
 

Add ReplyOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
 0.0269sec    0.96    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 28th November 2025 - 08:30 PM
All Rights Reserved © 2002- 2025 Vijandren Ramadass (~unite against racism~)
Removal Request
Powered by Invision Power Board © 2025  IPS, Inc.