Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

PC Audio Edifier Fan Club V3, where great sound comes to life =)

views
     
Wuakaka
post Jan 11 2007, 08:00 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
244 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


i felt fed up wit my fren when he saying dat my newly bought Edifier M3300 is lousy if compare to Altec,i was very angry wit wat he said,as i noe,Edifier speaker has the bast bass among all brand,even is 2.1,3.1 n so on,do ur all agree?
Wuakaka
post Jan 12 2007, 08:32 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
244 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


QUOTE(Joshua_0718 @ Jan 12 2007, 12:01 PM)
Who said that? Wei Lik got said a not?
*
My dat fren keep saying dat bcoz of my budget so i go for Edifier,he even say dat Edifier is a lousy brand,he say even Logitech also can beat Edifier,come on,if my budget is 1k above,i will still choose Edifier,the bass is boom boom enough,i ask him to go sri computers n compare it but he said dat he bought his speaker set at Low Yat too,i wonder wat set he bought dat he tinks dat Edifier is a lousy brand n duno is which stupid ppl dat convince him dat Edifier is a lousy brand,is reli iritating u noe?!

NO la joshua,i listen it by myself n tink so

This post has been edited by Wuakaka: Jan 12 2007, 08:35 PM
Wuakaka
post Jan 12 2007, 10:15 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
244 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


QUOTE(DotA 5.84C -AR @ Jan 12 2007, 09:28 PM)
come on.. dun because to get a speaker, but lose a fren.  biggrin.gif

In fact, i seriously doubt ur fren r layman in audiophile. there is no way a logitech speaker can better than edifier! even though u take their highest 2.1 Z2300(RM550) versus the cheap M3300(RM230) i still say M3300 is way better in over all sound stage. same goes to altec lansing speaker. IMHO, altec lansing just produce good speaker start from RM450(CS21) and above.  their lower range product like ATP3 and vs4121 sounds like a speaker cover by a pillow, and the bass is loud but bloat and not well defined. for those layman who dunno acoustic, they usually thought bass louder meaning the speaker is better. this kind of user like ur fren better ask them go to buy car speaker, because those cheap car skeaper already can blast until ur house vibrate with their "boomy" bass.

but... ignorance is not their fault, because they dun have a sensitive ear. just dun waste ur time to argue with them because they wouldn't understand it.  biggrin.gif
*
so dat means if i my budget reli is above Rm 500,i should go for altec?
u juz mention it dat if compare lower range oni lose,so if i wan compare the higher range de leh?
Wuakaka
post Jan 12 2007, 10:30 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
244 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


QUOTE(PcWork @ Jan 12 2007, 10:22 PM)
i can't tell u which is better.
i heard S2000V, it is too flat for me, too boring for my ear.
so far, sub RM 1K systems i only happy with Aego M / Altec MX5021/ R1900TIII.
and serious speaking FX6021 is SUCkS also.
its depend on ur budget, what kind music u like, and mainly use the speaker for wat (movie/ music).
then u only can find a speaker suit ur taste. else i suggest you get an Aego T set which can easily cost u couple thousand. that's quite good in my ear and my budget.
*
oh ya,i oso heard b4 of MX5021,is reli is a good speaker,actually,i buy tis set of speaker is juz for personal use oni la,coz my house already got Bmb karaoke system,n Jbl home theathre system,so is not reli is a must to buy a god pc speaker la,btw,thx,nice to meet u

Wuakaka
post Jan 14 2007, 04:24 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
244 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


QUOTE(DotA 5.84C -AR @ Jan 13 2007, 09:57 AM)
if wanna take 2.1 vs 2.1, currently the highest range product from edifier is S2.1D(arround RM390) only. IMO MX5021 is still better than S2.1D. anyway, there is a term we always use "performance/price ratio", S2.1D still perform very good for the price u pay RM390 only. but i never say RM500 and above altec lansing is best choice, what i mean is just RM500 above speaker like MX5021 at least have the quality there so u can consider it. FYI, the lastest and highest range 2.1 from edifier is S2.1MKII. its going to release in the market in this year. u can go to test it at show room now. i really think RM500 above 2.1 speaker, S2.1MKII still beat all the other 2.1 speaker like logitech, altec lansing, creative, and klipsch. so... no matter wat range i still think edifier is the winner, i can see they keep work hard to improve their speaker quality, their product building material never reduce one. last time 4 to 5 years ago i am altec lansing fans. at that time their speaker quality really good. but after that i dunno wat happen to altec lansing, their quality really drop already, meanwhile edifier keep improve their speaker quality, so now i change to edifier fan already because i found that their product for low, high range all also very good quality. u wanna take 4 years b4 ATP3 compare with current ATP3? u will found
that altec lansing they reduce their building material to save cost! one more thing i can tell u is, i always think ATP3 and VS4121 sounds like cover by a pillow u know y?
because this speaker design natively got problem! did u know their 3" satelite is hide under the satelite? this is the reason make the satelite sounds blur. wat the heck to the design engineer of altec lansing, i start disappointed to them since ATP3 and their following product. i am not convince anybody here because i believe u have ur own idea. if u urself dun like that kind of sounding method, no matter how i convince u also no point. u can always test by urself 1st b4 decide to buy. i just want to release my opinion here.  biggrin.gif
*
juz look back n u will find out dat is because their main designer had passed away and now the designing part is all in china now,so no wonder the quality is getting worser and worser

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0449sec    0.71    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 27th November 2025 - 02:49 AM