QUOTE(Orangutara @ Aug 17 2017, 10:48 PM)
You are
clearly an
idiot. Do you know how to read? What is your level of education?
The former Audi's crash engineer was comparing between Iriz and Bezza crash result and he explained why and how Bezza could score high points. It was due to
WEIGHT.


A short glance on Honda's website for Jazz and City reveals the weight for these two cars at only 1100 max as compared to Iriz which is 1180g, and Persona is 1210kg. This "duo" are the heaviest B-segment cars in the Malaysian market today.
In high speed collision between Iriz/Persona versus City/Jazz - the latter will suffer the most.
The models he mentioned is irrelevant, his elaboration on crash test technicalities is what matters.
REFERENCES:
Jazz:
https://www.honda.com.my/model/specifications/jazzCity:
https://www.honda.com.my/model/specifications/cityIriz:
http://www.proton-edar.com.my/en/Models/Ir...iew%20Page.aspxPersona:
http://www.newpersona.proton.com/Well his mind is shut off edi, he only sees crash test numbers and conclude Honda is safer than Proton, full stop.
It is only so as they both crash into inanimate crash test equipment, thus own car's momentum is key differentiator. Since both crashed at same speed, heavier car will be at a slight disadvantage as it has higher momentum to disperse.
But in real world, the variables are much wider. The heavier car may have the advantage if it crashes with much bigger, heavier object as the difference in momentum is smaller. The lighter car, with bigger gap in momentum, may not be able to absorb and disperse the force as well as the heavier car, the frame will just give way and the occupants are more vulnerable. Physics law is absolute.
That's why Volvo never makes compact car, ultimately a bigger car allows more room to reinforce the cars enough to protect occupants better in real world accident. Their current smallest car, V40 hatch broke record as the World's Safest Car when it first sold, but comes at a price of space, as it is not generous with interior or boot space, nor is it the lightest in its class. All that space gone and heavier weight goes to maximise safety of the car.
Proton's safety in newer models is never in doubt, they just need better, fuel efficient powertrain and improve aftersales to be a good seller.