I've been using Phillips monitor which I think is using TN panel for around 2 years now. I was thinking to upgrade to an IPS monitor.
Budget wise, only in the price range of these 2 monitor.

This post has been edited by MagnificM: Feb 26 2018, 12:07 PM

29" vs 24" ?
just go for 29"

it just that, im doing some 3D modelling and rendering, some AAA gaming. Not sure whether gaming on ultrawide will affect the performance or not. In dilemma as the panel on the Dell monitor looks so superior compared to the LG one, or is it the same ? hahaha

Dell U2417H is only fullhd
while LG is 2k, 2k need better GPU, and this term LG still better

are you sure that the LG 29" is 2k ? I thought it is 2560 x 1080

wrongly read, its actually is wide full hd

still not sure to get which one, or should I just settle down with normal ips monitor

luckily i've had the opportunity to own both, to narrow this down please ask specific questions on what you want to know and i'll answer to my best.

I want to know the differences in the color of the screen, does the color output differ that much. Movie and gaming experiences



This post has been edited by MagnificM: Feb 26 2018, 02:06 PM

i'll try to break it down for you

LG 29UM59A
pros:
- wider ( around 30% wider not too wide )
- it's not curved, kinda hard to see the edges from right and left pane.
- color accuracy same with U2417H
- 75hz refresh rate is much smoother than the 60hz U2417H ( no need graphics card for 75hz to work)
- i like watching movies or youtube here, the black screen on the sides gives like a cinema effect.

Cons:
- low monitor stand height, i used a monitor mount for better viewing.
- 2560x1080 require more GPU power if you want play full screen gaming. (30-40% more, GTX 1060 recommended, my 1050Ti dropped from 70fps to 50-60fps on fullscreen )
- height a bit smaller than 24 inch, it's like 23 inch height x 29 inches wide


Dell U2417H

pros:
- sleek design , small bezel
- stand is height adjustable
- uses mini dp for better video quality
- has 2 usb inputs ( i plug in my keyboard to my monitor since cpu is far, cable cannot reach. )
- less demanding, can play high end games with GTX 1050 or 1050Ti ( 1920x1080p)
- slightly better color? but not that significant
- the height dimension of the screen accommodates more for gaming.

cons:
- lower refresh rate
- bulkier and heavier? but more better material quality
- expensive for the price.

wahhhh, thank you sooo much for listing the pros and cons. So when playing games, does the extra 15Hz give you better experience ? I think the color for ips panel doesnt differ that much right, it is still better than tn panel. I love multi monitor setup, do you think I should get the ultrawide rather than the Dell one ?

the color for both monitor is almost the same, for daily use the 75hz is noticable.

if you're buying the DELL U2417H for 1k rm, then better buy a 27 inch for better experience ( ACER / AOC / Samsung )

If you're going the LG 29UM59 it's worth it but get at least GTX 1060 to maximize it for gaming.

I see, right now, im leaning toward the LG one, as for 27" FHD, I've tried using a friend's, it is kinda pixelated for me

Hi There

Judging from your needs, I believe your workload is the same as me..

I currently using the LG29 inch, 2560 x 1080 pixles.

Mainly I use it for 3dsMax modelling and rendering, as well color and photo editing with Photoshop and some other view software.

So far, I have no regret and have been happy with the LG29 inch monitor. the color accuracy is there for our work field.

the wider screen did help us a lot for viewport modelling area, with some material / modifier tab open.

even for general usage, Ms Excel and Word, it still works nicely.

my only complain for this LG29 inch is it will be quite pushing the graphic card if do plan to play some game.
since the resolution is wide, its going to struggle the graphic card a little bit more compared to normal 1920 x 1080 monitor.

but again, that aside, this monitor works really well..

Hope this help.

thanks so much for the review, I see the ultrawide helps a lot huh, and for gaming, If my 1060 is struggling, Ill just play on my current monitor then, hahahahaha

You are welcome !

Currently I running on 1070 and sometimes it does give a bit of slow fps but not very noticeable. should be fine I guess..

All the best mate.

hey guys wanna ask if GTX 1050 can use or upgrade monitor to lg 29um59a ? I just play dota 2 tho. will struggle like you all said?

I think it'll not struggle much, It will struggle a bit if playing AAA games