Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 investment return taxable?

views
     
klthor
post Oct 24 2017, 10:34 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(cherroy @ Oct 24 2017, 09:52 AM)
You already gave the early hint/answer...   biggrin.gif

Trading is definitely taxable.

Money changer is trading currency by offering money exchange service, their business is not investing.
So their profit is taxable.

Flipping property actually may be seen as a form of trading as well.
That's why those flip or trade excessive number of property, those profit made may be seen as "trading profit".

If the property trade is treated as trading profit, then RPGT is not applicable.
*
this is because the moment they saw their own keywords stocks, forex they will jump into conclusion ... capital gain in nature.... but in fact, badges of trade or other case law to define what is trade and what is capital gain... not just the word, investing/stock/forex.

for years i have been seeing these few confused topics on tax arising from forumer :-

1. foreign income not taxable
2. capital gain not taxable

We need to know how to define foreign income and how to define capital gain. i saw a lot of people define these 2 using their own interpretation.

This post has been edited by klthor: Oct 24 2017, 10:44 AM
SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 24 2017, 03:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

QUOTE(cherroy @ Oct 23 2017, 04:41 PM)
Generally, investment return is treated as capital gain, and capital gain is not taxable.

But if a person use the investment tool to trade upon to make a living, eg. a broker trade stock in the market to make a living, then it is considered trading profit, and trading profit is taxable.

Imputation dividend (tax credit system) already became a history.
From 2014 onwards, all dividends are single tier (aka tax exemption in the hand of shareholders) as it is already taxed at company level.
*
so if my wife not working and use my money and generate income from stocks, she has to pay tax? confused.gif Then i cannot claim the rm3k wife relief?
cherroy
post Oct 24 2017, 05:11 PM

20k VIP Club
Group Icon
Staff
25,802 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Penang


QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 24 2017, 03:07 PM)
so if my wife not working and use my money and generate income from stocks, she has to pay tax?  confused.gif  Then i cannot claim the rm3k wife relief?
*
It depends on your wife whether she is trading the stock typically like constantly with high volume daily/monthly or in other word, trading stock is becoming like her job, or just buy and hold type for investment.

3K relief is for wife not working, if she works as stock trader, then clearly it will be not entitled to claim the relief.

Whilst dividend from stocks is single tier which is tax exempted.

You need to distinguish the difference in term of the income definition.
duplicated
post Oct 24 2017, 08:27 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
653 posts

Joined: Dec 2015
The issue here will be resolved if one can define if his investment is 'investing' in nature or 'trading' in nature.

Nobody here could make an exact distinction between trading and investing. I don't blame you because I myself do not know. IRD are also very vague on this.

1. It's not about the number of trades you make, but it's about the duration you hold. The more cash in hand you have, the more trades in smaller amounts you could make. So, number of trades should not be the determinant to categorise you as an 'investor'. I used the word 'should not' because I am not sure what IRD/LHDN thinks.

2. We have to clearly define how long of a holding period of an investment for it to be classified as 'investing' and how long to be classified as 'trading. From what I heard, it's 3 months, not sure though. So, if you hold securities for more than 3 months, it's considered as capital gain tax.


Thradash
post Oct 24 2017, 08:39 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
153 posts

Joined: Jun 2007
At the heart of it there is confusion because LHDN also not sure about how to treat capital gain... every so often then will sue someone in court and try to get capital gain declared as income... all this because of our income tax act and how they try to define income ...

part 2 section 4f
(f) gains or profits not fall
ing under any of the foregoing
paragraphs.

so far if i remember correctly the judge throw out the last attempt because he say section (f) is to broad... but dunno now how.... goverment so poor... maybe do to capital market whaT They do to the poor doctors
GratsManagement
post Oct 24 2017, 09:21 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
19 posts

Joined: Jun 2016
From: Solaris, Mont Kiara, Kuala Lumpur
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Oct 23 2017, 05:03 PM)
Knight_2008 is right. Capital gain is not taxed in Malaysia, except it falls under the ambit of S4 of income tax law definition of income

So be careful. If you are a regular trader, then your idea of "capital gain don't need to pay tax" may be taxed under income tax (being assess under carrying on a business). If you thought your capital gain is not taxable, and use the profit to buy car buy house, then IRM may be triggered and you may be at risk.

However, although this is the tax law, I personally have not seen anybody around me kena income tax as a result of trading stock. Or maybe they never tell me they kena audit biggrin.gif

And since we are in this topic, same applies to flipping properties. If your frequencies is high, you will be assessed under income tax instead of RPGT. I remember there was an announcement 1-2 years ago by IRB saying if a person buy and sell 2 properties per year, and/or at consistently interval then you will be assessed under income tax instead of RPGT

As for 1 tier dividend, an investor cannot say they are not taxed. Because the company has paid the tax. The company only declare the net income. So you only get dividend which is already net of tax

Unlike the imputation system, where shareholder re-gross back and claim franking credit, and being assessed again. The end result is similar as 1 tier system. But 1 tier system is a lot more straight forward and save a lot of administration
*
Agree, as well as Knight_2008. Capital gain is non taxable.
SUSyklooi
post Oct 25 2017, 07:38 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
8,188 posts

Joined: Apr 2013


QUOTE(GratsManagement @ Oct 24 2017, 09:21 PM)
Agree, as well as Knight_2008.  Capital gain is non taxable.
*
at first, I thought it was an easy and a straight answer just like yours....but then after I continued to read more postings by other forummers on this 2 pages.....I had second thought.
klthor
post Oct 25 2017, 10:09 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
the fact capital gain is not taxable remain unchanged, it boils down to how you define capital gain. for example, we all know speeding is against the law. but what is speeding? definition of speeding etc etc... some said 80km/h, some said 90km/h, some said 110km/h, some said 60km/h

like now, i still can see some said the number of transactions doesnt matter but the duration of holding. more than 3 months is consider capital gain etc. that is why the confusing part kicks in, interpretation of the law. we all have our own interpretation. im not a lawyer, you guys can search badges of trade case law. if you still insist on your own interpretation, you can always take LHDN to court. once you won, it will become a case law and a guide line for the rest of us. if LHDN won, they will use this case law to take action against all other similar cases.

This post has been edited by klthor: Oct 25 2017, 10:41 AM
SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 25 2017, 10:31 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

QUOTE(cherroy @ Oct 24 2017, 05:11 PM)
It depends on your wife whether she is trading the stock typically like constantly with high volume daily/monthly or in other word, trading stock is becoming like her job, or just buy and hold type for investment.

3K relief is for wife not working, if she works as stock trader, then clearly it will be not entitled to claim the relief.

Whilst dividend from stocks is single tier which is tax exempted.

You need to distinguish the difference in term of the income definition.
*
ini macam, why dont my wife just use my name and account to trade? in that case, i dont have to pay any extra tax on the earning and wife still considered not working and i can claim the rm3k tax rebate rite?
MUM
post Oct 25 2017, 10:46 AM

10k Club
********
All Stars
14,855 posts

Joined: Mar 2015

QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 25 2017, 10:31 AM)
ini macam, why dont my wife just use my name and account to trade? in that case, i dont have to pay any extra tax on the earning and wife still considered not working and i can claim the rm3k tax rebate rite?
*
If lhdn define yr stock income as trading...then ?
SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 25 2017, 10:50 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

QUOTE(MUM @ Oct 25 2017, 10:46 AM)
If lhdn define yr stock income as trading...then ?
*
i am already salaried and paying a hefty income tax
rapple
post Oct 25 2017, 10:58 AM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 25 2017, 10:50 AM)
i am already salaried and paying a hefty income tax
*
Paying a hefty income tax and capital gain/stock trading is two different matter.

If IRB deem your capital gain as an income then you will be fine plus the tax rate for that year of assessment.


SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 25 2017, 11:06 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

QUOTE(rapple @ Oct 25 2017, 10:58 AM)
Paying a hefty income tax and capital gain/stock trading is two different matter.

If IRB deem your capital gain as an income then you will be fine plus the tax rate for that year of assessment.
*
i dont understand this.... since trading is no done full time,

what about if dump money in to asm funds? say rm600k? the interest is stated as tax free but can they say it is income?
rapple
post Oct 25 2017, 11:27 AM

Y N W A
*******
Senior Member
2,065 posts

Joined: Oct 2014
From: Ipoh,Perak
QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 25 2017, 11:06 AM)
i dont understand this.... since trading is no done full time,

what about if dump money in to asm funds? say rm600k? the interest is stated as tax free but can they say  it is income?
*
Distribution/dividend from unit trust is already tax therefore you won't have issue on this.

Having a full time job doesn't mean your "side income" it's non-taxable.

This post has been edited by rapple: Oct 25 2017, 11:27 AM
klthor
post Oct 25 2017, 11:34 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
lol maybe we should stop spreading fear to small time traders.
klthor
post Oct 25 2017, 11:35 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
http://msiataxjunior.blogspot.my/2011/11/b...s-of-trade.html

have a read and thats it. from what i see, unless you make it like your bread and butter...AKA arms' length transaction. else you are safe.

This post has been edited by klthor: Oct 25 2017, 11:39 AM
SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 25 2017, 11:41 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

thanks guys

justs for some final clairification

so if my wife spends lavishly, buys bmw, MK, overseas trips mainly europe ... all money given by me, she cannot be inquired by lhdn right? all money i have records and paid tax by me,
klthor
post Oct 25 2017, 11:58 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 25 2017, 11:41 AM)
thanks guys

justs for some final clairification

so if my wife spends lavishly, buys bmw, MK, overseas trips mainly europe ... all money given by me, she cannot be inquired by lhdn right? all money i have records and paid tax by me,
*
well, they can send a letter to your wife to ask for source of 'fund'. once she can prove it, source of fund from you. then they will turn to you to check your income. if your wife shows fund from you 500k, but your income tax form stating 50k a year. good luck.
SUStrumpkampung
post Oct 25 2017, 12:00 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
59 posts

Joined: Jan 2017

QUOTE(klthor @ Oct 25 2017, 11:58 AM)
well, they can send a letter to your wife to ask for source of 'fund'. once she can prove it, source of fund from you. then they will turn to you to check your income. if your wife shows fund from you 500k, but your income tax form stating 50k a year. good luck.
*
ok thanks
i can prove my income....
rclxm9.gif

klthor
post Oct 25 2017, 12:10 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
5,469 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(trumpkampung @ Oct 25 2017, 12:00 PM)
ok thanks
i can prove my income....
rclxm9.gif
*
unless you are super big fish, else they will just look at the facts, logic, evidence and discuss with you and call it a day. big fish, raid, freeze accounts, check transaction yada yada. so far i only eye witness once LHDN raid big fish, i think 2~3 teams consist of 20 lhdn officers and police...raid office, house, and registered office. freeze bank accounts.... really once in a life time.

3 Pages < 1 2 3 >Top
Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0196sec    0.20    5 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 29th November 2025 - 08:46 PM