QUOTE(whateva2k @ Jan 23 2015, 02:15 PM)
Hi all,
I need guidance here.
I have an upgrade target for my Vigor P9, eventually having either 18 or 20 speed.
But I like to do it in stages, first changing the RD shifter, then RD, then adding 2nd chainring and FD.
While upgrading in stages, I also don't want to change the upgraded component as I go. For example, I want to change my RD shifter first, so I need to make sure the RD shifter I get will be compatible with all future upgrades of other components.
Therefore, I have questions as follows:
1. Will a 10 speed shifter, say a Shimano Tiagra 10 speed shifter works with my current 9 speed Neos RD and 9 speed cassette?
2. Will a 10 speed RD & shifter, say a Tiagra 10 speed shifter and RD works with my current 9 speed cassette?
Thanks in advance!

I can understand the reason for upgrading in stages as I did the same. It is easier to actually get a high spec bike slowly as what I wanted will cost 6k if I choose a Dahon with the specs.
Sadly, you can't upgrade the way you mentioned as Tiagra 10 speed shifters are not compatible with a 9 speed RD. If you want you have to get the whole front modded and then the whole rear modded at once.
So I can suggest going for 9 speed.
That way. You first buy a 9 speed shifter, bear in mind, SRAM and Shimano are not compatible. Also road bikes and mtb has different shifting index length. If you choose Tiagra or 760 shifters, these are road bike flat bar shifters so mtb RDS are not suitable. But if you choose mtb shifters, you can use road bike RDs as long as your cassette don't exceed 30 teeth as roadie RDs has short cage.
So start with say 9 speed Alivio or Accera shifter. That way you can still use the Neos RD and then later change the RD. Then later add a chain ring to the front. This way if you ride hilly area, just shift the chain manually by hand to the smaller chain ring. Then later the FD and adapter and finally you have 18 speed which is sufficient for Fraser's Hill if you are on mtb set up at the rear. The front is always roadie 53/39 set up.