Japanese Buffet

Saisaki (WIsma UOA) _ Bad review good review (from tripadvisor) 

Zipangu (Shangri-la) _ same also (from tripadvisor)

the review is very mix ...all say food and service is getting from good to bad

Tried once at Shogun 1Utama   - nice.. 3 years ago ( not going back here because need it to be at kl in time to go watch sunset from Wisma KH )
Second Shogun Sunway  - Might as well eat steamboat buffet at the sunway roadside. terrible..even the basic sashimi and sushi is not there

Now my dilemma... my bf having birthday coming up this weekend and he enjoys great food ( i think he is more picky    )
And i wanna treat him to good food... well im picking the japanese and he is happy as long is good food..sometimes he order new dishes to try but if food is bad he rather not finish them.

SO which is actually good in term of food..
IS A BETTER CHOICE....both prices is not that cheap but will be nice not to choice wrong place to eat..

any recommendation?