QUOTE(limeuu @ Feb 27 2010, 12:06 AM)
on one hand, that would seem like an excellent way of getting people to be independent and resourceful.....
on the other hand, people will complain why they are paying so much fees for so little..........
The reason people complain about the fees is the facilities, which are the absence of classrooms, only lecture theatres and small group rooms that look like they could have been store rooms since they don't have LCD projectors / clearly not comparable to the learning suites in Monash fully equipped with X-Ray panels and patient bed. Also, lecturers from vietnam sri lanka etc. there just for the sake of having foreign lecturers to make it 'international' medical university.
QUOTE(limeuu @ Feb 27 2010, 12:06 AM)
fyi, it's the standard way for many oecd unis, not the spoonfeeding msians are used to......
Whether or not msians are used to spoonfeeding, I don't know and won't judge since I am not informed of the study patterns and methods practiced by msian students. Spoonfeeding may or may not be the only thing msian students are used to / able to take. Msian students also may or may not have problems with independent and self-directed learning.There are also a variety of ways to get students to be resourceful. Active learning can still be achieved with given/arranged sessions with lecturers as guides. Learning is through experiences, not just 'independently' mugging up reference books.
QUOTE(limeuu @ Feb 27 2010, 12:06 AM)
eg, contact hours (lectures and tutorials/practicals) per subject in oz unis is 3-5 hrs/week only, if you take the standard 4 subjects per sem, that's 12-20hr/week.........tutorials are important, you get marks for attending, and can be refused sitting for final exams if you do not attend the minimum of tutorials.........
tutorials and practicals practiced in oz unis are good things to be implemented. Worksheets with questions and detailed learning objectives are given prior to the practical session, and during the practical session, students present their answers with clinical relevance aided by the given plastinated models. Hence, this is not spoonfeeding. So, not spoonfeeding is fine, provided that there is implementation of substitutes such as these kinds of tutorials and practicals carried out by oz unis. You can learn by making mistakes. In fact, this is one of the best ways of learning. The student when corrected during a presentation in the practical session will be able to learn from his or her mistake. The more opportunities for students to make mistakes (or in this case, to have tutorials and practicals) the more the students can learn. This learning is more interactive and more effective. oz unis also implement formative assessment, which is another opportunity for students to practice on what they have learnt, make mistakes, and learn even more.
QUOTE(limeuu @ Feb 27 2010, 12:06 AM)
lectures are not..........nobody cares whether you attend or not, many do not..........it can be so boring, people just sleep in lectures.........
the didactical way must stop........and dialectic way adopted.........(google if you don't understand what these terms means)......
msian students do not necessarily advocate didactical way. What they are definitely looking for is quality education, which might lie in many different types of modes of delivery or models of learning.
So, not only do students need to have a basic structure or guideline on which a topic should be built upon in order to have direction in learning, they need to be able to ask questions, and then be able to make mistakes, and finally repetition in learning for reinforcement of concepts for effective learning. Repetition (such as identifying one's weakness when realising he or she makes similar mistakes several times -- this essentially is practice, like in math or when practicing piano) can be done on their own, but the rest not necessarily, and those are the steps that should come first.