i disagree with your comment... first of all singkieland did it with a reason, a clear understanding of the need for a capable armed forces to defend the country and it can only be done with either a very expensive huge regular army or conscription.. the others reasons are for cultural n racial integration, propaganda dissemination and cheap labour... msia doesn't have a strong enough reason...
there's no buy-in by the people... when singkieland introduced ns, lky n pappy was at the height of their power, although there're people that disagree they understood why... as for msia, for what reason? to guard msia's border against pinoys n indons? no (gov via projek IC already importing them in), to reduce crime? no (lots of civil servants already in cahoot with criminals), to provide business for mak losmak's catering and equipment supply business? to create employment for the massive unemployable unemployed? to create businesses for bumi contractors? to have more projects so that gov funds can be siphon off?
the middle class and elites would not allow such bigotry to happen... unlike some with 10 kids whose lives are deemed expandable, many do not appreciate any foolish effort that would put their offspring in harms way for no strong reason..
after several years of ns in msia, what has been achieved? msia is not more safer/secure... racism is at all time high... no clear indication that participants benefit from it... what's fact is a list of misendeavours that came out of it...
a total 23 deaths at camps nationwide have been reported.
The main reasons for the deaths are drowning and health issues like viral infection.
Apart from that, sexual assault, rape and fights have also taken place.
March 8, 2012
An 18-year-old trainee, R. Vinoth, died after having fever for three days. According to the post-mortem, Vinoth had succumbed to leptospirosis, or commonly known as the “rat fever”.
January 2010
A Sikh youth woke up to find his hair had been cut by 50 to 60cm while he was asleep in his dormitory.
June 29, 2009
Abdul Malik Ishak, 18, was found dead on his bed at Kem Guar Chenderai, Padang Besar, Perlis. He had no medical condition as shown on his health declaration form.
June 27, 2009
A brawl involving 100 trainees broke out in the canteen of Lake Chini Resort Camp, Pahang. The fight started when trainees were instructed to arrange the table and some inadvertently shoved each other.
Seventeen trainees were arrested and held at the Pekan district police lock-up for two days before being released after a meeting with their parents.
June 23, 2009
An 18-year-old trainee claimed she was sexually assaulted by more than 20 unidentified men at Lake Chini Resort Camp, Lake Chini, Pahang, while making a call from a phone booth on camp grounds at night.
She declined to return to camp after the incident.
May 29, 2008
Sixty-seven trainees at the Barracuda, Setiu Agro, Terengganu camp reportedly suffered stomachache believed to be caused by food poisoning.
Sept 3, 2007
Mohd Rafi Ameer, 18, died after having fever and his leg had been swollen for a week.
March 1, 2007
P. Prema from Kajang, Selangor, was found unconscious in a toilet at Jeram Linang and she was pronounced dead upon admission to the Tengku Anis Hospital.
Jan 18, 2007
Ili Ameera Azlan, 17, who was attached to the Ayer Keroh camp in Malacca, died after suffering breathing difficulties.
June 11, 2005
S. Theresa Pauline, 17, died due of a viral infection. She was attached to the Karisma Camp, Kuala Pilah, Negri Sembilan.
May 14, 2005
Nurul Ashikin Karino, 17, died at the Han Sui, Tawau, Sabah camp after allegedly being injured during training.
April 23, 2004
Awang Mohd Fazil Awang Borhan, 17, died when he was swimming with 36 other trainees at Sungai Cina, Matang, Kuching, Sarawak.
Feb 28, 2004
A female trainee, 17, was raped by in a car in the Rhu Tapai agro-industrial estate near Setiu. Corporal Zuki Mohd, 30, was jailed 12 years and ordered to be caned three times for the offence.
- See more at:
http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia...h.N60YqFdy.dpuffeedback from majority of the participants describes it as a holiday camp, some try to console themselves by mentioning they got 5 free meals a day (catered at extremely high cost), free allowance, pickup some 'skills' which by now has long been forgotten, learned how to sing some songs and made some friends along the way...