QUOTE(cherroy @ Apr 2 2009, 01:00 PM)
GST is good if you look at this side.
But if GST is implemented, I can guarantee inflation will be skyrocketing, which in the end of the day, it is the poor one suffer the most.
At current structure, lower income group doesn't pay the tax and rich one pay more. But if GST is implemented and reduce the personal income tax, it becomes poor and rich one also need to pay tax (even though only you buy more then pay more, but poor one origin doesn't need to pay, has to pay now).
The GST implementation has been suspended indefinitely until gov decide later, primary reason, it will cause a shock inflation effect as mentioned.
GST is a type of 'Consumption Tax' whereas "Income Tax' is a tax on 'Income'.
The bad thing about income tax is that it does not encourage savings. As long as you make a certain amount of income, you have to pay a certain amount of tax, regardless of whether you spend them or not.
Consumption Tax, on the other hand, encourages savings in a way that you only pay the tax when you spend. If you do not spend, then you are not taxed. We already have some consumption tax in Malaysia, eg. hotels, high-end restaurants, parking, gambling, etc. You pay mainly 5% tax when you use these services. If you don't use, then you don't pay. It's fair, right ?
The good thing about consumption tax is based on the fact that the rich usually spend more, then they are taxed more, compared to the poor.
In countries that has GST, the income tax rate will have to be low to balance it out. You cannot have a high tax on income and then tax again when people spend, that will be bad for the people.