I'm surprised Robbie Savage was mentioned. I'll have to go with Diouf as he has already admitted to diving when it is in his best interest to do so.
Discussion who's dive the most?, EPL players who dive the most in game
Discussion who's dive the most?, EPL players who dive the most in game
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 02:27 PM
Return to original view | Post
#1
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
I'm surprised Robbie Savage was mentioned. I'll have to go with Diouf as he has already admitted to diving when it is in his best interest to do so.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 02:37 PM
Return to original view | Post
#2
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
In many leagues, diving is considered gamesmanship. It's sad to see this happening in the EPL though because the English game is known to be hard but fair. More and more pansies are coming into the league and fearing injury, choose to dive rather than soldier on like real men. I suppose there is nothing wrong in 'cheating' the referee if you can live with yourself. Nowadays it's rare to hear the commentator go, "you know that if he stays down, it's got to be bad" as too many players not only dive but feign injury.
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 04:53 PM
Return to original view | Post
#3
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
You can't blame a person for giving an opinion based on the topic of the thread.
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 04:58 PM
Return to original view | Post
#4
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Of course you can defend your player if they aren't guilty. It helps if you give a reason lah otherwise it will end up like this:
you : "he does not dive!" him : "he dives!" How to argue lah like that? |
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:07 PM
Return to original view | Post
#5
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:34 PM
Return to original view | Post
#6
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
QUOTE(Wan @ Dec 4 2006, 05:26 PM) You really think it's fair to compare Gerrard with the other names that have been mentioned here? Has he dived? yes. Does he do it frequently? no. If I drink a couple of beers, does that make me an alcoholic? Not saying he never dived, just trying to put some perspective into your argument.The topic is "who dives the most?" and not "who has ever dived" This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 4 2006, 05:36 PM |
|
|
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:40 PM
Return to original view | Post
#7
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
I'm just responding in line with the title of the thread
If the title was "who ever dived", I myself will name Gerrard ler. I support the club first and the player second. This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 4 2006, 05:41 PM |
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:51 PM
Return to original view | Post
#8
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
It's almost impossible to keep with the statistics. There is no smoke without fire though and if a pundit, managers or players labels someone a diver, there must be some degree of truth to it. Aside from you, I don't know anyone who has labeled Gerrard as one
This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 4 2006, 05:51 PM |
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:53 PM
Return to original view | Post
#9
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Let's just all solve this argument by agreeing that all goalkeepers dive the most.
|
|
|
Dec 4 2006, 05:59 PM
Return to original view | Post
#10
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
QUOTE(Notoriez @ Dec 4 2006, 05:55 PM) Liverpool LEGEND got my vote Eh ptooi ptooi! He's not a Liverpool legend, we hate him as well! El Hadji Diouf..he's known as a DIVER since he was in Liverpool..who else can get freekicks, corners and penalties...he even knows how to feign injury..damn that guy, me and my Reds friends really hated him |
|
|
Dec 5 2006, 02:36 PM
Return to original view | Post
#11
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
QUOTE(aboogee @ Dec 5 2006, 12:05 PM) Why not start a thread abt the rate of foreign takeovers and how it would affect the league and eventually the game. Dont you think thats a better topic to start on? I did in the EPL thread but no one seemed interested in discussing it. The best all time diver award has to go to Juergen Klinsmann. |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 10:30 AM
Return to original view | Post
#12
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
There are two things wrong with this thread:
1) People who don't seem to grasp the thread topic. It doesn't have to be backed by statistics. No one can be expected to remember each dive made or have ratio's to back it up. Sometimes a players reputation precedes them and this is enough. As I've said before, there is no smoke without fire. 2) People who defend their players at all costs. How would we react to a Bolton Wanderers fan who claims Diouf doesn't dive? Some people may want to win at all costs even if it means they condone their players going for diving lessons but I personally do not. I love sports and I participate which is why I think cheating for whatever reason is totally against the spirit of sportsmanship. Call it gamesmanship, tactics or whatever, deceiving the officials is wrong in my books especially when the EPL is supposed to be all about fair play. |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 11:11 AM
Return to original view | Post
#13
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
QUOTE(bubucaca @ Dec 6 2006, 11:05 AM) You're right. When I spoke with Phil Neal during his visit to KL, he told us stories of how tough the league was back then. Elbows where thrown all the time and players played on with fractures and small breaks. Nowadays, players want to come off having broke a fingernail. |
|
|
|
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 11:28 AM
Return to original view | Post
#14
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Here is an article I read that is relevant to our discussion.
QUOTE Ronaldo acts the part well Please practice some objectivity before responding.10:41am 5th December 2006 by Des Kelly The only excuse is that ham acting must be in his blood. Such an elaborate tumble, such an intuitive trip, must happen through some involuntary instinct, just like blinking when you sneeze. Cristiano Ronaldo just sees a leg and he falls over, whether it has touched him or not. Maybe we shouldn't be surprised. After all, Cristiano Ronaldo dos Santos Aviero, to give him his full moniker, was not dubbed 'Ronaldo' because of some romantic affinity with Brazilian football and the beautiful game. The name was chosen because his parents' favourite movie star was Ronald Reagan, the enduringly wooden actor and all-American Presidential plank. Reagan was once asked "How can an actor become President?" He replied: "How can a President not be an actor." And so it seems with football. These days, acting is so much a part of the game that we are almost growing weary of condemning it, preferring to excuse the professional tumblers, particularly if the simulation is convincing enough. Take Ronaldo's hop, skip and jump at Middlesbrough, a deceit that earned Manchester United a penalty as he pushed the ball past Mark Schwarzer. Rather than criticise him for this obvious bout of chicanery, a surprising number of commentators queued up to explain away the act. Alan Hansen came out with the most bizarre nonsense of all, claiming: "My sympathies were with Ronaldo, he was looking for the Middlesbrough keeper to hit him. Under the laws that a centre forward lives by, he was guilty of no crime." By this warped logic, players in different positions must be entitled to play to different regulations. Let's see how Hansen's Law might apply elsewhere? "Under the laws that a centre half lives by, he was guilty of no crime when he clattered straight through the striker from behind and left him on his backside with a broken ankle." For all the inane alibis and misplaced commiserations, most of us know Ronaldo did not stumble accidentally; he did not leap selflessly out of the way of an advancing goalkeeper; he did not helplessly fall to earth. The player dived, pure and simple. Yes, it was skilfully accomplished with all the twinkle-toed mastery that you might expect from the Premiership's best Riverdance impersonator, but it was still a blatant act of gamesmanship. As Schwarzer advanced, Ronaldo left his right leg trailing, inviting contact. The fact that the keeper missed by a foot or so did not deter him from completing his collapse to the turf. Here, United fans will complain their club are being victimised and that there would be less media scrutiny of the incident had Ronaldo not been involved. And they are right. That's the trouble, you see; it's Ronaldo again. "Something has to be done because it is happening with that lad too many times," said Boro manager Gareth Southgate. "It seems to be a handful of players at the centre of it." Correct. Ronaldo, Didier Drogba, Arjen Robben are among the repeat offenders and yet, despite the wealth of evidence and the endless howls of protest, it goes on. On his first day in office at the Football Association, the new chief executive Brian Barwick announced it was his intention to help cut out the plague of diving but, sincere as his intentions undoubtedly were, nothing official has been done. There is no panel in place to review incidents, no retrospective punishments issued for simulation. In fact, it has been the court of public and media opinion that has come down on the cheats. Mockery and abuse has made some of the worst offenders think twice about falling over as players realise how quickly a reputation can be gained and lost. But it is not enough. The great sadness is Ronaldo had been arguably the player of the season so far. Having been pilloried for his part in Wayne Rooney's World Cup dismissal and widely expected to flee to Real Madrid as a result, he had responded with real character and maturity, shedding his reputation as a novelty act who would look more at home in sequins and producing the kind of irresistible performances that marked him out as a potential Footballer of the Year. Until he went and fell flat on his face. |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 01:48 PM
Return to original view | Post
#15
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
If there weren't so much controversy, we'll have nothing to talk about also ler.
|
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 01:52 PM
Return to original view | Post
#16
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Perhaps because he isn't. If he was, why isn't he labeled as a diver by any of the press. One or two instances don't sum up a man. Please try to reply with a certain degree of objectivity as mentioned before. I understand that most people don't take criticism well.
This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 6 2006, 01:53 PM |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 02:08 PM
Return to original view | Post
#17
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
QUOTE(refnulf @ Dec 6 2006, 01:58 PM) He happens to be Britain's master diver. Does it with such grace that most pundits close one eye when it comes to him. In fact, they're always applauding the penalties he wins. Ok fine, so Ronaldo never dives and is constantly victimised while Stevie G is a habitual diver, happy now? Pundits and the media have no idea what they are talking about either. Makes me wonder why I even bother reading articles. The only reason you mentioned Stevie G is because I am a Liverpool fan and the article just happens to be on Ronaldo. Would you be happier if I were to dig up another article on Diouf perhaps? I only posted the article, because it was relevant to the topic but apparently articles are biased towards your team anyway so they don't matter. Why do all the big clubs claim they are being victimised? Next topic please.One or two instances? I think it's more than that when it comes to your captain.How many times has Ronaldo dived for penalties? Perhaps he had that nasty habit when he first came here but I think he's successfully cut it out of his game now. Perhaps the FA needs to offer him more protection, instead of criticizing him when he does go down. EDIT: I wouldn't really count on any tabloid over there as a source of diver statistics. The media likes to play favourites. This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 6 2006, 02:09 PM |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 02:25 PM
Return to original view | Post
#18
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
I myself agree that Stevie G has dived, I'm no hypocrite. What I don't like is when someone attacks a player of mine just because I posted an article that mentioned Ronaldo. Heck, it's not like I wrote the bloody article. It should at least open up a channel for discussion and not retaliation. I would not have got the some response had I been a Wigan fan, no? To make matters fair, why don't we add Stevie G to the pool then? I'm pretty sure that many players dive, but some make an art of it. Look at Juergen Klinsmann. He perfected the art of diving.
|
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 02:27 PM
Return to original view | Post
#19
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Here is another article on diving except it mentions "BEST DIVES". Do not mistake this with BEST DIVERS please.
QUOTE The 10... Ctn'd...best football dives Sunday November 2, 2003 Observer Sport Monthly 1: Roberto Rojas Brazil v Chile, World Cup qualifier, 3 September 1989 Overrun and intimidated, Chile needed a way out. The plan: force an abandonment and a replay in a neutral venue. The execution: on 69 minutes, goalkeeper Rojas threw himself into the smoke of a firecracker, which had landed nearby, pulled a razor blade from his glove and stabbed himself in the head. The result: lots of blood, a mass brawl, a walkout, an abandonment - but, after video evidence, no replay. Instead, Brazil were awarded the game, Chile were out of one World Cup and excluded from the next, Rojas was banned for life and the woman who threw the firecracker was signed up by Playboy Brazil. In May 2001, Fifa lifted the ban. 'At 43, I'm unlikely to play again,' said Rojas, now coach at São Paulo, 'but at least this pardon will cleanse my soul.' 2: Jurgen Klinsmann West Germany v Argentina, World Cup Final, 8 July 1990 Germany had no answer to Argentina's solid, anti-football until Klinsmann collected the ball on the right and tried to go past Pedro Monzon. Monzon was lining something up - a tackle, perhaps even a foul - but before he'd had a chance, Klinsmann was soaring above him. Arcing through the air, he broke into three jarring, electric rolls. He'd done enough to see Monzon sent off - the first red card in a World Cup Final. Germany won with a penalty, awarded following a late Rudi Völler air trip. 3: Diego Simeone Argentina v England, World Cup, 30 June 1998 Before he was deified, David Beckham was a sack hanging from lamp posts. He owed his unpopularity to Diego Simeone, who, flicked by Becks's back heel in retaliation after a foul, toppled theatrically in this World Cup last-16 match in Saint-Etienne. 'I took advantage,' Simeone told OSM in May last year. 'I think anyone would have done so in just the same way.' Beckham was naturally unimpressed. 'Simeone went down as if he'd been shot,' he said. 'My first thought was, "I've made a big mistake here."' |
|
|
Dec 6 2006, 02:29 PM
Return to original view | Post
#20
|
|
Elite
6,112 posts Joined: Sep 2006 From: Earth |
Cnt'd
QUOTE 4: Robbie Savage I didn't write this article.Derby v Leicester, 15 September 2001 Robbie makes it so high in the list for sheer effort: a corrosive 90 minutes, a last-minute dive in the area, a hopeful look to the referee and a fist-pumping explosion in front of the home fans. Derby players chased him all the way to the corner flag, then tried to mug him in the tunnel afterwards. 'We've seen players for years who are very clever at diving for penalties,' said Derby boss Jim Smith. 'But he's not very clever and his penalties become riots. It's always him.' Robbie said: 'I've never dived in my career. I was blameless.' 5: Slaven Bilic Croatia v France, World Cup semi-final, 8 July 1998 Feeling the hairs on the back of Laurent Blanc's hand brush his cheek, Bilic went down, his hands covering his face. He stayed down until Blanc had been dismissed, which meant he was suspended for the World Cup Final. 'He only had himself to blame,' said Bilic. 'I am not a cheat, I am honest. I am not to blame. After all, he hit me in my face.' Bilic was condemned by the PFA, colleagues and fans across Europe, including his own in Croatia. 6: El-Hadji Diouf Senegal v Uruguay, World Cup, 11 June 2002 On his way round Uruguay keeper Fabian Carini, El-Hadji Diouf felt the keeper's breath on his shin. The gust blew him up, then down, then all over the penalty area. Replays confirmed no contact - as in, none at all - had been made. Later, Richard Morales did the same for Uruguay and the ref gave that, too. When he wasn't giving penalties, he was taking names: 12 players booked and Senegal through to the last 16. 'We'll keep playing to our strengths,' said Diouf. 'Above all, I feel proud.' 7: Francis Jeffers Arsenal v Liverpool, December 2002 'He's the biggest cheat in football,' said Peter Osgood. 'I'd love to see him get really hurt.' Jeffers's greatest moment in an Arsenal shirt, a last-gasp trip over a space where John Arne Riise's leg might have been but wasn't, earned Arsenal a penalty and a point. 'The referee was conned,' said Gérard Houllier. 'I wouldn't be surprised if he practised diving in training,' said Ron 'Chopper' Harris. 'Since the foreigners came over here everyone's at it, even the English lads.' 'I'm not a conman or a diver,' said Franny, now back at Everton. 'I'm an honest player.' 8: Paul Alcock Sheffield Wednesday v Arsenal, 26 September 1998 Just before half-time, Patrick Vieira and Petter Rudi drew handbags, Paolo Di Canio kicked Martin Keown's shin and Paul Alcock sent the latter pair off. Di Canio reacted by pushing the referee, who staggered backwards several paces before splaying like a new-born foal. 'I gave him a shove, but it was hardly done with force,' said Paolo. 'He took sideways steps then fell over in a rather strange way - like someone acting for a penalty.' Di Canio was banned for 11 games and Alcock threatened to retire. 'I did not expect to be branded a psycho,' said Paolo. 9: Rivaldo Brazil v Turkey, World Cup, 3 June 2002 Hit in the leg by a football - always nasty - Rivaldo felt the pain searing in his face. Referee Yung Joo Kim, seeing him clutch his head, sent off the ball-kicker, Hakan Unsal. Fifa fined Rivaldo £5,180. 'I'm calm about the punishment, and I am not sorry about anything,' he told reporters. 'I was both the victim and the person who got fined. Obviously the ball didn't hit me in the face, but I was still the victim. I did not hit anyone in the face! Nobody remembers what that Turk did to me. I'm not a player who fakes fouls.' 10: Mark Hughes Manchester United v Montpellier, Cup Winners' Cup quarter-final, 6 March 1991 Millions watched as Mark Hughes was thrown backwards by the weight of a Pascal Baills air-butt. Uefa wouldn't allow Baills to use TV evidence to prove he hadn't made contact. Hughes was warned not to travel for the second leg by Montpellier president, Louis Nicollin. 'What Nicollin said is intimidation,' said Alex Ferguson. 'This is 1991. They can't get away with these things.' In the event, Hughes travelled; Jean-Manuel Thetis was booked for fouling him and sent off for spitting at him. United won 2-0. · Rationale This month's 10 was selected by Observer football writer David Hills. Here he justifies his choice: So where's Ruud? Like Franny Lee, the game's first great English diver, Van Nistelrooy's effective dive-for-penalty/score-from-penalty routine knocks him way down the list. This list is about showmanship, about falling with an eye on the cameras. Among those to nearly make it were Italy's Alessandro Del Piero against England in 1997; Klinsmann for Monaco against Milan in the 1994 Champions League semi-final; Bernd Hölzenbein for Germany in the 1974 World Cup Final; Robert Pires for Arsenal against Portsmouth this season; and Peter Schmeichel, in 1993, knocked down by a Micky Quinn punch that missed. Quinn's red card was one of the first to be overturned on TV evidence. Other contenders included David Speedie, Cristiano Ronaldo, Hristo Stoichkov, David Ginola, Anders Limpar, Sasa Curcic, Vitor Baia, Maradona, Christian Panucci and Hakan Sukur, whose air sprawl against England in Turkey last month was genre-defining. Michael Owen, against Argentina in 1998, was ruled out for patriotic reasons. One other near miss: Ariel Ortega in the 1998 World Cup quarter-final. In the 88th minute, Ortega plunged over but missed Jaap Stam's leg; he was so incensed at being booked, instead of winning a penalty, that he head-butted keeper Edwin van der Sar, who, writhing in pain, threw himself to the ground. Ortega - out-dived and humiliated - was sent off. Roberto Rojas was the clear winner, however, not least because he inspired a copycat self-slashing from Esperance keeper Chokri el Ouaer in the 2000 African Champions League final. Chokri's attempt at self-knifing, though, was seen by all, including the officials. He was substituted and banned for a year. A more neutral one wouldn't you say given that they did mention Franny Jeffers and Michael Owen, both of whom are English. This post has been edited by Duke Red: Dec 6 2006, 02:40 PM |
|
Topic ClosedOptions
|
| Change to: | 0.0532sec
1.37
7 queries
GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 19th December 2025 - 08:31 AM |