ahaa....
meaning...the onli choice is BOLEH...
cuz the question is....NILAI YANG BOLEH DITERAP OLEH PUISI....
if u didnt write BOLEH oso boliao one....

It's over anyway...
cheer up everyone...

Regarding the patut and harus..I just follow the question..

BIO MONDAY THEN MERDEKA!!!!!

Tanggal 4....bulan 12..2006..

merdeka merdeka tetaplah merdeka

i just read a few pages back u guys were complaining about the moral essay..what mistake did u guys make?

nilai yang BOLEH diterapkan oleh puisi

apparently if you didn't write BOLEH

your screwed

on a 2nd thought i think i did wrote boleh *runs*

owh i didint do that question cause i didint know what how to put it into words..so i did the other 2 cause 1st one got kerajaan malaysia and second one got pak zin dan rakan-rakannya..

IF say the question asked "apakah yang boleh dibuat ali?"

then you asnwer "ali BOLEH makan" then its correct

but if u write "ALI HARUS MENCUCI" then its wrong

the harus makes all the diff

dont really get it..how bout the pak zin esei what if i write "nilai yang harus diamalkan oleh pak zin dan rakan-rakannya ialah kesederhanaan"?

follow kehendak soalan apparently

if they state apakah nilai yang HARUS

then u have to stick with harus =/

i forgot how the question was..hopefully im correct.fingers crossed

oh well, how if i din wrote such thing ??

my essay start like :

XX Nilai rasional. bla bla bla and goes on

This post has been edited by LittleLinnet: Dec 1 2006, 04:51 PM

Geez..are they not done at tricking us already?? There's nothing but unpopular questions and tricky crap this year!

Lucky for me I wrote all three essays.

We don't have to worry about the moral answer,because there are many answer is possible for da question. As long as u feel that the nilai is suitable for the situation,then should be okay.

ur supposed to answer in ayat penuh mah

laa.. u guys blom merdeka lg ke? ksian...
i'm in sience/account class so my last paper was chemistry.
you guys go study bio!!!!

that is crap ok

what i answered is answered, what i wrote is written
now i am asking what is gonna happen lol

this is called spam

wht is gonna happen is mayb u get 1/10 marks.. cause the moral marking scheme is very strict

I personally think the "boleh" doesn't make sense. Let's think about it.

Antara nilai yang boleh diterapkan daripada puisi tersebut ialah nilai rasional. Kita boleh berfikir berdasarkan alasan dan bukti yang nyata. Kita boleh...[insert huraian here]. Kita juga boleh mengambil tindakan berdasarkan pertimbangan yang wajar. Kita boleh...[insert huraian here].

Doesn't all the "boleh" just sound wrong? Sure, you "CAN" [boleh] learn some values from the poem, but you "SHOULD", not "CAN" follow the lessons which you've learned from the values. So basically your essay will end up sounding something like this: I can learn value A from the poem. The value says that I can do this. According to the value I have learned, I can do that.

While a more logical essay would probably sound like this: I can learn value A from the poem. According to the value, I should do this. I should do that.

Get what I mean?

I'm pretty sure that harus/patut/etc restriction rule is in place, but "boleh" as one of those words in the list just sounds wrong.

This post has been edited by Glassy: Dec 1 2006, 05:31 PM

i taught we should put in harus n patut...