QUOTE(Rotuham @ Oct 3 2013, 03:49 AM)
if you compare with what kenny and roy did then BR is a massive success.all our best performers this season have been BR's buys.Toure,mignolet,sturridge.
Who are our poor performers this season? Gerrard,lucas,henderson.None of whom BR bought.
Getting suarez to stay itself was a big success.
Never in recent times has a liverpool manager been able to stop a star player from leaving.
Rafa couldnt stop owen or alonso leaving,roy couldn't stop mascherano leaving and kenny couldn't stop torres leaving.
I don't see how BR has been any less successful than Rafa or Houllier in the transfer market. Notable signings were Daniel Agger, Xabi Alonso, Martin Skrtel, Glen Johnson, Javier Mascherano, Fernando Torres, Lucas, Dirk Kuyt and Pepe Reina. On the flip side of the coin were the likes of Robbie Keane, Fernando Morientes, Josemi, Antonio Nunez, Jermaine Pennant, Sebastian Leto, Andrea Dossena, Andriy Voronin, Phillip Degen, Albert Riera, Alberto Aquilani, Milan Jovanovic and Ryan Babel. To be fair, some came on a free transfer but my point is there were a fair share of flops as well. I think it's the same with any manager at any club.
As you quite rightly put though, I think BR and FSG played a massive part in Suarez staying. Rafa on the other hand pissed Alonso off and one wonders what would have been had Xabi stayed? Having said that this isn't an attack on any manager, it is to point out that almost every manager will have more failed or average signings that successful ones. Fact.