QUOTE(KLthinker91 @ May 22 2019, 11:37 PM)
Vulnerable areas are more spread out, the ship might be less structurally affected, damage control capability would be much higher. So you might be able to hit something if you're very very lucky. And then again, you might not. You might damage something critical beyond repair, and then again, you might not.
It might, because as I say again, the blast from an ATGM is quite small. There's a good reason why you don't see antiship missiles of this size other than the LCS's Hellfire.
Better to achieve a total kill than settle for a mission kill.
Read properly, I'm talking about bringing 2 USVs to the fight versus bringing a helicopter.
However an S-70 is more capable, can accomplish many other missions such as ASW and transport and aerial surveillance, isn't potentially affected by jamming, has much more range, and can carry much larger missiles or torpedoes to achieve a total kill.
Because the Vanguard 130 only has room for a helicopter hanger OR a USV hangar, it can't carry both.
Of course it "might" cause critical damage. If it can destroy a 26m patrol boat, why can it not cause a 26m gaping firey hole in a frigate or a Kedah. And that is just one atgm missile. Typically, a USV as large as a Venus 16 can carry 4 or more. And that "might" increases dramatically given the smallish ships (frigates and below) deployed in the region.
My point is that the aim of such tactic is to get a mission kill bar a total kill. I never said that one should not get a total kill. A mission kill can always result in a total kill later. What..you are going to wait for another opportunity when an gap for an attack presents itself before you in a hot war situation? Do not be ridiculous.
You get a better grasp of what I am proposing. It is not about platform versus platform anymore; rather bringing to the fore the entire force of the network. When the Vanguard deploys its USVs, UUVs and helicopters, they will be tied to a network i.e. sensors and shooters. It is not always the case that a harpoon must come from the Vanguard rather it can even be a sequential attack by the USVs and helicopter and/or ship.
No... it is slowly growing list of marine atgms..hellfires, Spike LR, Spike NLOS and now MMP.
A vanguard class will have room for both USVs and helicopter given its size and if it applies the same design it has implemented on the Endurance 140, the USVs can be stored in the hull of the ship. It is not for nothing Mindef's design showed the deployment of helicopter, UUVs, USVs and UAVs.