Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Car loan rate vs Fixed.deposit, Compare

views
     
fun_feng
post Jun 20 2018, 01:39 PM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
QUOTE(weichong @ Jun 20 2018, 11:53 AM)
Car loan uses something called Flat Interest Rate, you can convert it to Effective Interest Rate(something similar to FD) using some online calculator . https://loanstreet.com.my/calculator/flat-t...rest-calculator

3% flat rate for 7 years is about 5.57% effective interest rate.

In summary,
Scenario 1
if you take RM50,000 car loan for 7 years and dont touch the FD, you will have RM 65,796.59 in FD after 7 years compounding.

Scenario 2
if you pay with FD money and put the monthly installment you have to pay every month into FD, you will have RM 62,989.57 in FD after 7 years.
*
How you get RM62989.57 in scenario 2?? I got RM69895.20 through https://financialmentor.com/calculator/comp...rest-calculator

You already calculated the loan as 5.57 effective interest rate, which means the loan cost more than the earnings through FD..

Therefore of course it is better to pay the car using cash
fun_feng
post Jun 20 2018, 02:04 PM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
QUOTE(weichong @ Jun 20 2018, 01:41 PM)
scenario 1 is take loan

scenario 2 is use FD money, then monthly installment put back into FD
*
Yes I understand.
I'm just saying your calculation for scenario 2 is wrong.. It should have more money than scenario 1

https://financialmentor.com/calculator/comp...rest-calculator
Attached Image

QUOTE(rapple @ Jun 20 2018, 01:46 PM)
[attachmentid=9867930]

The yearly effective interest rate based on 3% FD and 3% car loan interest.
*
Sorry I don't understand..
We are using 50k principal and 4%FD vs 3%loan example
fun_feng
post Jun 22 2018, 05:17 PM

One Cat to Rule Them ALL
*******
Senior Member
2,289 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Stairway to Heaven
QUOTE(chicaman @ Jun 22 2018, 04:35 PM)
RM100k Loan, 3% P.A, 5 Years

Interest RM3k P.A, over 5 Years is RM15k

Effective Interest Rate is 15%

---------------------------------

RM100k cash put in FD, 4% P.A, 5 Years

Y1 Interest RM4,000 - Assuming you do not touch it since assume you buy car and cannot touch it. Compound Interest
Y2 Interest RM4,160
Y3 Interest RM4,326.40
Y4 Interest RM4,499.46
Y5 Interest RM4,679.43

Total Interest RM21,665.29

Effective Interest Rate 21.67%

---------------------------------

Nowadays FD is easily 4% and above with 1 Year Tenure and could be more if you have RM100k.
So? Post #24 only shows EFFECTIVE INTEREST RATE for the Flat Interest Rate (P.A). Question is why buy cash when you can loan?
*
Dude you totally miss out the monthly payment part... How can you compare like this????

Now let's assume your example of 100k 5 year loan. Loan:3%, FD:4%


Scenario 1 (Buying car with loan and putting 100k into FD)
Cost (Money you fork out): 100k in FD + 115k in repaying loan (1916 monthly installment)
So total cost is 215k
At the end of 5 years you will have a car (fully paid) and RM121,665.29 (FD) in bank


Scenario 2 (Buying car with cash, and use the monthly installment for FD)
Cost: 100k in car + 115k in FD (Putting the monthly installment in FD instead)
So total cost is 215k (see this is same as Scenario 1, and must be the same for a apple to apple comparison)

The calculation of a monthly saving 1916 to FD 4% can be found here https://financialmentor.com/calculator/comp...rest-calculator
The amount is 127,452

At the end of 5 years you will have a car (fully paid) and RM127,452 (FD) in bank









 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0195sec    1.00    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 30th November 2025 - 11:25 AM