QUOTE(sphiroth @ Jul 30 2013, 09:54 AM)
But then, it make a new gundam recognizable. I means that even at first glance, people can realized, 'hey, its new gundam', not transformers, SRW etc. Which is good for marketing. Its good for manufacturing also.
Sometimes paying homage to old model can be good also, such as Porsche 911. Looks almost the same since its first launch until today, and there even a 'greatest hit version' which they bash all the best feature on all 911 in one car. Porsche enthusiast also dislike newer 911 when Porsche decided to use newer electric power steering to replace the traditional hydraulic version.
Just my 2 cent

u dun need to slap on old design together to make it recognizable. What classified a gundam is just the head; v fin, mohawk, side vents, mouth piece, two-eyes, any combination of the 2 is enuf for ppl to recognize it. There is no reason to reuse 90% of the wing and weapon design, there is no reason to make the shoulder, backpack, chest, etc so similar. Abit here and there fine u can say its just homage, but doing it so much so often then its just plain lazy.
Exia for instance is unique, so different then conventional gundam that it doesn't look anything like previous incarnation to the point ppl begin to hate it at first but as time goes by ppl accept it, loved it even. If Okawara did it just once or twice sure u can say its homage, but the entire seed and destiny is just 1 big bunch of reuse design slap on together. Wing another of his creation is pretty much the same deal as well, dragon fangs that shoot fire, geez where have i seen it b4 i wonder?
no doubt okawara is a pioneer and a genius but he has drop his balls more often then not as of late. Whether he had reached his creative ceiling or turn lazy is besides the point, Bandai needs to use more ppl like izubuchi to mix things up and im glad 00 went with that route.
take ur porcshe for example, if every car out there look like it it would be a dreary world. We need ferrari and lambo and pagani to spice things up.