QUOTE(Kojke @ May 17 2017, 09:10 AM)
No. I'm just referring to that statement "raised arms against country". Apparently that was not the case to the cpm, regardless of what the government propaganda said. To those in power, umno = malay = islam = government = malaysia. that's why there're always idiots who jump out and defend "maruah melayu islam" whenever government or umno kena kutuk. The statement
"colonialist installed government" was purely looking at the historical fact and it has nothing to do with whatever form of government i prefer. You talk history and history you talk. Don' mix it with your own preferences and personal feeling.
You're talking like a 'colonialist installed government' is a patently bad and evil thing. From a historical view, a 'colonialist installed government' isn't that of a problem, usually it's a good thing for the country if you see in the big picture..
You have to remember that Malaya has been until then, without a local ruling tradition or mechanism for nearly 400 years. All the government machinery has always been based on the colonial offices of faraway empires and never on a local basis. So there is a grave danger that when a colonial power leaves, there will be chaos on the ground due to the local people having no ruling traditions or a proper bureaucracy to effectively administer the government. History have shown that when an empire lets go of its colonies entirely, it usually leads to very bad things happening (civil wars, revenge attacks, rise of warlords, risk of becoming a failed state)
I think this was present also in Malaya, just after the Japanese surrender and withdrawal but before the British were able to return and restore control of Malaya. There were 45 days of bloody anarchy with scenes of murders and violent reprisals by the CPM and MPAJA on the local people (mainly malay) who worked for the japanese colonial government and police but also any suspected collaborators of all races. Not to mention the widespread effort to raise funds by means of robberies and confiscation of property.
What would've happened if the British never returned after WW2? No doubt the orgy of violence and killings by the CPM and MPAJA would continue unabated for a while but I'd also imagine a chaotic Malaya would be soon invaded by Indonesia, seeing that Sukarno at the time has been salivating at the thought of a unified 'Melayu Raya' encompassing the malay-speaking countries in South East Asia.