QUOTE(cherroy @ Sep 5 2015, 11:10 AM)
You buy raw materials in USD, and sell and export in USD, whether the exchange rate of USD/RM fall to whatever level has no impact on the cost.
It has nothing to do with USD cash in hand or not, credit facilities, LC, hedging or whatever finance facilities are easily available.
The issue has no impact what we were discussing previously about, MNCs are not greatly affected by the exchange rate, in fact they are beneficiers.
Factories that closing down because of downsizing, business volume died down, profit margin died down or shift to a much cheaper wages countries.
Large corporate doing export, and MNCs have not cashflow problem generally,
GST claiming back is not time consuming. Our company have filed GST every months since the onset of GST, little issues.
The issues mentioned are only pronounced in SMEs, as until now I still see many still not quite understand how the GST works.
Yes, there is a hiccup in the claiming process for some. But I believe it soon will be ironed out.
GST is not a cost to business, the cashflow issue due to claiming process is not a bigger deal for large corporation, but SME may be hit harder.
SME that ceased operation because of razor sharp thin profit margin, and with GST implementation just induce them to close down, not because of GST issue alone, because GST is not a cost to business except for those non-GST registered.
Yes, business is not good out there, in fact our company suffer 30~40% drop in revenue compared to previous year, but this slowdown is worldwide currently, there is not much can be done, to be fair, although can be better.
If you buy raw materials with USD in-hand, and then sell and collect USD and in-turn park it somewhere in the USD, you don't have a problem. If you do not convert and perform your acct'g treatments in RM, you don't have a problem. It is all about the acct'g treatment.
I have SME clients doing this, and they are not as badly affected as the others who delve into the RM.
Hence MNCs will not be affected so much in terms of raw material costing.
GST issue IS AN ISSUE, though not directly, but the indirect effects should not be ignored too. If the execution of the GST taxation process is not good, it will bring hardships to good operations which, as claimed (though I wouldn't concur is limited to this) have 'razor-thin profit margins'. Why should a strong cashflow company prosper and a company with lower cashflow capability suffer because of the GST ? If an SME operation is able to sell at a lower profit margin so that entities down the 'food-chain' can enjoy better cost savings, and finally benefitting the end-consumer, it will be good for the end-consumers. Furthermore, the percentage of GST charged against the end-consumer will be lower because of the lower pricing.
If the problem here is an entity which is not paying taxes or evading taxes, hence not respecting the law and the courts, that would be a problem. But if the problem resides with the tax-collection authorities, then it is not fair to eliminate the smaller guy which is trying to follow the rule-of-law.
There is a hiccup in the claiming process..., but it will soon be ironed out ? How long will it take to iron out, when we have a few tsunamis hitting us now in the face along with this GST thing ? Do we, then blame it on the timing of these issues coming together at the same time ? No,... blaming won't help the smaller guy who will be wiped out before the problems external to him are erased.
If we are going to go with the concept put up here, then many SMEs should close down, and MNCs alone will survive and prosper. Perhaps a few 'stronger' SMEs might survive too, and they will have the luxury of raising prices. We, as the end-consumers, will bear the brunt of this effect in the end. Perhaps we are already feeling that now, with the rising prices of 'everything' around us.
If your MNC (with good cashflow and dealing in the USD alone in and out) can suffer a revenue drop of approx. 30%-40% in these times, how do you think an SME (with razor-thin margins and not able to deal entirely in the USD) will be affected ? Is it fair to let the little guy go ? Is it fair for the end-consumers to pay more for products and services later on ?
Is it fair to let only MNCs survive ?
All should be given a chance to survive.