Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 LCD Monitor Thread v13.

views
     
toffy
post May 11 2022, 09:21 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
Hi all.

I am looking for a 2nd monitor, being used as a horizontal monitor.
27 inch.
WQHD (2560 x 1440).
Not for gaming.

Ideally, it should come with a stand that allows me to pivot or rotate it 90 degrees because I don't want to get a separate VESA stand or arm.

Is it possible to get it at around RM1,000?

I saw some Dell monitors that meet this requirement but it is around RM1,300, which I think is pricey for such specifications because if I top it up another RM200-300, I could get a 4k monitor.

Any suggestions?

Thanks.

toffy
post May 12 2022, 05:58 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(Andrewtst @ May 11 2022, 09:34 PM)
A good monitor not means resolution only. It depends on many condition. Also 4K not means it is good. I find QHD is basically the best for Windows with size not more than 27" (34" and 49" is in this range just wider).
*
Agree. I like your advice.
I understand that you don't go for value monitors. So I guess you also consider HDR, brightness, number of ports, ports version etc?
For my case, i am looking for a budget monitor of that specs. Since there are many factors, I had to prioritize certain specs (the ones I listed) as my basic requirements and also for comparison, if there are extra bells and whistles.
toffy
post Jul 3 2022, 02:12 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
Hi.

I am not using the latest GPU card but based on my research, it could run 2 units of QuadHD (2560 X 1440) monitors and possibly one more widescreen monitor.

I am planning to use them purely for productivity and office apps only. No gaming at all (maybe light games or old games, but gaming usage is not important here).

I do not have the QuadHD monitors yet but plan to buy them.

Should I future-proof my new monitors for new few years by buying 2 units of 4K monitors, instead of QuadHD ones?

To minimize the load on my GPU, I will downscale the 4K monitors to QuadHD resolution, until I upgrade my GPU in the future.
I read that downscaling from 4K to 1080 is a better ratio at 4:1, while downscaling from 4K to 1440p is almost 2.5:1.

If I downscale it this way, will it cause more work to the GPU and also make the picture quality more blocky/unsharp?

Or just get the QuadHD ones to run at their native resolution?
toffy
post Jul 3 2022, 12:32 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(xxboxx @ Jul 3 2022, 11:17 AM)
You didn't state what are the monitor size you aiming for. 27" if 1080p doesn't look as bad as 32" in 1080p.

Your hardware won't able to run 2 monitor at 4k? Using laptop?
Also can consider getting ultra wide instead of 2 16:9 monitor.
If getting 2 monitors, better buy from shop and check on the spot for how the color looks side by side. Running dual monitor and seeing different color is annoying for me, if you don't mind then it's ok.
*
Aiming for 27 inches.

Ya, laptop.
I think can run both but I am saving the juice for a 3rd monitor, which is an existing ultrawide.


toffy
post Jul 3 2022, 09:32 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(xxboxx @ Jul 3 2022, 11:17 AM)
You didn't state what are the monitor size you aiming for. 27" if 1080p doesn't look as bad as 32" in 1080p.

Your hardware won't able to run 2 monitor at 4k? Using laptop?
Also can consider getting ultra wide instead of 2 16:9 monitor.
If getting 2 monitors, better buy from shop and check on the spot for how the color looks side by side. Running dual monitor and seeing different color is annoying for me, if you don't mind then it's ok.
*
Thanks for your feedback.
For the sake of completion, on top of my previous reply, I need to give one more input.

I do agree that it is better to check the new 2 monitors side-by-side at a physical shop selling them. Hope the colour issues happen rarely? At the moment, I am trying to save by buying online. I guess I have to risk it a bit, haha.




QUOTE(Andrewtst @ Jul 3 2022, 02:22 AM)
LCD should only use in native resolution.

It is not advice use in not native resolution as it will be not sharp especially text.

You will not notice in video and may not obvious in games but it isĀ  obvious in text.

Running downscale will not cause more heavy load in your GPU as it is running at the resolution you choose.

If 4K resolution is something you prefer, suggest only get the monitor after upgrading your GPU. 4K display still got more improvement to go and it is not that value yet, when the time you upgrading your GPU, they probably had more choices, better and much value for 4K monitor.
*
Thanks for the insights.

In short, you are saying that it is best to use native resolutions and to hold on to the 4k monitors for now?
And to get the 4k ones once I have upgraded my GPU?
I don't have immediate plans to upgrade the GPU yet.

With the above said, I was thinking that 4k monitors are much cheaper now and are slightly more expensive than 1440p monitors of the same size for a similar config (27 inches).
So my initial thought was to future-proof it, just in case I am getting a new PC/laptop end of the year (with RTX 30 series) or early next year, making me ready by having my 'new' 4k monitors. Otherwise, my 'new' 1440p may become obsolete?

The choice of whether to upgrade to the soon-to-be-released RTX 40 series as my GPU, will be another story.

Your feedback about the current 4k monitors being not 'matured' yet and not of value yet, is indeed good feedback. I am considering these seriously.



QUOTE(Andrewtst @ Jul 3 2022, 02:54 PM)
Laptop? Laptop GPU is fixed and cannot upgrade.

Normally older Laptop only have 1 HDMI and 1 VGA, which means 2 monitor maximum and one of it cannot more than 1080p (VGA connection).

Even newer laptop also normally came with 1 HDMI and may also came with 1 extra DP. In this case also 2 monitor maximum.

Unless the 3rd monitor is connected via USB-C but older laptop not came with USB-C and only USB 2.1 which required converter and it is not enough bandwidth for 4K monitor, unless you accept 30hz which is very lagging even in Windows usage only (not gaming).
Since it is laptop, just bring to shop to test it out.

In additional, here is the common XX:9 aspect ratio screen resolution, size and type.
user posted image
*
Yes, fully agree. The GPU of a laptop cannot be upgraded. Not for typical end-users unless one is a hardcore person or professional that tinkers with the soldering and has access to mobile components to break the supported factory configuration... a super-risky thing that shouldn't be done. Better to upgrade those on a desktop one instead.

Another way is to use a eGPU, right? But that's more expensive and the return of investment may not be worth it because of the limited bandwidth of the connection (maybe TB4 or TB5 connectivity may address it) and the expensive eGPU case.

When I mentioned upgrading my GPU, I meant to say either I buy a new lappy or a desktop.

The laptop in discussion is a 2018 version with GTX 1060 6GB that comes with a mini dual-mode DP, an HDMI 2.0 port, and a USB Type-C Thunderbolt that provides DP output. I hope that means it can connect to 3 external monitors via 1 HDMI port and 2 DPs? Both the DPs are of version 1.2.

I am going for a minimum of 60Hz for all my external monitors.

To clarify, I have an existing 34-inch 3440X1440 UW as the main external monitor. I am thinking of getting 2 units of 27-inch 1440p as 2nd and 3rd external monitors (portrait) for productivity reasons (or is this overkill?). Then it dawned on me that, maybe I should get 4k monitors instead of 1440p monitors for future-proofing. Hence, the question came about.

The current UW has a PPI of around 108. The corresponding 1440p monitors have similar PPI, at around 108. I prefer such parity.
If I am going to get 4k monitors instead, then I have to downscale it to maintain that parity. Hence that question also.

This post has been edited by toffy: Jul 3 2022, 09:42 PM
toffy
post Jul 4 2022, 11:26 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(tungfunglaw @ May 15 2022, 02:51 PM)
Dell will always drop the price of S2721DS(rm979)/SE2723DS(rm839?) alternate week. keep an eye on that.

i bought S2721DS(rm979) + 4% discount + rm18.99 cashback on end of april.

but lead-time is around 1month at the moment, given a call by dell that ETA is end of MAY.

if can wait, can check them out.
*
Thanks so much for sharing this.

Have you received your S2721DS? I read that the stand is wobbly.
Other than that, any feedback on your usage of it?
toffy
post Jul 5 2022, 10:21 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(xxboxx @ Jul 3 2022, 11:21 PM)
If both same model then likely both look the same. Usually issue when different model or old monitor pair with new.

I think your laptop can run 3 external monitor. But probably limited to 4K 60hz due to DP v1.2
*
Sounds good! Thanks!
From what I read, it seems to be certified at DP 1.2 but ready for 1.3 and 1.4. Not exactly sure what this means.



QUOTE(BeastX @ Jul 4 2022, 01:42 PM)
Here where many people (including you).... gets wrong/do not understand...2D display resolution is always mainly depends on the display output(s)... both your DP 1.4 outputs (1060 supports 1.4) can support 4k@120hz and the HDMI 2.0: 4k@60Hz... You can have three 4k monitors@60Hz with no issues

All usb-c with DP out.... will output the supported DP of the GPU, in your case DP 1.4... you'll need a "cheap" converted for this (RM50 or less)... This DP by-pass output uses the same wires as the TB signals (only one [of the 2] will work at a time); taking a pure TB signal and you can split the TB signal to 2 or 3 monitor outputs that requires an "expensive" TB dock (RM500+ to 1k).

Most monitors with usb-c in are taking the DP signal and not the TB signal.... <<< Apart from Apple there maybe one other monitor that takes a TB signal input...

Example: I've a mini-PC with an intel 8265U that could run three 4k@60Hz outputs through its iGPU...
*
Thanks for elaborating on this.
Mine is a laptop, so it is a mobile GPU. Since it is GTX 1060, then it is all the 'same' in terms of supporting DP up to version 1.4? Or the mobile GPU is different from the desktop version?
Only one of the 2 will work... do you mean it is either DP or TB that will work at a time? I guess there is no reason to configure and split the TB signal to support 2 or more monitors via an expensive dock, unless I don't have enough ports to support 3 monitors in total.

Wow! You must have a powerful iGPU. I thought only dGPU can do that.



QUOTE(Andrewtst @ Jul 4 2022, 03:30 PM)
Additional information, since you got one 3440x1440 Ultrawide. It is better get another 2 in 1440p for consistency size with your current Ultrawide Monitor.

1440p won't obsolete and it will still be main steam.
*
I agree with the consistency suggestion.
If I am going to get a 4k, I can downscale it to 1440p to make it almost consistent but that carries the non-native concerns you mentioned earlier such as sharpness, non-value 4k monitors etc

Can 1440p be still mainstream for the next 4 years ah? Me curious.

This post has been edited by toffy: Jul 5 2022, 10:22 PM
toffy
post Jul 5 2022, 11:46 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(tungfunglaw @ Jul 5 2022, 10:59 PM)
Yes it's wobbly if u touch it, it will wobble too if u type aggressively given your desk is not solid wood  laugh.gif

the 'estate' gained is not too much if compares to 23/24" 1080p, not as awesome as 2k 32" (for work) but tbh, 27" really is the best size.

height adjustment is easy but rotating is a pain in the @ss, only can rotate if your desk is totally 'clean' or clutter-less.

dell display manager also not fully auto set the brightness/contrast, need to adjust manually, the presets only change the color scheme. dunno why my previous S2340 presets will auto set the brightness/contrast accordingly.
*
Lol.
Most folks don't type aggressively unless they are angry, are testing the wobble or one of the keys is stuck stubbornly.
Hope it won't wobble at all during a 'normal' situation?

Ya, 27 inch seems like a sweet spot for now.

Do you mean you had stuff under your monitor before you rotated it to portrait mode?

The display issue is a bummer. Do you need to adjust it every time you switch it on?

Other than the above, I assume it is a budget monitor that is worth its price, given minimum bells and whistles?
toffy
post Jul 6 2022, 12:50 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(tungfunglaw @ Jul 6 2022, 12:01 AM)
normal typing is not causing any serious wobbling to me  laugh.gif

u cannot put any speaker on the side, need to take the hdmi cable length into consideration too. if u wish to rotate it & to rotate, u need to max the height, tilt it max, only can rotate.  rclxub.gif

the display manager really sux, cant change settings on the fly. need to adjust it everytime u change from night to day, re-adjust to watch movie & gaming.

yes, given the price & specs, value for money. if going for SE model, even more cheaper  laugh.gif
*
Oh ok. Got it.
Just have to live with the issues then. Minor ones.
Which SE model? SE2723DS?
toffy
post Jul 6 2022, 08:37 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(BeastX @ Jul 6 2022, 09:15 AM)
1. Either by bios update or just software drivers your 1060 should be able to utilise DP 1.4 bandwidth... regardless you'll still have DP.12 which is perfectly fine for 4k@60hz...

2. Yes with a DP-out usb-c port... You either utilse DP or TB signal (+ one USB 2.1)....and here's another nugget: DP signal can be split to multiple displays too, using a MST hub.

Example: Displays 4 and 3 (3440x1440) and 2 (2560x1440) are all running using a single DP 1.4-out.... all running at 120Hz @native res. (if not mistaken)
user posted image

3. No it's a basic grade iGPU... not even Iris Pro... but (again) you missed the point: 2D display-out support depends solely on the output supported... NOT on how powerful the GPU or iGPU is.

4. Nvidia consumer GPU has a software limit on display-out supported to only 4 displays.....AMD support up to 6... My picture example above: I have enough ports to push up to 8 displays... but NVidia limited it to 4...
*
1.
Thanks. I am going try this!

2.
Is MST hub worth it? Is there any difference in terms of bandwidth of throughput, using 2 DP ports (parallel?) for 1 display each, vs 1 DP port that split into 2 display (serial?) via the MST hub?

3.
May I know what the '2D' in 2D display-out means? 2 dimensions or something else?

4.
Why do they want to limit it to 4?
toffy
post Jul 6 2022, 08:39 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(tungfunglaw @ Jul 6 2022, 08:35 PM)
yup, SE2723DS model.
*
Any major difference between this model and S2721DS? Or just the pivot capability and different base stand?
toffy
post Jul 6 2022, 10:48 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(tungfunglaw @ Jul 6 2022, 08:46 PM)
nope, only minus pivot thingy & speakers. i've made a comparison on dell websites.

https://www.dell.com/en-my/shop/compare?ocs...0-axfz,210-beex

still can adjust height.
*
Oh ok.

The speakers are not that good I heard.

I guess if we want the pivot function, we have to choose the more expensive of the two, like what you did.
Otherwise, we will have to buy a new monitor arm or reuse an existing monitor arm, to have portrait mode for the cheaper version of the monitor.
I don't want to damage my table, so I prefer the pivot stand but I know the arm is more elegant.
toffy
post Aug 3 2022, 01:09 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
QUOTE(BeastX @ Jul 7 2022, 11:25 AM)
2. not needed if you don't intend to go beyond 4 displays

3. Display-output that does not involve processing and displaying 3D accelerated games...

4. So people would buy their Quadro line... that supports 8 display-out (if not mistaken)...
*
Thanks! This is enlightening.
toffy
post Sep 29 2022, 07:14 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
Deleted.

This post has been edited by toffy: Oct 22 2022, 10:50 PM
toffy
post Sep 11 2023, 09:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
182 posts

Joined: Aug 2017
<deleted>

Found the answer. Yay!

This post has been edited by toffy: Sep 15 2023, 12:29 AM

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0478sec    1.15    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 3rd December 2025 - 05:56 AM