QUOTE(tan171076 @ Sep 26 2018, 09:55 PM)
I am planning to get a MPV. And i am consider either take kia grand carnival or recond toyota estima. I am personally intersted with the new kia grand carnival 8AT. and i knew if talking about features, kia grand carnival is leading, but no doubts toyota estima are reliable car for so long and alot of people driving estima on the road compare with carnival.
But below is my concern for taking kia carnival,
- fuel consumption
- spare parts and maintenance cost
- spare part waiting period
- 8AT with diesel turbo engine reliability
- second value
Hope can get someone advise before i make my final decision. Appreciated if anyone who used kia carnival for years can share your experience.
I have an older Estima ACR30 (2005) and my closed cousin also bought a Estima ACR50 (2010) almost at the same time 3+ years ago. So I can say something about Estima. But below is my concern for taking kia carnival,
- fuel consumption
- spare parts and maintenance cost
- spare part waiting period
- 8AT with diesel turbo engine reliability
- second value
Hope can get someone advise before i make my final decision. Appreciated if anyone who used kia carnival for years can share your experience.
Lets start with the cons :
----------------------------
It's evergreen looking, but being recon you have no warranty or whatsoever and you are required to pay service bill from day 1.
ALL ESTIMA PRIOR TO 2016 LATEST FACELIFT DO NOT HAVE ESC or ESP (electronic stability control). Can you accept this ?
For ACR50 there is a design problem on the steering column, have glok glok sound, even after this RM2k replacement, it can only last about 3 year.
Do not fall into the trap that Estima have strong resale value, if you buy a 3-5 yrs old recond car, after you use it for 5-6 years it exceeds 10 yrs of age. Hard to get financing for the next buyer, so resale value will be suppressed by car dealers. Even if you buy a 2 years old 2016 model with latest facelift, it will set you back with closed to RM200k, you use it for 5 years it will be a 8 years old car, you probably get back something like 90k from car dealers. To me that is quite good already lar
FC is not something to shout about for Estima, in city the 2.4 car can cost you quite a bit to run. If you live in big city, prepare to see 7km per litre of RON95 petrol (you get 8km when you are EXTREMELY light footed and lucky). On highway it can then reach about 10-11km per litre.
Then we talk about the pro :
--------------------------------
Other than the above, Estima is a O-reliable simple car. Not a lot of electronics to deal with. Almost workshop or tyreshop know how to fix a Estima. Spare parts are abundant. Secondhand parts are also abundant.
Evergreen looking.
Easy to sell, there are lots of ppl looking for Estima when you want to sell in future. It's also not hard to sell it via mudah by yourself, do remember to let it go before it reaches 10 yrs of age.
This post has been edited by 4WD_er: Sep 27 2018, 09:07 AM
Sep 27 2018, 09:06 AM

Quote

0.0287sec
0.74
7 queries
GZIP Disabled