Just for discussion sake.
Not here to disagree or agree with any denomination.
Say if a person says the sinners prayer, confess and accept Christ as Lord and Savior but later lives a contradictory sinful lifestyle or doesn't go to Church anymore and doesn't really live a Christian life as how brother Thomas ask, is He saved?
Let us discuss this;
I think either something is wrong with the way how the Gospel is shared..either it's incomplete or the person didn't fully understand what was shared.
Now understand that I'm against Sin. UW is 100% against Sin. But how We overcome sin...this is where I differ from others.
But back to this dilemma, when we share the gospel, we need to tell the person, Christ died for you, He was judged and punished for your sins, If you put your faith in Him as your Savior & Lord, You are saved; sin is wrong, it's what corrupts the person and it's what separate the person from God, because God is holy. On Judgement day, any person who is still separated from God will be judged according to what He has done or said. Now I'm not God so I'm in no position to say God will send the person to Hell or Heaven, we don't know what the person did, only God knows.
But I will say this, any person who reject Christ will come under judgement. Most translation use the word condemned in John 3:18 but the Greek Word there is Krino which is Judgement...meaning will be tried.
Condemned means you are judged guilty. Whichever I leave that to your thoughts.
To be fair, the Bible does give chance to the person who wants to be justified by the Law (Performance base) under the New Testament but on the condition, you are bound completely to fully comply, break just 1 law is as good as breaking all of it. And the next condition is, there's no Grace for you. You cannot have both, can't have both the cake and still want to eat it. Bible is very clear on this in Romans 11:6. Jesus also said you cannot mix new wine into old wine skin, He was referring that you cannot mix both the old Testament covenant with the New Covenant, Law and Grace.
Now, the best of the Old Testament, King David whom God call a Man after his own Heart failed to uphold the law perfectly, what makes you think you can? What makes you think anybody can?
So back to the scenario, Either we fail to explain properly, you need to turn away from sin and that's it, never explain how [it's impossible for you to do that in your strength, you need to believe for the power of the HS to change you from inside], just tell him to "repent" , the person tried to live the Christian Life, failed then later find it impossible and gives up, then loses Faith or the person wasn't really born again in the beginning, He/She may say the sinners prayer but never fully comprehend What Christ did for Him and why Sin is wrong, thing like that.
What if the person fully understand the Gospel, said the sinners prayer and yet live a contradictory lifestyle? I will say there's no such thing. Because if you fully understand the gospel, you will also understand you need a Savior, so when the person said the sinners prayer with understanding, You accept Christ, you have the Holy Spirit in your life, He will convict you and the person will feel very uneasy on sinning.
What if such a person who accepted Christ and have the Holy Spirit but refuse to submit and wants to sin? Then I will say, either the person don't understand sin is wrong or we never tell him/her it's wrong.
So the scenario would mean for a person who said the sinners prayer but leave church and live contradictory lifestyle either the person has never really been born again or there's incomplete Gospel being shared.
What if the person understands sin is wrong, have accepted Christ, wants to live right but find himself failing and yet still has his/her faith in Christ, still comes to Church, still study the Bible, Still trying to live the Christian Life...I would say this person is still save, because He knows his Salvation is in his savior not himself. This is where I differ from other people.
Edit: Can such a believer as above be changed? Definitely can.
i've explained what you want to say through the Word of God.
I think it is what you want to say.
but i kinda summarized your 'questions' because God has already did that for us :-)
But i reckon whatever opinions or statements that we have or stand on, must be reproved by God's word. Remember Christ was as such. Often times Jesus would bring up the old testament statements and words... even apostles.. disciples.. so should we...