Hi here I come again, the long waited roundup that we mention to do earlier. Well...lets cut the crap and proceed to the roundup


Test Bed:
Processor: Intel C2D E6700 L628A303 @ 3.2GHz @ 1.368 Vcore
Mobo: Asus P5B 0701
Memory: Team Xtreem Micron D9GMH DDR2 Special OPB Edition
Graphic Card: XFX 6600 GT
PSU: FSP Fortron Epsilon FX700-GLN PSU
HDD: Maxtor 20GB IDE 5400 RPM Hard Drive


Contenders:
1. Tuniq Tower 120
2. Scythe Infinity
3. Scythe Ninja
4. Scythe Mine
5. Scythe Andy Samurai Master
6. Thermaltake Big Typhoon VX
7. Silverstone NT05


Software Used:
Everest Ultimate Edition 2006
Orthos Beta
Windows XP SP2


Test Method:
1. This time I have gotten myself a temperature probe to measure the ambient temperature and we found out that the ambient actually fluctuating a lot. The result will include the ambient temperature as well for better judgment. The result might not be 100% accurate as it might be affected by the mounting method, temperature fluctuations and user error.

2. The Fan speed is kept at the speed of 1600 rpm as the main objective of this test is to find out the best heatsink that can be operate in silent mode.

3. The Idle Temperature is measured after the system left open for 5 minutes and the Load Temperature is measured after 10 minutes of Orthos Stress. Everest Ultimate Edition 2006 was used to get the value of the temperature for each of the criteria, idle and load.

4. This test will be a open bench like what we did on the first roundup, TIM that is used is Arctic Ceramique also as it doesn't need any curing duration. This time the amount of TIM that I applied will be slightly more as many forumer mention that the amount that I applied is too little.

5. The mounting mechanism that will be used in this roundup will be the original mounting mechanism.


Disclaimer:
This roundup is only conducted to show how is the new heatsinks in the market perform under the power hungry cpu and to help some folks to decide which heatsink they should get. The result is vary and subjective, the same heatsink used might work fine on your rig but not on mine. So please dont flame me when the heatsink doesnt work on what u expected



Picture of the amount of TIM that is applied this time


This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 10:19 AM

Scythe Andy Samurai Master

This heatsink featuring 6 thick heatpipes that is connected from the thin shinny copper base to large area of aluminium fins and is blown by a 120mm fan. The fan is provided by the scythe but it was not used as the same fan (SS FM121) will be used in the roundup for all the heatsinks. Lets go the the pictures now


The TIM was spreaded pretty big area eh


The base of the heatsink


Scythe Infinity

Namely the highest end heatsink that is provided by the Scythe, they have 10 heatpipes. The introduction of this heatsink is on the v1 roundup, plz check it out there. so now lets go straight to the pictures


The vanilla cream spreaded pretty evenly as well^^


The Base


This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 10:19 AM

Scythe Ninja

Lets go straight to the pictures as the introduction has been done on v1


Close shot of the TIM spreaded on the CPU


The heatsink base....

Scythe Mine

Another heatsink that is featured in v1. So lets go to the eye candy


Nice pressure applied


The base


This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 10:19 AM

Thermaltake Big Typhoon VX

Another v1 heatsink. This is not the same heatsink that is tested in the v1 roundup and I found out that this heatsink doesnt really provide contact as good as the one in the v1. I wonder why... So lets go to the main point






Silverstone NT05

Got this little heatsink for free during a lucky draw in a LanParty^^. It was laying in my cupboard so i just take it out and run a test on it. It a small heatsink but I am sure it work like a charm compared to the Intel stock heatsink. It provided dam nice pressure as u see in the picture. When the fan ran at full speed, about 4500 rpm. the temperature is on par with the gigantic heatsink, just that its a bit noisy


Dont be suprised:)




This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 10:20 AM

Tuniq Tower 120

Namely the king of air cooling for more than 1 year. Have discovered about this heatsink 1 year back but got scared by the size of it that time. This heatsink is build to kill, the physical quality of it is superb. When I first gotten it I asked myself "WHY DIDNT I GET IT WHEN I FIRST SAW IT!!!!". If I have gotten it that time i wouldnt have to go through so many hassle to keep changing the heatsinks
Oh Well... This king uses 6 heatpipes only and it has a lot of thing and nice shaped fins. The fan is installed into the middle of the heatsink. They call this as midship convention. There is not clearance problem for me but mounting it sometime might be a pain in the ass. especially when u doin it in the casing Ok here is the eye candies


Very balance pressure applied I must say


It look like it spreaded in dam small area, actually its not, it just that the base is too big

This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 06:52 PM

Results


Results for v1


New Result

Conclusion

I am sure you guys noticed that why is there so many Scythe heatsink featured. Make no mistake I am not sponsored, so I wont be siding any party. All heatsink were contributed by the forumers. This might be the last air cooling roundup that I will be conducting as I am moving to watercooling soon^^. Hope you guys find this roundup helpful for choosing the heatsinks and don't scold me if you guys find that its useless


PS: For v1 Roundup please proceed to v1 Roundup, thanks for viewing

This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 10:32 AM

actually the NT-05 can perform much better if the fins were soldered to the heatpipe.....

for such a compact cooler, it definitely can be considered good isnt it ?

yeah good pressure and good performance but in a high cfm fan la.... 4k man... dam noisy

Great roundup!

That's what I thought. TTBTVX couldn't possibly be better than the rest (in V1 roundup). V2 is logically more accurate I believe.

I had wished a noctua would have been included.

BTW, how is it that you people are living in a 20-21'C ambient temp??? Not cold aaaa?

This post has been edited by kmarc: May 31 2007, 01:15 PM

it was 20 - 21 coz i on my aircond....adjust the temp to the lowest...u see the tuniq.... the ambient raised coz i cant tahan and go and off the aircond liao
well ttbt vs is really a good hsf la.... it just that this one didnt give enough pressure

This post has been edited by sup3rfly: May 31 2007, 01:34 PM

sup3rfly,

mind doing a passive test between each tower sinks?

Thanks

dont think most of them can run passively.... as the tuniq also will fail if running passive + prime...summore all the hsf give back to ppl already... >.<

finally the results.... hmmm, seem like TTBT VX still can hold on its own. actually thinking of getting Tuniq but you mention its big.. how big actually? the size big because of 12cm fan built inside?

well the dimension of it is around a size of a normal psu....but dun worry there is not clearance issue between the mobo unless ur casing is too small

Ya, I know the TTBT is a good HSF. It was one of my choices when I was deciding on which HSF to buy (couldn't get other HSF due to my mobo's different layout). Finally went for the Noctua as it has a silent setup.

That's why I was hoping that the Noctua was included....

hey, im thinking of getting scythe infinity...
my oni concern is weather my mobo can take the weight? how is the mounting for it?

the mounting same like the stock cooler...clip type..

make sure it wont block your psu intake and interfere with rams..
because my ninja is blocking psu's intake and nearly block 1st DIMM slot..
take note mine is ninja, not infinity. and also bear in mind, infinity is bigger than ninja..

** ignore this if you have a big big casing such as gigabyte 3D aurora 570 or other full-tower casing.

-adios-

ic... thx, my 2nd worrry, can my mobo take the stress? its quite a heavy thing...

there's already a thread about this. try to search around..
but IMO, scythe's older mounting mechanism (which using the backplate) is more secure.. those 4-pins looks not reliable to hold the HS on the mobo

** ops, a bit offtopic here.. sorry

-adios-

This post has been edited by Are_keem: Jun 1 2007, 01:04 AM

The Scythe Andy Samurai Master on the review belongs to me and I used it before I get myself a Noctua U12F. Trust me.. Even though, it used those push pin method as its mouting but it is very tight and put damm alot of pressure. Back plate mounting only needed if your heatsink is real heavy.

the tuniq tower 120 has 3 heatpipes, not 6
p.s. please keep the thread cleaned. its only been a day and there has already been so many useless posts here

This post has been edited by DaRkSyThE: Jun 1 2007, 03:03 PM

erm..i also got confused with the heatpipe def actually. at CM webpage, for hyper 6+ they claim it got 6 heatpipe.but when i count, it only three...
very2 confused la....

well.....3 heatpipes but 6 contact point to the fins

Try to see and compare both of this test:-

http://xbitlabs.com/articles/coolers/displ...ex_5.html#sect0

http://www.frostytech.com/articleview.cfm?...eid=2082&page=3

with the fan 1200rpm, i think Thermalright Ultra-120 eXtreme is the best of all

well, good thread about heatsinks and fans..

I got questions though,

i've bought a new Celeron D 420 @1.6GHz (socket 775)

after installed it, i've found out that my computer suddenly shut down automatically.

so i run a few test to check which hardware that cause the problem and found out that the CPU is the cause of the sudden shut down. below are my test results:-


Activity CPU Temperature (in degrees)

1) MP3, watch DVD, open Microsoft Office 38 - 50 (my pc still work out fine)

2) playing games, install new software >65 (and my pc will suddenly shut down)

thus, my question is, can you give me any suggestion what heat sink and TIM can I use for my CPU overheat problems and what are the prices?

do I need to upgrade the system fans too? if so what system fans do you suggest?

and lastly, any other solutions that you can suggest?

Thanks, and really appreciate if you can give suggestions ...

is the infinity original mouting cannot support its weight and cant put enuf pressure?

@all
why dont someone test the CM Hyper 212 heatsink, i personally think its good.

yes i agree..coz i'm the hyper 212 user

This post has been edited by sukatra_aicaca: Feb 3 2008, 03:41 PM

need help here..anyone here use tuniq tower 120?

want to know will it affect my mobo if its on vertical?which mean in the casing..coz its heavy(768gm!)and summore,the clip for am2 doesnt look promising..afraid will break anytime

i have the idea.. lend me ur tuniq.. maybe can mod the clip from sumting2 from Uni bengkel..haha

thats a good idea..tomorrow mybe the clip will arrive...then u came to my house and take a look at it

r u sure sampai??.. tomorow going back seremban la.. then go kl.. then late nite sunday only at here

ala..tau la busy skang...i think so..ive banked him another rm5 for things that is not my fault...he text me this morning..----sent it---- thats all..haha...tuniq already a month in my hand..now berhabuk already

what another rm5 for his mistake??
nak kena dia nie

This post has been edited by xixo_12: Feb 14 2008, 06:05 PM

what to do bro..kena tindas saje...i
ve been nice to them,but they step on my head..

http://www.tomshardware.com/2008/02/20/cpu...er_charts_2008/

hmm this thread needs to be focused on cooling topics... by the way CM hyper 212 works really well with push-pull strategy.

guys..
wanna ask about suitable fan that can be mounted on our hsf..
is it really better to mount a fan with higher rev compared to lower one??
ive read sumwhere that high rev fans can cause low presure air around the hsf, causing less efficient heat transfer..
dun know this true or not..hope sifus can help me verify this..

thx

high rev doesn't mean high air flow... high air flow also doesn't mean better cooling performance as u need sufficient time for heat to transfer from the hsf to the air... u need to see the specification of the fan.. there got show the air flow volume... hope that helps...

air flow volume is denoted as cfm in fan's specs rite?
but like u said, sufficient time is required for heat transfer..
so does it means that we have to find the balance between air flow rate and time of the heat transfer?
sory if my question is difficult to answer..
got free time, so i do some thinking about how to maximize cpu's air cooling so many ideas popped out

http://www.xigmatek.com/product/air-hdts1283.php

why xigmatek put air pressure value in specs for d product above?

thx

what i meant is ... there is a maximum airflow effect for every cooler... even if u put a higher cfm fan the performance of cooling doesn't increase.. like i have 2 x silverstone fm121 fans on my ifx-14 cooler... i turn the fan up to 60% and above gives the same results... erm.. how do i say this.. pressure... more pressure = better as more pressure allows more air to be moved through the resistance more easily...

owh..ur explaination are same with my theories
thx alot for ur explaination

but i will do some test la..i will mount my panaflo fans to my sigmatek hsf..
see how is d difference..
tomolo i'll report

V3 coming?

Can anyone tell me what's the best low profile heatsink for i7 ? =P

AXP140?

Questions!!!!!!!!!!
What is the thermal compound ice fusion... is it better??

i've used ice fusion before. not recommended for users with room full of dust coz it tends to get polluted by dust when u open the cap. better buy those in syringe type. my 2 cents