QUOTE(acougan @ Dec 29 2006, 02:59 PM)
my 2c,
if u already have a decent HDTV. hd-dvd add-on offers good value for money. the hardware itself is subsidised, its catalog/library wont suddenly plummet to zero even if some studios go multi-format. the way i look at it, if u even watch & enjoy 20~30 movies in the next 2 years, the cost is well justified. no need to worry too much abt the future.
note: my 1st dvd player costed more than the hd-dvd add-on

also no hdtv for me

Thanks for the feedback. I also know how much it cost to own a DVD player back then. My first DVD player cost me quite a mint too.

QUOTE(zio @ Dec 29 2006, 03:13 PM)
I believe you have to see it to believe it. The clarity of the HD DVD compared to a DVD is noticeable. Especially when you have a good TV.
Also the extra features of the U control although not necessary, its a cool-to-have feature.
And your What Ifs generally can't be answered, so if you want to wait for a sure thing, it might be a long wait.
And therein lies the problem. Since I don't know where to see the difference (online screenshots don't count), that's why my concern was valid. Would it be a marginal difference or a noticeable one? Also, I know my concerns will never be answered properly for a while. Still, many thanks for your opinion.
QUOTE(stringfellow @ Dec 29 2006, 03:40 PM)
Regarding the HD-DVD thing, if you're concerned of the what-ifs, better dont buy. I dont want to turn this thread into another HD-DVD vs Bluray wittiness-fanboy thread that made me close the other thread, but frankly speaking HD-DVD will not go down easily. The interactiveness and features alone will secure its place in the format war, not to mention the overzealous fanboys. Me? I'd rather savor both sides of the plate, not just one.
There is a reason of course, on why MS includes King Kong with the HD-DVD bundle in the States, this movie is the best title to use to showcase the power of HD-DVD. For reference titles on both Bluray and HD-DVD, head to www.avsforum.com Go to the forum sections appropirate to the HD-DVD/Bluray and look at their Tier system for ranking the different movie titles released. So far,
for HD-DVD, King Kong and The Hulk are the top tiered reference titles to showcase HD-DVD. Tokyo Drift is the title to get to showcase U-Control on HD-DVD.Bear in mind that the HD-DVD addon does not have optical out, meaning for serious audiophiles there will be audio quality degradation since it goes through the USB connection to the 360. Even the optical connection of 360p has limitation, only able to process Dolby Digital Plus at the moment, while waiting for MS to realse software patches to enable DTS processing for it. This reported by the forum member "amir" in the AVSforum, as this member is with MS.
I agree with you in that both Bluray and HD DVD should be savoured for its strengths and offerings. I never intended to be a "fanboy" of sorts, based only on my purchasing decision. But my concern will always be of merit; if support for either party becomes lopsided, then the original reason to own the particular format is moot. Thanks a lot for your feedback on the matter.
QUOTE(goodspeed @ Dec 29 2006, 04:11 PM)
if got hdtv then you will definately notice the difference..
if don't have and using normal TV like me (non-LCD or non-plasma)... then i see no point in getting one..

Yes, I do own a HDTV. In fact, the reason I'm thinking of getting HD DVD has something to do with me getting used to HD resolutions. Case in point? Many people like to say that DOA4 looks about the same as DOA3. So I fired up the old DOA3, and... I have to say, I can't go back to lower resolutions. There's something about the visual clarity that have to be seen to be appreciated.
Thanks everyone for your valuable feedback! Guess I'll be coming back here sometime soon with news of the HD DVD drive. Now, to look for HD DVD titles...