There is not much other choice as comprehensive as MT4. AFAIK.

It's the market maker vs ECN profile that is more relevant to your trading pattern.

Had a quick look. I'm interested in automated trading which all 3 seem to have.

Any comments on the automated trading aspects?

Why need good broker?

If you have a winning formula, you don't care about the broker.

The spread is known upfront.

Hard to measure delay execution.

Trading desk against you is how your selected account work. Not the same thing as good/bad.

Gov? no comment.

This is not about "always".

Long term, the question is whether your wins are bigger than your losses.

One that does not pay out your profits.

But first, you need to make a profit, before you know the broker will pay out or not.

Small profits are not a problem. It's when they give excuses for not paying out the big profits.

If you are sure you have got a winning formula, go for an ECN broker.

If you profit, and the broker pay out, that's all you need to worry about.

Anything else, you are just getting confused.

Why should you worry about bad or scan brokers if you can win?

Don't worry about the wrong thing.

If one broker win, you stick with the same broker, why change?

Let's get back to my original point "If you profit, and the broker pay out, that's all you need to worry about."

Profitable Consistently = GOOD. Keyword: consistently.

And first you got to make a profit.

In that case, you enjoy what they have already paid out, consistently profitable.

If they have paid-out, you take their money and say thank you.

What is the problem?

If you google forex trading, you would have across the fact that a very large percentage of people lose.

For the very small percentage that win, I suspect they are not going to tell you their confidential information.

No, I'm saying idiots like you fall for their tricks, and I'm glad you learnt your lesson.

What do you want then?

1st you might be getting back the payout from your own money which you dont even know. The payout might not even genuine.
>> How can you not recognize that payout is from your own money? Only an idiot cannot.

2nd what if many invest today and they stop paying tomorrow and many got scammed. Is that ok to you?
>> They stop paying? Just enjoy that they have paid. Unless you did not cash it out - that makes you the idiot/

3rd we learned to be smart investors not getting involve with scams.
>> Sure

You said: Which broker and any Myfxbook we can learn?

You expecting me to spoon feed? haha..

Us? Who's "us"?

Wrong? About what exactly? I havent' replied to any of your posts.

But that's what I meant. Don't put money in if you don't have a good chance of payout.

So simple point.