QUOTE(MacDaNife @ Oct 28 2006, 08:43 PM)
On another point: I would not discount the Zune just yet. Microsoft is at its core a Software company (unlike Apple who has always been at its core a Hardware with an integral Software company). The first real foray MS has into the hardware business is the XBox and that is now into its second hardware revision.
If the XBox is anything to go by, Microsoft has an established track record at making a hit consumer device. They have the resources and staying power. In any case, monopoly by any company is NOT a good thing.
I agree with the added convenience of using a well-designed content delivery system like Apple's iTunes. I'm sure everyone here has downloaded horribly misnamed music files with inconsistent bitrates and the like - that's the reason why I switched over to BitTorrent after my initial reliance on Napster, KaZaA, WinMX, and Shareaza. Having on-demand access to fresh content is a must - I think both Apple's iTunes and Microsoft's Marketplace accomplish this successfully.
What I'm more concerned about is what Apple plans to do to further differentiate its product from the Microsoft Zune. Speculation has run for years about the emergence of WiFi in the iPod, yet nothing has materialized thus far. Maybe we'll finally see it in this generation of the iPod. The big question, though - what is it to be used for?
News about Apple's patent filings suggests strongly that we'll finally see a touch-screen vPod, and I recall reading an article suggesting that Apple would introduce WiFi as a means of purchasing content through the iTunes Store through the iPod. Hmm!
QUOTE(hydrogen @ Oct 29 2006, 07:15 AM)
Furthermore, illegal downloading of music is so widely available and blatantly easy. Restrictions on the new iPods will only serve to fuel frustrations of its users, and not really affect illegally obtaining music.
I'm sure Apple (and all other MP3-player producers) is well aware that many iPod owners don't pay for their music. There exists a fine balance between accepting music piracy and condoning it. I'm wondering just how far Apple will open up the iPod if WiFi is indeed added to the spec sheet. The two extremes here: Allowing open trading of all unsigned content vs. restricting trading to Fairplay-signed content with playback and time constraints. Or skip WiFi altogether, leaving Microsoft to laud its Zune for successful implementation of WiFi.