Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Proton Persona 2016 Booking?

views
     
davidletterboyz
post Aug 24 2016, 02:42 AM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(AMDAthlon @ Aug 23 2016, 10:54 PM)
How bad it is? They said much roomier than old gen persona.
If it is roomier than old gen persona,then acceptable i guess. But if its much more cramped than old persona.. doh.gif
*


I don't see how it's possible to be roomier than the first gen when the wheelbase is a lot shorter. But don't get me wrong. It doesn't directly translate to comfortabilty because the old gen seat is too low. Like kid's seat. New gen car height is higher as well.

IIRC, Preve was supposed to be the Persona replacement but they priced it higher and old Persona was selling well. That was is not really replaced until now.
davidletterboyz
post Aug 24 2016, 05:41 PM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(ruffstuff @ Aug 24 2016, 07:50 AM)
Clearly you have no idea on the interior.  The legroom is much roomier than the old persona.  The braking distance is improve over the old persona despite non all disc brakes.  The boot space is also bigger than the old persona, and the biggest in its class.  Even it is a B segment compare to the old Persona C segment, it is bigger where it needs to be.  Big in dimension, but not translate into usable space is pointless.
*
QUOTE(ruffstuff @ Aug 24 2016, 07:52 AM)
It is possible.  The Jazz B segment was even roomier than C segment car.  Wheelbase is wheelbase. It is how the engineer make use of that dimension into usable space. Proton is learning towards this, but still cannot match those Japanese who known to have very good skill in using space with restrictions.
*
I see! Maybe I should drop by showroom lol. But then my current PE is still doing fine.
davidletterboyz
post Aug 25 2016, 11:10 AM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


Yesterday evening I went to Proton showroom to look see look see. Didn't test drive because the traffic was bad ...but a few observations on the Premium :
- The interior is much better than first-gen but then the first-gen interior wasn't even good to begin with. It's no Mazda2's level of interior. Some parts still feel a bit cheap to me. It's a major improvement never the less.
- The engine is quiet (only listened to the engine idle sound). But then I remember my PE wasn't that noisy when it was new. lol Now it sounds really rough after 6 years of abuse.
- Built is quite sturdy. Again my PE wasn't too bad when it was new. The main question is how long it can last.
- The rear passenger seats are more comfortable than PE. PE's seats are too low and lacking depth (because the car, overall height is low). New Persona width is narrower though. Legroom is about similar.
- Yes the boot volume is really huge. Unbelievable for such a small exterior boot!

QUOTE(AMDAthlon @ Aug 24 2016, 06:41 PM)
You wait new engine come then tukar la laugh.gif
*
Huh? Got new engine coming?

davidletterboyz
post Aug 26 2016, 01:15 PM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(AMDAthlon @ Aug 25 2016, 11:15 AM)
Yup..new engine suppose to be available by end of 2017 if im not mistaken. So maybe around 2018 we can see Persona/Saga with the new Proton engine AND Transimission(this time not punch cvt)
*
Ah I see. That's a long wait lol.

QUOTE(kingsora @ Aug 25 2016, 11:16 AM)
Got a lot of people test drive?

Was thinking of maybe just go and take a look this weekend.
*
I'm in a small town. Saw a few families were testing it.

QUOTE(leokoo @ Aug 25 2016, 12:05 PM)
Better than the Vios and City engine? Are you serious? Toyota's engines have won global awards from car magazines after much testing and comparison. Proton's Campro engine is an outdated piece that needs to be replaced fast.

The problem is, no major car blogs would talk about it due to the fear that Proton will stop advertising with them.
*
Huh? Vios 1NZ-FE is around 19 years old bro. Yes, Campro wasn't great but I don't remember that Vios engine won any award. Even if it does, it could be more than 10 years ago which is not relevant now.

QUOTE(leon898 @ Aug 25 2016, 01:03 PM)
ya..my preve used to be quiet during 1st year. haha. but anyway, it is not that loud nor giving problem to me. just when compare with my brother's myvi (bought same year), can noticed the engine noise from cabin.
*
How old is your Preve now? Any major issues? I compared Preve with Persona. Preve is an odd one... the interior needs updating. No leather option. doh.gif
Sorry for the off topic. tongue.gif

QUOTE(mat79 @ Aug 25 2016, 01:30 PM)
persona engine is old,yes,thats true. toyota's engines have won many awards,yes,that's true,but just that i dont know whether vios or city engine has won any awards before. maybe i miss it.
*
Hi mat79. What's your opinion regarding first gen Persona's handling (multilink rear suspension setup) vs the new gen (torsion beam)? I heard new Persona's handling is very good but is it better than the old ones?
davidletterboyz
post Aug 26 2016, 05:08 PM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(mat79 @ Aug 26 2016, 05:00 PM)
its actually a tiny bit better cuz when talking about rnh,not only suspension types taking into account,also rigidity of the chasis(less flexing),absorber n spring damping rate,steering gearing ratio n setup. plus esc do help plus traction control where also involve reduce engine power n braking to give natural handling,compare to most esc in the segment or below use braking only.  but if old persona has what it is in new persona,so multilink is better.

good things about multilink,it is easier to be adjusted n tuned cuz its independant,n to find out balanced between handling n comfort is easier. for torsion beam,since its fix, if too too much focus to be sharp handling,normally it will become too stiff,so,take out comfort.

but if talking about comfort especially bad road,multilink is the best for common cars.

the cons,it is heavier,cost more.
*
That's very surprising! Maybe I should go test drive lol.
But with Preve beside it...I still think Preve is more worth the money spent....barring the NVH and non-leather interior.
davidletterboyz
post Aug 27 2016, 11:55 AM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(serez @ Aug 27 2016, 09:44 AM)
just test drive new persona just now. for me everything are nice except for a little bit lagg (perhaps 0.3s the car move after pressing the pedal).
overall built quality suits its price but the steering wheel cover look a little bit cheap.
for me its worth to buy even its downgraded to B segment compare to previous version. safety tiptopp
*
Better than Persona Elegance AT. The lag is like more than 0.5s lol.
davidletterboyz
post Aug 29 2016, 12:34 PM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(Quazacolt @ Aug 27 2016, 03:20 PM)
Just had a short test drive session at Taman Wahyu Proton dealer while i was on the way home sending my iswara for a rear bumper installation/repair lol

pros:
- the engine bay is really neat
- Made in china Bosch ESP module on the left
- very thick looking anti roll bar and neat looking electric powered steering rack
- the 510 liter rear boot space is HUGE and really impressive for a b segment. if anything, seemingly same, if not bigger sized than my c segment inspira.
- engine response seems better than the Iriz
- the new TCU tuning on the punch transmission was really impressive compared to the Iriz experience. Less hesitation and less jerking on low speeds; Makes you forget if you're even on a clutch based CVT.
- Suspension/handling was impressive even if it was only short distance with generally straight roads. and while i didn't get to test the ESP on more extreme cornering, i did get to fly through lots of road bumps/uneven roads within Taman Wahyu vicinity and the ride is really supple all the way. really good balance for an a to b comfort oriented family sedan.
- NVH is even improved from the Iriz! although my particular car (that has 400km driven despite being a test drive car LOL! looks like good demand/interest!)  has dashboard rattling when i bring the RPMs up to 6k (impressive, given its a CVT unit, and without engaging L gear as well!)
to emphasize how well it is, besides the engine roar that came up only past 4k rpm, the air cond fan blowing was the only noise i heard.
- aircond/fan speed knobs etc was further improved from the Iriz, much sturdier and the clicks are very pleasant from switching it up around.
- steering has a damn nice feel to it despite being electric power steering. not too heavy, not too light, just right for me.
- i LOVE the frabric seats, more so than the leather biggrin.gif
really good feel and since it is dark colored, looks like it'll last very long as well with minimal to no maintenance required.
- Love the meter cluster design! very high contrast of white/red/black background themed.
a bit small though however considering the overall dashboard/panels have shrunk in size as the persona is basically a b segment, understandable i guess.

cons:
- gear lever position is really far
- steering position a bit high after lifting it up for leg clearance
- speaking of leg clearance, the foot well in the front is quite cramped. it would be amazing if they can score 5 star NCAP/ANCAP without deducting points from the crash dummy avoiding leg injury as the bottom dashboard portion and the steering is basically in contact with my knees all the time.
- and again on the footwell, the left foot rest for the automatic is basically just beside the brake pedal which doesn't leave room for the clutch pedal and a footrest combined if you look at how cramped it is. makes one wonder if the manual would be even feasible or not with the given position
- YES AGAIN on the foot positioning, the pedals were pretty weird to me as the brakes were a bit higher up than the accelerator. ignoring that it is quite far apart between each other (yes i know its an auto however usually they don't specifically re-design/re-position the pedals between auto/manual variants) the high/low positioning of the brake and accelerator also leaves much to be desired. Did i mention the accelerator being lowly positioned? yes, oddly enough the travel of said accelerator pedal is very minimal, seemingly in an almost "on/off" switch ish with very little applicable modulation. maybe its just my personal problem with a lead chained intensely heavy right foot, but hey this may actually be a good thing depending on how you look at it.
- still apparent throttle lag/response on the DBW system/Clutch engagement of the punch transmission, although from the rough feel, still slightly better than the Iriz.
however, once you get it going, it goes, nuff said biggrin.gif
*
That is true for most cars. In fact, I thought it's quite the contrary. The height diff of throttle and brake pedals were very big on the previous gen Persona. I thought the new Persona is much closer, almost same height. Can drive like a GP car. lol
davidletterboyz
post Aug 30 2016, 02:16 PM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(lowpro @ Aug 30 2016, 11:29 AM)
The HU is not so nice to use but it is acceptable.

For the FC, after using the car for about a day, I managed to get to about 7 something litres for 100km. Combination of highway, fast and slow driving plus city. Not too bad lah. Will improve further as it runs in.
*
What is HU? hmm.gif
davidletterboyz
post Sep 1 2016, 11:13 AM

Der Kaiser
*******
Senior Member
4,672 posts

Joined: Jan 2003


QUOTE(Volfeed @ Sep 1 2016, 10:44 AM)
Those minor issue will always be there - maybe in lower rate if the QC & QA are very much tightened. A car is made of thousands of components, which even grouped into chassis, drivetrain, electronics, accessories etc. Even if one of the component screw-up, it may affect the whole car. It is not easy to control yo.

If P1 / P2 doesnt exist, I think the price of sushi and kimchi car will still be the same (see the sushi / kimchi car price in Thai / Indo / Phils - almost same as us). Only maybe we will have more choices of car at RM30k ~70k region.
*
Did you mean P1/P2 does not exist in the first place or P1/P2 does not exist now? I think there are two possibilities of what would happen. You may ask your parents/elder how much a sushi car cost back then before Proton was found. sweat.gif

On side note, I would wait for Preve face lift and see how it goes.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.1574sec    0.35    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 13th December 2025 - 03:10 PM