Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 LYN Kia Cerato Owners CLub V1, 1.6 : Rm99,888, 2.0 : Rm118,888

views
     
vaniss
post Apr 8 2015, 04:17 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Nov 2012


Hi there guys, i have some questions to ask bout the car.
Because i try to let my parents to buy this car(K3 1.6) for me instead of the honda city 1.5V.
But they refuse me because of the reason below, i hope anyone can really find out the answer for me as a real user/ dealer.(compare to the honda city)
1. Is it have a big different on the 2nd hand value compare to city?
2. Is it harder to buy spare part or expensive?
3. Is it more valuable? depends on performance,comfortable,handling,fuel consumption.
4. Is it have any problem? eg. gearbox problem, air-con problem etc.
5. How is the feeling of the seats, will it be not confortable or very hot after shine by the sun for few hours?

This post has been edited by vaniss: Apr 8 2015, 05:31 AM
vaniss
post Apr 9 2015, 03:20 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Nov 2012


QUOTE(madcow1 @ Apr 9 2015, 02:22 PM)
parent money, so let them choose lor ...
*
They let me to choose, but in their opinion japanese car value is always far higher than kimchi's car. So i need some information to support my selection.
vaniss
post Apr 10 2015, 12:14 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Nov 2012


QUOTE(madcow1 @ Apr 9 2015, 03:52 PM)
nobody know 2nd hand value tomorrow la bro .....

if you go to 2nd hand car shop now,there wont be two same year car or same condition car there to compare.

if scare this and that ,buy japanese is the safest wat ..... that what malaysian thought .... stay inside the home don't come out at all oso safe wat ...

who know you buntut itchy wana change car after 2-3 years ?

easy to get spare part or not ? I feel this is one of the stupid thing in Malaysian mind .... got money, got spare parts la ....

cerato back light cost RM4k++ to replace ... the front windscreen cost RM2k+ to replace .. Forte power steering cost RM5k++ to fix ..... got money or not ?
*
QUOTE(perror @ Apr 9 2015, 06:21 PM)
Hope this helps. Answered point based to make it easier for you to relate to the question:

1) Resale value is fairly subjective. A 1 year old K3 is going for about 85k. So that's about a 10K+ depreciation a year if you look at a purchase price of around 95K+. I'm not sure what's the price of a 1 year old city or civic though

2) This is something we have to accept. Spare parts wise, it can be a bit pricy. Mainly because pretty much everything in the car is new and hence the pool of shared parts is small. Unlike a Vios that shares a 10 year old powermill and gearbox with it's older siblings, which will likely have a larger pool of shared parts. That being said, there are some things that Toyota charges more with regards to spares. So, yes some parts can be pricy, but time will tell

3) Pretty happy with my car relative to the price I paid back then. It is quite comfortable and spacious. Handling wise is ok, not fantastic. Fuel consumption for me is quite good. Note that I compared a K3 to a city as well back then and the K3 is a much better drive. Can't compare B-segment cars to C-segment.

4) I've had gearbox and engine issues. The former has been sorted with the replacement of a switch and the engine oil leak has not really resurfaced since

5) My 1.6 K3 had been reupholstered in leather, so in the hot sun, it can get pretty hot, but not overwhelmingly hot. Get a good tint and you should be fine. Never really had the issue of the seats burning any parts of my body yet.
*
QUOTE(Chester77 @ Apr 9 2015, 08:00 PM)
To me these two cars are both good enough. Standing on yr parent's shoes, of course further consideration is needed, not to mention is not a few hundred ringgit toy. 2nd hand value, spare parts issues is like what perror said, it all depends on market and users.

I would think jap cars have more 2nd hand value due to it's build and lasting. So if kimchi car have equalalent build that could last for 15-20 years i would say the value sure will be as good as jap cars (I drove a 18years nissan sentra with the interior still very firmly attach)

Spare parts wise, is important as well as it depends on who will be paying when the car needs a fix brows.gif , if you are to bare the responsibility of your own car after handed to you then i think you could have them less worry about this later issue.

Else i think best to take your parents to a test drive together and let them feel the car and value  smile.gif Since it's the K3 VS City, i could say the K3 value will stand out  brows.gif  (C vs B segment of course lo)

Handling, comfort, safety for K3 i give 4 and half stars, Kx just 3and half out of 5. FC i think city might have a slight advantage due to kerb weight. 

Other issue out of the above i would think it's just merely personal preferrrence and instint of "going for the safe side" decisions.

Here to say, my own thinking K3 VS City, K3 wins. Kx VS City (THIS a tough one) i might go for City whistling.gif . But i still like my Kx so far tongue.gif  thumbup.gif
*
Thanks guys biggrin.gif
I think i will bring my parents to test drive both cars first and then i'll explain to them bout the resale value and compair them, but i remember the new city's gearbox is upgraded from the old got problem 7shift gearbox right?
Btw, did u guys know the 3years cerato free part repair service is it real?

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0411sec    0.43    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 30th November 2025 - 12:49 PM