The mod is just need to be more smart to close people's thread instead of the 3rd party's judges. At least you should PM me why you have to close my thread.


Thank you.

http://forum.lowyat.net/index.php?showtopic=445078&hl=

LOL..just PM the mod back with your reason and purpose to unlock the thread.

Yes if you have any questions on the closure of your topic, you should PM the moderator that closed it (if you know who it is) or just PM any of the admins if you are not happy with it.

Also, I don't think it is really wise to say that LYN should select more potential ones. Just my two cents.

Don't you think if the thread starter is mod or a staff, the story will be differ?

It depends on the topic itself.. Don't try think bias as we all know MOD, ADMIN and STAFF have power to close topic.. Just PM the MOD and no harm done to do so, right?

the mod was waiting for ur ans... whether it is a survey or not...i guess

In the first place, u rarely see any mods creating threads that deserve to be closed, do u?

AHAHA you should say, did create any nonsense thread?
*off-topic* Jim, u still go CG for matches?

This post has been edited by Doomsday: Apr 20 2007, 09:49 PM

Please discuss the related topic as I've arose.

Please tell me how non-sense was it.

This post has been edited by serewen: Apr 20 2007, 09:56 PM

opening a three word thread which holds no avenue for discussion in a post count enabled forum is considered as spam ( or post count whoring ).

To make this clear.. your topic was this and only this.



And i reckon the only possible answers you're going to get is Spirulina or Royal Jelly. It might not have been locked if it was a poll with some avenue for discussion on the reasons.

I didn't state your thread was nonsense, but have u PMed the MOD that closed your thread?

Interesting for u to say that as u were the one who said "Don't you think if the thread starter is mod or a staff, the story will be differ?" first

To expand on what KilJim said, yes, the story would be different because we are familiar enough with the rules to know what is and is not proper in the first place. As such, Se7en has given you a very good explanation and reason already.

Well, since it was I who closed the thread and it was I who opened it back up after recieving a PM, I guess I should clarify why I did so?

Frankly speaking, your post looked like a poor attempt at an advertisement post or spam. The title looks like an advert and the post left me wondering what the purpose of the thread was.

Since I was unsure of the thread's purpose, I gave you a fair chance to further clarify prior to closing the thread, as no response was recieved within the time between my post and my closing of the thread(which I'll admit was pretty short), I made the decision to close the thread.

There are several reasons for my doing so:

A) As previously stated, suspicious name and post.
B) I recieved requests to close the thread as people suspected it to be an ad or spam(one such request visible in thread).
C) I felt that it was a justified action, where the pro's outweighed the cons.

Questions?


ETA: In response to your earlier question:

No, had I been the one posting your thread in the manner with which you posted it, I'd have closed it just the same.


ETA2: I apologize for the grammar mistakes, it's been a long week(month...).

This post has been edited by malaysianPotato: Apr 22 2007, 02:13 AM